Trade Relationships During and After a Crisis

Alejandra Martinez · 2026

Read Trade Relationships During and After a Crisis by Alejandra Martinez (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14150.txt.

Introduction

Alejandra Martinez studies how firms adjust when trade ties break for a short time in 2026. International trade relationships often run through relational contracts, built on trust. Martinez exploits an extreme, plausibly exogenous weather shock as a natural test. The shock hit during the 2010-11 La Niña season in Colombia.

Heavy weather restricted Colombian flower exporters' access to cargo terminals. Transaction-level data from Colombian-U.S. trade tracks the response. The study asks how firms adjust during and after such a crisis. Flower exports are time-critical, so the case shows stress in sharp relief.

Catalog record

CREATORAlejandra Martinez
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14150

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Trade Relationships During and After a Crisis Thanks: I am grateful to Isabelle Mejean, Dennis Novy, Carlo Perroni, and Christine Braun for their support. I am also grateful for comments by Isabela Manelici, Marta Santamaria, Wiji Arulampalam, James Fenske, Luis Candelaria, and Gavin Hassall as well as seminar participants at the Royal Economic Society Conference 2023, GEP-CEPR Postgraduate Conference, European Trade Study Group 2023, the 2023 Oxford Development Economics Workshop,2023 CEP-Warwick Junior Trade Workshop, the II Workshop on International Trends in Economic Research, and 2023 Junior workshop day at KCL. The author is affiliated with the University of Nottingham School of Economics and the Centre of Inclusive Trade Policy (CITP). Email address: [email protected]. Alejandra Martinez Abstract I study how firms adjust to temporary disruptions in international trade relationships organized through relational contracts. I exploit an extreme, plausibly exogenous weather shock during the 2010–11 La Niña season that restricted Colombian flower exporters’ access to cargo terminals. Using transaction-level data from the Colombian–U.S. flower trade, I show that importers with less-exposed supplier portfolios are less likely to terminate disrupted relationships, instead tolerating shipment delays. In contrast, firms facing greater exposure experience higher partner turnover and are more likely to exit the market, with exit accounting for a substantial share of relationship separations. These findings demonstrate that idiosyncratic shocks to buyer–seller relationships can propagate into persistent changes in firms’ trading portfolios. Keywords : La Niña, Supply Chains, International Contracts, Weather Shocks JEL classification : F18, L14, O19, Q54 1 Introduction In less-than-perfect product markets, firms rely on buyer--seller relational contracts. 1 1 1 Relational contracts are defined by 5 as “informal agreements sustained by the value of future relationships.” These relationships are inherently vulnerable to temporary disruptions that interfere with production or delivery. As extreme weather events become more frequent and severe, supply chains are increasingly exposed to such disruptions, including temporary road closures, transport bottlenecks, and interruptions to logistics infrastructure. Even when shocks are local and transitory, they can substantially disrupt established production networks and generate aggregate effects. 2 2 2 24 show how idiosyncratic shocks propagate through production networks. 21 and 41 document how firm-level shocks contribute to aggregate volatility. Understanding how supply chain disruptions affect buyer–seller relationships is particularly important in international settings, where contracts are imperfectly enforceable and firms depend heavily on repeated interactions. Existing work documents output losses among firms linked to regions affected by disruptions ( 8 ; 16 ) . Much less is known about how firms adjust their portfolios of buyer–seller relationships in response. These adjustments matter because buyer–seller relationships form the backbone of trade networks and shape the structure of world trade. The accumulation of relationships drives firm growth, while relationship destruction can precipitate market exit ( 49 ) . Buyer–seller matches also affect productivity through sorting and influence firms’ ability to expand their trading networks through network effects ( 13 ; 43 ) . This is the first paper to identify shocks at the level of individual buyer–seller links and shows how disruptions to specific relationships propagate within firms to affect their overall relationship portfolios and market participation. I study Colombian flower exporters and their U.S. importers during the extreme 2010–11 La Niña episode, which disrupted road access to cargo terminals used by exporters. The Colombian flower industry exemplifies relational trade under limited contract enforceability: exporters access international markets almost exclusively through established direct relationships, and forming new connections is costly. The setting therefore provides a sharp environment in which to study relationship portfolio decisions when firms have few outside options. Importantly, flower production itself was largely unaffected by flooding at production sites, and the industry relies minimally on upstream inputs, allowing me to isolate disruptions operating through transport access rather than input shortages. This enables a clean comparison between buyer–seller relationships exposed to disrupted routes and those that were not. I construct a novel dataset linking road disruptions to exporter routes to cargo terminals for all buyer--seller pairs, using firm-to-firm Colombian customs data from 2007 to 2019. Exploiting variation in which roads were affected by the La Niña floods, I define relationship-level exposure based on whether a given buyer--seller link relied on disrupted transport routes. For importers, exposure varies within the firm because buyers source from suppliers located in different regions, which use different road networks. This design allows me to identify shocks at the level of individual buyer--seller relationships and to trace how disruptions to specific links transmit within firms to affect their broader relationship portfolios. 3 3 3 18 , 6 , 36 , and 27 study the reorganization of firm linkages using firm-level shocks, which precludes analysis of how disruptions to individual relationships propagate within firms. I estimate the effects of the La Niña disruption using an event-study design. To study relationship termination, I estimate linear probability models of relationship ending. Because terminations are infrequent at the monthly level, outcomes are aggregated to six-month periods when analyzing portfolio adjustments. I additionally examine short-run adjustment along other margins using monthly data at the 6-digit HS product level, including transaction incidence and traded quantities. I document distinct effects at the relationship and firm levels. At the relationship level, pooled specifications show no differential termination between exposed and non-exposed links. Within importers, however, exposure reduces relationship termination during the disruption: the probability of termination falls by 7 percentage points, a 53% decline relative to a baseline hazard of 0.13. Transactions along exposed relationships decline during the shock but recover once transport access is restored. At the firm level, exposure induces adjustment through exit and portfolio contraction, concentrated among highly connected buyers. Among importers with high pre-shock indegree, greater exposure increases relationship termination during the disruption, with effects that persist over time. These effects operate through firm exit: a one-standard-deviation increase in exposure raises the probability of importer exit by 10 percentage points, mechanically terminating all relationships, although exit occurs only during the shock period. High-indegree firms also experience a persistent decline in new relationship formation, leading to a contraction of supplier portfolios. In contrast, exposure has no effect on exit among low-indegree firms and only a small, marginally significant increase in relationship termination. In the final section, I present a simple framework to rationalize how shocks to individual buyer–seller relationships translate into firm-level portfolio adjustment. The key assumption is that the surplus from any relationship depends on firm profits across the entire portfolio. Road disruptions are modelled as shocks that simultaneously reduce deliveries across multiple relationships, consistent with the empirical setting. The framework delivers an ambiguous effect on relationship surplus. When multiple links are disrupted, firms’ outside options deteriorate, increasing the value of maintaining existing relationships. At the same time, reduced deliveries lower relationship-specific surplus, particularly when forming new relationships is costly. Which force dominates depends on the extent of exposure across the portfolio and the costs of reorganization. When replacing multiple relationships simultaneously is difficult, firms optimally retain disrupted links despite temporary delivery shortfalls. When relationship-specific surplus losses are sufficiently large, firms terminate relationships or exit. The framework highlights the interdependence of relationship-level decisions within firms and provides a rationale for persistent firm-level adjustment following relationship-level shocks. Contribution to the literature . This paper contributes to the literature on the propagation

Read the complete text