Remapping and navigation of an embedding space via error minimization: a fundamental organizational principle of cognition in natural and artificial systems
Benedikt Hartl, Léo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, Michael Levin · 2026
Read Remapping and navigation of an embedding space via error minimization: a fundamental organizational principle of cognition in natural and artificial systems by Benedikt Hartl, Léo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, Michael Levin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-14096.txt.
Introduction
Benedikt Hartl, Léo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, and Michael Levin seek a shared principle of cognition in 2026. The emerging field of diverse intelligence studies problem-solving across very unlike agents. Agents range from subcellular chemical networks to swarms of organisms. Evolved, engineered, and chimeric systems all fall in scope.
The team hypothesizes scale-invariant principles of decision-making across them. Their focus is remapping and navigation of an embedding space via error minimization. In plain terms, agents may think by moving through a mental map toward lower error. A shared principle could unite biology and AI research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Benedikt Hartl, Léo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, Michael Levin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 73 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-14096
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Remapping and navigation of an embedding space via error minimization: a fundamental organizational principle of cognition in natural and artificial systems Benedikt Hartl, Léo Pio-Lopez, Chris Fields, Michael Levin Abstract The emerging field of diverse intelligence seeks an integrated view of problem-solving in agents of very different provenance, composition, and substrates. From subcellular chemical networks to swarms of organisms, and across evolved, engineered, and chimeric systems, it is hypothesized that scale-invariant principles of decision-making can be discovered. We propose that cognition in both natural and synthetic systems can be characterized and understood by the interplay between two equally important invariants: (i) the remapping of embedding spaces, and (ii) the navigation within these spaces. Biological collectives, from single cells to entire organisms (and beyond), remap transcriptional, morphological, physiological, or 3D spaces to maintain homeostasis and regenerate structure, while navigating these spaces through distributed error correction. Modern Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, including transformers, diffusion models, and neural cellular automata enact analogous processes by remapping data into latent embeddings and refining them iteratively through contextualization. We argue that this dual principle – remapping and navigation of embedding spaces via iterative error minimization – constitutes a substrate-independent invariant of cognition. Recognizing this shared mechanism not only illuminates deep parallels between living systems and artificial models, but also provides a unifying framework for engineering adaptive intelligence across scales. Keywords: Evolution, Development, Intelligence, Active Inference, Navigation Policy, Nested Embedding Spaces Running Title: Remapping and Navigating Embedding Space 1 Introduction Conventional behavioral science tends to focus on animals with brains and nervous systems. Three main lines of thought suggest that this might be too narrow, as schematically illustrated in Figure 1 . First, an operationalist stance suggests that cognitive terms are interaction protocols, not claims about the essential nature of specific substrates such as brains 118 , 51 , 50 , 139 , 2 , 172 , 140 , 94 , 144 , 167 , 9 , 87 . In other words, an assessment of cognition within any system is, operationally, just a testable hypothesis about whether, for example, the system is most amenable to techniques that rewire its hardware, reset its homeostatic goals, train it via rewards and punishments, or convince it via cogent reasons and psychological strategies. From that perspective, a system’s position on the spectrum of persuadability 118 is an empirical question. This operational view facilitates the application of tools from the behavioral scientist’s toolbox 2 to a wide range of complex, simple, and even non-living systems to see which formal interaction model offers the most effective prediction and control. The second line of thought points out that the mechanisms implementing intelligence in the brain are evolutionarily homologous to those in the non-neural living substrates. Ion channels, electrical synapses, synaptic machinery, and the algorithms they embody are evolutionarily ancient, and ubiquitous, raising the question of when precisely they became fodder for cognitive tasks (albeit in unconventional contexts), in the long history prior to the formation of brains 94 . Finally, third, developmental biology reveals that familiar bioelectric networks play key roles in coordinating cellular activities toward specific anatomical endpoints, long before nerves appear during morphogenesis, again pointing to the need for models of scaling of competencies from those of the single blastomere to those of an adult 116 ; examples are illustrated in Figure 1 (A). The emerging field of Diverse Intelligence 15 , 112 , 140 , 141 , 139 seeks to understand what all active agents have in common. In moving away from classic assumptions that brains, and a history of evolutionary trial-and-error for behavior in 3D space, are privileged substrates and origin stories for cognition, it seeks a unifying theory for agents of highly diverse composition and provenance 51 . Evolved, engineered, and hybrid systems at all scales of complexity are fodder for experiments in learning, problem-solving, and decision-making 49 , 50 . Progress in this field suggests that neuroscience is not about neurons – it’s about biophysical processes and mechanisms that operate as a kind of “cognitive glue”, binding competent subunits (e.g., cells) into collective intelligences that operate in spaces and with spatio-temporal goal horizons (cognitive light cones) much larger than those of their parts 120 . This research program has three unique key features. It is deeply interdisciplinary – revealing novel phenomena at the intersection of biology, computer science, materials science, and cognitive science. It is tractable – the tools of behavioral, computational, and cognitive neuroscience have now been applied far outside the brain and avail the modern worker with very effective tools with which to probe the primitive – or perhaps surprisingly sophisticated – minds of unconventional systems. And finally – it impacts a critical unmet need and knowledge gap: aspects of regenerative medicine, bioengineering, AI, and even fields such as ethics are being enriched by a novel understanding of the origin, scaling, and properties of unconventional embodied minds, such as cellular collectives, that can be coaxed to pursue alternative end-states 32 , 35 , 103 , 120 , 125 . This paper extends the Fields-Levin framework of cognition as competent navigation in arbitrary spaces 51 , 50 (see Figure 1 (B, C)) by proposing that intelligence is characterized by two equally important cognitive invariants: the creation and remapping of embedding spaces, and the navigation within these spaces in response to new contexts. More precisely, we define remapping in this paper as representing and/or updating new information acquired via experience into the internal latent representation formalized by the problem space (i.e., constantly refining a navigable embedding space) – a concept closely related to internal representations formed by world-models 69 , 33 . We argue that embedding spaces are not static and given structures but actively constructed representations that translate complex realities into navigable dimensions, as schematically illustrated by Figure 1 (D). By recognizing both processes as fundamental to cognition, we develop a more comprehensive substrate-independent framework for understanding intelligence across biological and artificial systems. We demonstrate the explanatory power of this dual framework through examples ranging from biological regeneration to AI systems, showing how the interplay between remapping (via embeddings) and navigation processes enables complex adaptive behaviors across diverse embodiments of distributed intelligences, agnostic to problem spaces, scale, or material composition. We begin by outlining navigation as an invariant of cognition, before turning to remapping, embeddings, and their manifestations in biology and AI. We conclude with a perspective on how these principles will foster the development of novel adaptable synthetic and chimeric collective intelligences. 2 Remapping and navigating arbitrary spaces as an invariant of cognition 2.1 Navigation in arbitrary spaces as an invariant of cognition William James, the pioneering psychologist, offered a goal-directed definition of intelligence: “Intelligence is a fixed goal with variable means of achieving it” 87 . It remains particularly prescient in the modern era of AI, where populations of software and physical agents are expanding. This definition also emphasizes that intelligence manifests as goal-directed behavior rather than any specific mechanism or embodiment. The cybernetic tradition, developed by Ashby 9 , Maturana and Varela 144 , and Pattee 167 , expanded this perspective by framing cognition in terms of information processing and self-regulation. Very recently, Fields and Levin expanded further this approach and framed cognition as