Quantum Qualifiers for Neural Network Model Selection in Hadronic Physics

D. Keller · 2026

Read Quantum Qualifiers for Neural Network Model Selection in Hadronic Physics by D. Keller (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-13463.txt.

Introduction

D. Keller sorts when quantum nets beat classic nets in hadron physics by a score called a quantum qualifier. Quantum machine learning builds fast. The hard ask now is not how to build such nets. It is where they help in real use and where they do not.

Keller's frame gives tools to call that line in data led hadron tasks. The qualifier is a number based mark of quantum gain. It guides the pick of classic or quantum net for each task. For physics teams with thin quantum time, a sound pick tool saves runs on tasks a classic net would win.

Catalog record

CREATORD. Keller
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-13463

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Qualifiers for Neural Network Model Selection in Hadronic Physics D. Keller Abstract As quantum machine-learning architectures mature, a central challenge is no longer their construction, but identifying the regimes in which they offer practical advantages over classical approaches. In this work, we introduce a framework for addressing this question in data-driven hadronic physics problems by developing diagnostic tools—centered on a quantitative quantum qualifier—that guide model selection between classical and quantum deep neural networks based on intrinsic properties of the data. Using controlled classification and regression studies, we show how relative model performance follows systematic trends in complexity, noise, and dimensionality, and how these trends can be distilled into a predictive criterion. We then demonstrate the utility of this approach through an application to Compton form factor extraction from deeply virtual Compton scattering, where the quantum qualifier identifies kinematic regimes favorable to quantum models. Together, these results establish a principled framework for deploying quantum machine-learning tools in precision hadronic physics. Brandon B. Le 1 Introduction Quantum machine learning has opened new possibilities for data analysis in strongly correlated and information-rich physical systems, motivating growing interest in whether quantum models can offer practical advantages over classical approaches. In particular, quantum deep neural networks (QDNNs) employ parameterized quantum circuits as trainable models that operate in a Hilbert space and naturally encode complex correlations [ 4 , 7 ] . While the extent of quantum advantage in near-term applications remains an open question, QDNNs provide a flexible framework for exploring how quantum architectures may outperform classical deep neural networks (CDNNs) in challenging inverse problems and high-dimensional regression tasks. Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering (DVCS) offers a compelling setting in which to investigate these questions. As one of the most direct experimental probes of the three-dimensional structure of the nucleon, DVCS provides access to Generalized Parton Distributions (GPDs) through their convolution into Compton Form Factors (CFFs) [ 19 , 13 , 5 , 6 ] . Extracting CFFs from experimental data is a central inverse problem in hadronic physics, complicated by the coherent interference of DVCS and Bethe–Heitler amplitudes, limited kinematic coverage, and strong correlations among fit parameters. Classical deep learning has already shown promise in addressing these challenges [ 22 , 25 ] , making DVCS an ideal testbed for assessing the potential added value of quantum approaches. In this work, our primary focus is the development of practical tools for the systematic use of quantum deep neural networks and for determining, in advance, whether a CDNN or QDNN is better suited to a given extraction task. Central to this effort is the construction of a quantitative diagnostic we term the quantum qualifier , designed to guide model selection based on intrinsic properties of the data. The application to experimental DVCS measurements from Jefferson Lab is presented as a culminating case study, illustrating how these methodological developments can inform deployment and regime selection for CFF extractions. 2 Quantum Deep Neural Networks Quantum deep neural networks (QDNNs) incorporate elements of quantum mechanics into learning architectures, providing a computational paradigm fundamentally different from that of classical deep neural networks (CDNNs). In a CDNN, each layer performs a transformation of the form h=\sigma(Wx+b) , where W denotes the weight matrix, b is a bias vector, and \sigma represents a nonlinear activation function. By contrast, QDNNs implement quantum operations on qubits in place of these classical mappings. A complete quantum circuit is built from successive layers of parameterized unitary operators, interleaved with entangling gates that generate correlations among qubits. For a circuit composed of L layers, the resulting quantum state can be written as |\psi_{\text{final}}\rangle=U_{L}U_{L-1}\cdots U_{1}|0\rangle^{\otimes n} . A central component of any QDNN is the encoding of classical data into a quantum representation. Among the most widely used strategies is angle embedding, in which classical inputs are mapped to rotation angles of single-qubit gates. For an input feature x , this encoding is realized through the operation R_{x}(x)\ket{0}=e^{-ixX/2}\ket{0} . Following the quantum evolution, information is extracted through measurement. Classical outputs are obtained by evaluating expectation values of Hermitian observables, \langle O\rangle=\bra{\psi}O\ket{\psi} , which can subsequently be processed using conventional learning techniques. A typical QDNN architecture therefore comprises four key stages: data encoding, a sequence of parameterized unitary layers, entangling operations, and final measurement. QDNNs are appealing because they exploit the exponential structure of quantum state space, enabling compact representations of complex transformations [ 7 ] . A system of n qubits spans a Hilbert space of dimension 2^{n} , offering expressive power that can exceed the polynomial scaling typical of classical networks [ 28 ] . In addition, quantum entanglement and superposition provide natural mechanisms for modeling nontrivial correlations and parallel computational pathways [ 17 , 27 ] . Although a definitive demonstration of quantum advantage in deep learning remains open, accumulating evidence suggests that QDNNs may offer practical benefits for feature extraction and kernel-based learning in high-dimensional settings [ 34 , 14 , 1 ] . In the sections that follow, we examine systematic approaches for assessing the potential advantages of QDNNs over CDNNs in both classification and regression settings using well-defined performance metrics. Establishing robust evaluation tools is particularly important for applications in hadronic physics, where accurate and efficient information extraction is essential. 2.1 Quantum Classification (a) (b) Figure 1 : (a) Schematic of a CDNN for binary classification. Eight input features x_{i} are passed through a hidden layer of 8 ReLU neurons, followed by a single sigmoid output neuron \sigma(y) that returns the probability of belonging to Class 0 or Class 1. (b) Schematic of a QDNN for classification. Eight input qubits |q_{i}\rangle are processed by a layer of quantum perceptrons U^{(1)}_{i} . The final measurement M(|q_{\mathrm{out}}\rangle) determines the class label. To carry out a basic comparison between CDNN and QDNN classifiers, we construct a binary classification task using synthetically generated data from two distinct classes. Each data point is represented by a pair \{X,\,y\} , where X\in\mathbb{R}^{n} denotes the vector of input features and y\in\{0,1\} is the corresponding class label. In order to control the complexity of the learning problem, we consider two different types of datasets. The first, referred to as 1 function data, is generated by producing both classes from a single underlying function. The second, termed 3 function data, increases the level of complexity by generating the two classes from a combination of three distinct functions. Factor varied Change CDNN eff. QDNN eff. QDNN/CDNN ratio change Number of training pairs 500 pairs \rightarrow 50 pairs 0.6436 \rightarrow 0.4716 0.8745 \rightarrow 0.8116 27% Data complexity 1 func. data \rightarrow 3 func. data 0.8378 \rightarrow 0.6290 0.9678 \rightarrow 0.8704 20% Number of input features 8 feat. \to 16 feat. 0.6290 \rightarrow 0.5327 0.8704 \rightarrow 0.9359 27% Noise 0.2\sigma \rightarrow 0.05\sigma 0.7917 \rightarrow 0.8378 0.8704 \rightarrow 0.9678 5% Table 1 : Comparison of CDNN and QDNN classification efficiency for different data sets. Our default data set is 3 function data with 250 training pairs, 8 input features, and 0.05 noise; each row varies one of these factors while holding the rest at the default. The QDNN classification efficiency is higher than the CDNN classification efficiency for all datasets classified, indicating universal QDNN outperformance in this classification task. Fewer training pairs, higher data complexity,

Read the complete text