Modeling Perpetrators’ Fate-to-Fate Contagion in Public Mass Shootings In The United States Using Bivariate Hawkes Processes

Youness Diouane · 2026

Read Modeling Perpetrators’ Fate-to-Fate Contagion in Public Mass Shootings In The United States Using Bivariate Hawkes Processes by Youness Diouane (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-13501.txt.

Introduction

Youness Diouane models how a mass shooter's fate sways the fate of the next such shooter in the United States. The team uses data from 1966 to 2024. Each case is tagged by if the actor died at the scene or lived past the act.

Their tool is a bivariate Hawkes process. Such a process lets each past event lift the rate of like events to come. With two fates as two streams, the model can say if a death at the scene lifts the odds the next actor dies too. Such a fate to fate spread, if real, bears on press guides and threat work. The model gives that ask a firm form.

Catalog record

CREATORYouness Diouane
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-13501

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling Perpetrators’ Fate-to-Fate Contagion in Public Mass Shootings In The United States Using Bivariate Hawkes Processes Youness Diouane Abstract This study examines how the fate of a perpetrator in a public mass shooting influences the fate of subsequent perpetrators. Using data from 1966 to 2024, we classify incidents according to whether the perpetrator died at the scene or survived the attack. Using a bivariate Hawkes process, we quantify the cross-excitation effect, which is the triggering effect that each event type exerts on the other, i.e., ”die at the scene” → \rightarrow ”live” and ”live” → \rightarrow ”die at the scene”, as well as the self-excitation effects, i.e., ”die at the scene” → \rightarrow ”die at the scene” and ”live” → \rightarrow ”live”. Our results show that the strongest spillover was from ”live” incidents to ”die at the scene”, where we estimate that 0.34 (0.09, 0.80) of ”die at the scene” incidents are triggered by a prior event in which the offender survived the attack. This pathway also exhibits the longest estimated contagion timescale: approximately 20 days. In contrast, the reverse influence, that is, ”die at the scene” → \rightarrow ”live”, is not statistically significant, with the lower bound of its 95% confidence interval nearly equal to zero. We also find that ”die at the scene” events can only cause their own type, where 0.139 (0.01, 0.52) of such incidents are caused by previous ”die at the scene” events, with the shortest contagion timescale of roughly 20 hours. When we analyze the pre and post 2000 periods separately, we observe a clear shift in dynamics. Before the year 2000, cross-excitation effects were approximately symmetric, with about 0.1 (0.003, 0.3) of incidents of either type triggered by a single event of the other type, and contagion timescales of roughly 2.5 days in both directions. This symmetry disappears after 2000. In the post 2000 era, the strongest spillover runs from ”live” to ”die at the scene”, estimated at 0.228 (0.03, 0.55), with the longest contagion duration of about 4.3 days. The reverse effect is not statistically significant. Instead, as in the full-period analysis, ”die at the scene” events trigger only their own type, with an estimated effect of 0.044 (0.01, 0.09) and the shortest contagion timescale of about 16 hours. This mirrors the pattern found in the full 1966–2024 dataset, which suggests that the dynamics of public mass shootings in the United States are mainly driven by the post-2000 era. Introduction While public mass shootings are rare, their social impact is profound, prompting urgent calls for prevention. Amid ongoing research, a critical question has emerged: can the occurrence of one event influence the likelihood or characteristics of others, and if so, how? Exploring this question requires considering how reactions to these attacks - media coverage and public discourse – might contribute to patterns that are not immediately obvious. Our research seeks to illuminate whether and how the fate of offenders at the scene may play a role in shaping subsequent events, offering new insights into the dynamics of these signal crimes. Defined here as incidents in which four or more people (not including the offender) are shot and killed within 24 hours in a public setting and which are not attributable to underlying criminal activity or commonplace circumstances [ 20 ] , public mass shootings generate intense public concern and legislative interest [ 6 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 14 , 36 ] . Scholarly efforts to understand the phenomenon have ranged from creating offender typologies to researching specific antecedent behaviors and experiences (e.g., mental illness, masculinity norms), as well as life-course perspectives, all of which underpin the growing consensus that offenders do not just “snap,” but instead move over time along a “pathway to violence” [ 38 ] . Based in part on the enormous media and public attention given to these events, researchers have also begun to examine the possibility of a contagion effect [ 13 ] . Evidence of contagion has been found across various unrelated behaviors such as airplane hijacking [ 17 ] , smoking cessation [ 8 ] , and especially suicide [ 1 , 33 , 39 ] , and there is no theoretical or practical reason that it would not also be found in acts of public violence. Confirming a contagion effect in public mass shootings would be of great value to those entrusted with protecting public safety. Contagion theories have been developed since the late 19 th century across a variety of disciplines, with Bandura’s social learning theory proposing a cognitive framework through which attentive individuals learn aggression by observing the actions of others [ 3 ] . Bandura recognized that television and film broadcasts (and media attention in general) can serve as an effective transmission mechanism for aggressive behaviors (for a more complete discussion, see [ 18 ] ). And it is safe to assume that media attention would be the transmission mechanism for public mass shootings, as it is highly unlikely that any offender has personally observed a previous event [ 28 ] . Importantly, although all mass shootings receive significant media coverage, previous research has shown that public mass shootings receive far more coverage than non-public events (family mass shootings and mass shootings related to underlying criminal behavior), potentially making them particularly contagious [ 12 , 13 , 18 ] . Furthermore, the media attention directed to public mass shootings is overwhelmingly national, showing few regional differences, thus reducing the possibility of spatial effects of any contagion [ 13 ] . To date, contagion in public mass shooting has been understood in two ways. Copycatting or “specific contagion” occurs when an offender adopts a particular public mass shooter as a role model and attempts to carry out a similar act of violence [ 21 , 22 ] . The authors in [ 23 ] recently documented evidence that a subset of mass shooters engages in copycat assaults (including statements made by the offenders themselves and striking demographic and behavioral parallels between offenders and role models) and demonstrated the degree of similarity between model and copycat. Notably, they found that the majority (nearly 80%) of the offenders attacked more than a year after their role model with an average temporal gap of approximately eight years. In contrast, “general contagion” (also called “social contagion” [ 18 ] ) is more akin to the metaphor appropriated from epidemiology which describes how behaviors spread across groups of people, and contemplates a closer temporal connection between events than does copycatting. While it has been suggested that a more apt term may be “generalized imitation” in which individuals learn to perform behaviors that are like those observed or described (although not always enacting an exact copy of the role model’s behavior) [ 28 ] , the concept is the same – the occurrence of an event makes it more likely that a similar event will occur in the near future. Support for general contagion of mass shootings is mixed. Some studies suggest a short-term effect, while others find no significant impact. [ 42 ] examined both school shootings and mass killings using a self-excitation model, finding that incidents are temporally contagious for approximately two weeks. Replications

Read the complete text