Human Values in a Single Sentence: Moral Presence, Hierarchies, and Transformer Ensembles on the Schwartz Continuum Journal: Information Processing Management
Víctor Yeste, Paolo Rosso · 2026
Read Human Values in a Single Sentence: Moral Presence, Hierarchies, and Transformer Ensembles on the Schwartz Continuum Journal: Information Processing Management by Víctor Yeste, Paolo Rosso (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14172.txt.
Introduction
Víctor Yeste and Paolo Rosso detect human values in single sentences at scale in 2026. They study the nineteen human values in the refined Schwartz continuum. Their corpus holds about seventy-four thousand English sentences from news and political manifestos. The corpus is the ValueEval'24 set, annotated for value presence.
Each sentence yields a binary moral-presence label and a nineteen-way multi-label task. Severe class imbalance makes the task hard, since rare values appear seldom. Transformer ensembles tackle the detection in their work. Sentence-level value maps could track moral themes in public debate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Víctor Yeste, Paolo Rosso |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14172
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Human Values in a Single Sentence: Moral Presence, Hierarchies, and Transformer Ensembles on the Schwartz Continuum Journal: Information Processing Management Víctor Yeste, Paolo Rosso Abstract We study sentence-level detection of the 19 human values in the refined Schwartz continuum in about 74k English sentences from news and political manifestos (ValueEval’24 corpus). Each sentence is annotated with value presence, yielding a binary moral-presence label and a 19-way multi-label task under severe class imbalance. First, we show that moral presence is learnable from single sentences: a DeBERTa-base classifier attains positive-class F 1 = 0.74 F_{1}=0.74 with calibrated thresholds. Second, we compare direct multi-label value detectors with presence-gated hierarchies under a single 8 GB GPU budget. Under matched compute, presence gating does not improve over direct prediction, indicating that gate recall becomes a bottleneck. Third, we investigate lightweight auxiliary signals—short-range context, LIWC-22 and moral lexica, and topic features—and small ensembles. Our best supervised configuration, a soft-voting ensemble of DeBERTa-based models enriched with such signals, reaches macro- F 1 = 0.332 F_{1}=0.332 on the 19 values, improving over the best previous English-only baseline on this corpus (macro- F 1 ≈ 0.28 F_{1}\approx 0.28 ). We additionally benchmark 7–9B instruction-tuned LLMs (Gemma 2 9B, Llama 3.1 8B, Mistral 8B, Qwen 2.5 7B) in zero-/few-shot and QLoRA setups, and find that they lag behind the supervised ensemble under the same hardware constraint. Overall, our results provide empirical guidance for building compute-efficient, value-aware NLP models under realistic GPU budgets. 1 Introduction Human values are central to explaining and predicting attitudes, decisions, and behaviour in individuals and groups ( 49 ; 24 ) . Among the most influential frameworks, Schwartz’s theory of basic human values models values as motivational goals arranged in a continuous circular structure, where adjacent values express compatible motivations and opposing values express conflicts ( 55 ; 53 ) . The refined model distinguishes 19 basic values (e.g., Self-direction: thought , Security: societal , Universalism: concern ), each linked to underlying needs and motivational emphases, and has been widely used in social psychology and political science to study value structure, value change, and cross-cultural invariance ( 3 ; 10 ) . Figure 1 illustrates this circular motivational continuum. Figure 1: Circular motivational continuum of the 19 refined basic values in Schwartz’s theory. Neighbouring values are motivationally compatible, whereas values on opposite sides of the circle tend to be in conflict. Adapted from 53 . In parallel, work in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and computational social science has begun to infer moral or value-related content directly from text. Value-aware and morality-aware NLP has been applied to political communication ( 69 ) , news and media analysis ( 15 ) , stance detection ( 2 ) , and social discussions ( 43 ) , and recent surveys systematise this emerging area and its benchmarking challenges ( 48 ) . Much of this research has drawn on Moral Foundations Theory (MFT) ( 22 ; 19 ) , which proposes a small set of intuitive moral foundations and associated resources such as the Moral Foundations Questionnaire ( 20 ) and the Moral Foundations Dictionary and its extensions ( 26 ; 25 ) . These resources support supervised and lexicon-based models that detect whether a text invokes, for example, harm, fairness, or loyalty ( 47 ; 64 ) . Using Schwartz’s value theory in NLP is more recent and less explored than MFT, but it is particularly suitable for political and ideological language. Schwartz values have a long measurement tradition in survey research, for example with the Portrait Values Questionnaire (PVQ) ( 54 ) , strong evidence of cross-cultural robustness ( 11 ; 56 ) , and well-documented links to political preferences and issue positions ( 6 ; 50 ) . Recent projects have begun to operationalise the refined 19-value continuum for text, most prominently in the ValuesML collection and the ValueEval shared tasks ( 38 ; 30 ) . These initiatives provide sentence- or segment-level annotations of value presence and thus make it possible to study fine-grained value detection with modern NLP models. Detecting values at the sentence level, however, remains difficult. First, value cues in naturalistic text are often subtle or implicit, especially in technocratic or institutional language, and may only become clear when surrounding context is considered ( 34 ) . Second, the distribution of values is highly skewed: values such as Security: societal or Conformity: rules are common in political and news texts, whereas others such as Humility or Hedonism are rare ( 38 ) . This leads to severe class imbalance and makes macro-averaged metrics particularly demanding. Third, models must distinguish between neighbouring values on the continuum (e.g., Benevolence vs. Universalism ) and between different facets of similar themes (e.g., Power: dominance vs. Power: resources ). This requires fine-grained semantic distinctions that go beyond generic sentiment or topic information ( 53 ) . Modern transformer-based encoders and instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) provide strong tools for such tasks. Contextual encoders such as BERT ( 13 ) , RoBERTa ( 36 ) , and DeBERTa ( 23 ) have been successfully applied to moral foundation detection, political framing, and stance classification ( 63 ; 77 ) . Instruction-tuned LLMs can perform zero- or few-shot classification from natural-language label descriptions ( 40 ; 68 ; 18 ) and can also generate text under moral or value-related constraints, for example in humour generation conditioned on moral judgments ( 71 ) . At the same time, recent evaluations suggest that medium-sized encoder models, when carefully fine-tuned and combined with simple ensembles, can match or surpass much larger LLMs on structured multi-label problems under realistic compute constraints ( 35 ) . 1.1 Research objectives In this paper, we study sentence-level identification of the 19 values in the refined Schwartz continuum as a concrete formulation of human value detection. We focus on the English, machine-translated release of the dataset used in the ValueEval’24 shared task ( 38 ) , where each sentence from news articles or political manifestos is annotated for the presence of each value and for whether the value is portrayed as attained or constrained. Following prior work on value detection ( 30 ; 38 ) , we collapse the stance information into a single binary label per value and additionally define a moral presence variable indicating whether any value is annotated as present in a sentence. This yields two related prediction problems: (i) binary detection of moral presence and (ii) multi-label detection of the 19 values. Our overarching goal is to understand how well current transformer-based and instruction-tuned language models can detect refined Schwartz values at the sentence level under strong class imbalance and an 8 GB single-GPU constraint. We structure this goal into four research questions (RQ1–RQ4): RQ1. Can we reliably detect the presence of moral content in single sentences? RQ2. Does a moral-presence gate (hierarchical) help over a direct multi-label value detector on the 19-way Schwartz value detection task, under matched compute? RQ3. Which lightweight auxiliary signals help under an 8 GB GPU constraint? RQ4. How do supervised DeBERTa models compare to instruction-tuned open LLMs (7–9B parameters) and their ensembles? We make three main contributions. First, we operationalise a sentence-level moral presence task on the ValueEval’24