Analytic discrete self-similar solutions of Einstein–Klein–Gordon at large 𝑫 \bm{D}
Christian Ecker, Florian Ecker, Daniel Grumiller · 2026
Read Analytic discrete self-similar solutions of Einstein–Klein–Gordon at large 𝑫 \bm{D} by Christian Ecker, Florian Ecker, Daniel Grumiller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14358.txt.
Introduction
Christian Ecker, Florian Ecker, and Daniel Grumiller solve a gravity problem in closed form in this 2026 paper. Their topic is critical gravitational collapse, the borderline case where matter is just strong enough to form a black hole. Discretely self-similar solutions govern that borderline. Since Choptuik's pioneering work, those solutions were known only from numerical runs.
The team constructs an infinite family of such solutions in analytic form. The system is the Einstein-massless-Klein-Gordon system, gravity plus a light scalar field. Their tool is the large-D expansion, which treats the number of space dimensions as large. Readers get exact formulas where the field long had only computer output.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christian Ecker, Florian Ecker, Daniel Grumiller |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14358
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Analytic discrete self-similar solutions of Einstein–Klein–Gordon at large 𝑫 \bm{D} Preprint: TUW-25-03 Christian Ecker, Florian Ecker, Daniel Grumiller Abstract Discretely self-similar solutions govern critical gravitational collapse and have been known only numerically since Choptuik’s pioneering work. We construct, in closed analytic form, an infinite family of such solutions of the Einstein-massless-Klein–Gordon system using the large- D D expansion. We characterize their structure and compare them with numerical critical solutions at finite D D , identifying both universal features and distinctly large- D D behavior. I Introduction Black hole formation is a dramatic physical process that is hard to describe using only paper and pencil. Even imposing spherical symmetry and taking Einstein gravity with only a minimally coupled scalar field does not simplify the resulting PDEs sufficiently to permit analytic solutions in closed form Christodoulou:1986zr ; Christodoulou:1986du ; Christodoulou:1987vu ; Goldwirth:1987nu . Choptuik constructed numerically the first solutions that can be arbitrarily close to the threshold of black hole formation Choptuik:1993jv and discovered that they exhibit discrete self-similarity (DSS). The symmetry enhancement of the critical solution resembles the emergent conformal symmetry observed in physical systems at a second-order phase transition, see e.g. Koike:1995jm ; Gundlach:2002sx ; Gundlach:2007gc for comparisons between critical collapse and other physical systems. A related property is the existence of a self-similar horizon (SSH), i.e., a null hypersurface where the lattice vector \partial_{\tau} associated with DSS, \tau\to\tau+\Delta with echoing period \Delta , becomes null. The SSH is an ingoing null hypersurface and terminates in the center in a naked singularity. Emanating from the latter is an outgoing Cauchy horizon. See Fig. 1 for a sketch of the past patch of a critical solution with DSS. This means one can interpret the critical solution as (conformal to) a spacetime crystal where the lattice vector \partial_{\tau} is timelike in the region between center and the SSH (called past region), spacelike between the SSH and the Cauchy horizon (called outer region), and lightlike on the SSH. Figure 1: Illustration of the past patch of the Choptuik spacetime with DSS. The closer one moves towards the top, the more rapidly the Ricci scalar oscillates until the singularity is reached. The inset zooms into one of the fundamental domains to highlight the Ricci contours, i.e., the magnitude of the Ricci scalar is bigger in the center and smaller at the SSH. This emergent discrete symmetry of the critical solution might, in principle, help to find it in closed form. Nevertheless, so far, the best one can do is to numerically construct the critical solution directly by imposing DSS as an input Gundlach:1995kd ; Gundlach:1996eg ; Martin-Garcia:2003xgm . Since Einstein gravity has no dimensionless small parameter, there seems to be no obvious way to improve the situation. However, if we allow deviations of the dimension D from four to arbitrarily large values, we can use 1/D as a small dimensionless parameter Emparan:2013moa . While it has been suggested in the past to exploit the large- D expansion to understand critical collapse Emparan:2013xia ; Rozali:2018yrv ; Emparan:2020inr , so far, the critical DSS solution seemed out of reach. Numerically, going to large D is problematic because radial gradients get steeper with increasing dimension Sorkin:2005vz ; Bland:2005kk . This numerical drawback has been turned into an advantage in the past to get analytical expressions for large- D observables Emparan:2013moa ; Emparan:2014cia ; Emparan:2015gva ; Emparan:2015hwa ; Emparan:2015rva ; Emparan:2020inr . Our main goal is to show that the same is true for DSS solutions. In the present work, we explicitly construct an infinite family of DSS solutions of spherically symmetric Einstein gravity in D spacetime dimensions, minimally coupled to a massless scalar field \psi . By construction, these solutions turn out to be regular between the center and the SSH and have a naked singularity in the center at the future endpoint of the SSH, just like for Choptuik’s critical solution. We confront these solutions with numerical data to highlight the similarities and differences and show how to systematically improve features of the leading-order (LO) solutions by including next-to-leading-order (NLO) and next-to-next-to-leading-order (NNLO) corrections. II Field equations Generalizing Choptuik’s Eqs. (3)-(5) in Choptuik:1993jv to arbitrary spacetime dimensions D>3 yields \displaystyle\frac{\partial_{r}a}{a} \displaystyle=\frac{(D-3)\big(1-a^{2}\big)}{2r}+\frac{r}{2(D-2)}\,\big(\hat{\Pi}^{2}+\hat{\Phi}^{2}\big) (1a) \displaystyle\frac{\partial_{r}\alpha}{\alpha} \displaystyle=\frac{\partial_{r}a}{a}+\frac{(D-3)\big(a^{2}-1\big)}{r} (1b) \displaystyle\partial_{t}\hat{\Phi} \displaystyle=\partial_{r}\Big(\frac{\alpha}{a}\,\hat{\Pi}\Big)\qquad\partial_{t}\hat{\Pi}=\frac{1}{r^{D-2}}\,\partial_{r}\Big(r^{D-2}\,\frac{\alpha}{a}\,\hat{\Phi}\Big) (1c) where the D -dimensional metric \extdm\!{s}^{2}=-\alpha^{2}(t,r)\extdm\!{t}^{2}+a^{2}(t,r)\extdm\!{r}^{2}+r^{2}\extdm\!^{2}\Omega_{S^{D-2}} is spherically symmetric, i.e., \extdm\!^{2}\Omega_{S^{D-2}} is the metric of the round unit S^{D-2} . The quantities \hat{\Phi}=\partial_{r}\psi , \hat{\Pi}=\frac{a}{\alpha}\,\partial_{t}\psi are suitably chosen first derivatives of the scalar field \psi . (We use units c=8\pi G=1 , which differs from Choptuik’s choice c=G=1 .) The coordinate system above is inconvenient for our purposes. Using the coordinate transformation Martin-Garcia:2003xgm \tau=-\ln(-t) , x=-r/t together with the redefinitions 1 1 1 The idea to rescale a variable like a^{2}-1 by a linear factor in the dimension in a large- D context is due to Rozali and Way Rozali:2018yrv . However, they also rescaled one of the coordinates, which makes the SSH inaccessible. Therefore, we do not follow their scaling regime but establish here a different one that allows a regular SSH in the large- D expansion. \Omega=\frac{(D-3)(a^{2}-1)}{x^{2}}\qquad\;f=\frac{\alpha}{a}\;\qquad\epsilon=\frac{1}{D-1} (2) the field equations above read \displaystyle x\partial_{x}\Omega+x^{2}\Omega^{2} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{\epsilon}\,\big((1-2\epsilon)\,\Pi^{2}-\Omega\big)+ (3a) \displaystyle\quad\;\Omega\,\big(\Pi^{2}x^{2}+x^{4}\,\Psi^{2}\big)+\Big(\frac{1}{\epsilon}-2\Big)\,x^{2}\,\Psi^{2} \displaystyle\frac{1}{x}\,\partial_{x}\ln f \displaystyle=\Omega (3b) \displaystyle\big(\partial_{\tau}+x\,\partial_{x}\big)\,\Pi \displaystyle=f\,x\,\partial_{x}\Psi+f\Big(\frac{1}{\epsilon}+x^{2}\,\Omega\Big)\,\Psi-\Pi (3c) \displaystyle\big(\partial_{\tau}+x\,\partial_{x}\big)\,\Psi \displaystyle=f\,\frac{1}{x}\,\partial_{x}\Pi+f\,\Omega\,\Pi-2\Psi (3d) where we introduced the first-order matter variables \Pi=\sqrt{\frac{\epsilon}{1-\epsilon}}\frac{1}{f}\big(\partial_{\tau}+x\partial_{x}\big)\psi\qquad\;\Psi=\sqrt{\frac{\epsilon}{1-\epsilon}}\frac{1}{x}\partial_{x}\psi. (4) The DSS property means that the four free functions that characterize our solutions, \Omega,f,\Pi,\Psi , are periodic in \tau with some (echoing) period \Delta . The D -dimensional metric in the gauge above is given by \extdm\!s^{2}=e^{-2\tau}\Big(1+\frac{\epsilon\,x^{2}\,\Omega}{1-2\epsilon}\Big)\big((x^{2}-f^{2})\extdm\!\tau^{2}-2x\extdm\!\tau\extdm\!x+\extdm\!x^{2}\big)\\ +e^{-2\tau}\,x^{2}\,\extdm\!\Omega^{2}_{S^{D-2}}\,. (5) yielding a Ricci scalar R=-(\frac{1}{\epsilon}+1)e^{2\tau}(\Pi^{2}-x^{2}\Psi^{2})a^{-2} that grows like \frac{1}{\epsilon} for large dimensions. Assuming the SSH conditions f(\tau,x=1)=1 , f\geq x\geq 0 , any solution to ( 3 ) must obey the inequalities 0\leq\Omega<\infty\qquad\qquad 0\leq x\leq f\leq 1\,. (6) Our goal is to solve the equations ( 3 ) in an expansion of the dimension parameter 0<\epsilon\ll 1 . III Leading order solution at large \bm{D} We expand all fields as Taylor series in \epsilon , e.g., \Omega=\Omega_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}+\epsilon\Omega_{\textrm{\tiny{NLO}}}+\epsilon^{2}\Omega_{\textrm{\tiny{NNLO}}}+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{3}) and analogously for the SSH function f and the matter function \Pi . By contrast, as explained below, the other matter function \Psi starts at one order higher, \Psi=\epsilon\Psi_{\textrm{\tiny{LO}}}+\epsilon^{2}\Psi_{\textrm{\tiny{NLO}}}+\epsilon^{3}\Psi_{\textrm{\tiny{NNLO}}}+\mathcal{O}(\epsilon^{4}) . All coefficients of \Omega are determined algebraically from ( 3a ) in terms of \Pi . This is so because, to LO, the terms proportional to 1/\epsilon in the first line on the right-hand side of ( 3a ) must cancel, i.e., \Omega_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}=\Pi^{2}_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}\,. (7) This mechanism persists for all subleading orders. Moreover, \Psi is determined without integration from \Pi and f using ( 3c ). Similarly to before, the reason for this is the 1/\epsilon coefficient on the right-hand side, yielding \Psi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}=\frac{D_{1}\,\Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}}{f_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}}\qquad\qquad D_{n}:=\partial_{\tau}+x\partial_{x}+n\,. (8) Again, this mechanism persists for all subleading orders. We only have two remaining PDEs that need to be solved. While in some general coordinate system these are still coupled, non-linear PDEs and hard to solve, in the gauge ( 5 ) they decouple at each order. Indeed, ( 3d ) to LO simplifies to a non-linear first-order PDE for the matter function \Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}} , \partial_{x}\Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}=-x\,\Omega_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}\,\Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}=-x\,\Pi^{3}_{\textrm{\tiny LO}} (9) solved by \Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}=\frac{\beta(\tau)}{\sqrt{1+\beta^{2}(\tau)\,x^{2}}} (10) with an arbitrary integration function \beta(\tau) . We have adapted this integration function such that \Pi_{\textrm{\tiny LO}}