Toward Reliable Interpretations of Small Exoplanet Compositions: Comparisons and Considerations of Equations of State and Materials Used in Common Rocky Planet Models Journal: PSJ
Joseph G. Schulze, Natalie R. Hinkel, Wendy R. Panero, Cayman T. Unterborn · 2026
Read Toward Reliable Interpretations of Small Exoplanet Compositions: Comparisons and Considerations of Equations of State and Materials Used in Common Rocky Planet Models Journal: PSJ by Joseph G. Schulze, Natalie R. Hinkel, Wendy R. Panero, Cayman T. Unterborn (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-13176.txt.
Introduction
Joseph G. Schulze, Natalie R. Hinkel, Wendy R. Panero, and Cayman T. Unterborn warn care in how small far worlds are read. The bulk make up of a small world ties straight to how it was born. Yet no probe can see inside such a world. Its make up must be read from mass and size alone, through a model.
Those models lean on star make up and on laws for how stuff acts at high crush. The team sets models side by side and asks where the laws part ways. They urge care in how much trust a single model read gets. For world birth staff, the piece is a check list for sound claims about rocky worlds.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joseph G. Schulze, Natalie R. Hinkel, Wendy R. Panero, Cayman T. Unterborn |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 113 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-13176
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Toward Reliable Interpretations of Small Exoplanet Compositions: Comparisons and Considerations of Equations of State and Materials Used in Common Rocky Planet Models Journal: PSJ Joseph G. Schulze, Natalie R. Hinkel, Wendy R. Panero, Cayman T. Unterborn Abstract The bulk compositions of small planets ( R p < 2 R ⊕ R_{p}<2\mathrm{R}_{\oplus} ) are directly linked to their formation histories, making reliable compositional constraints imperative for testing models of planet formation and evolution. Because exoplanet interiors cannot be directly observed, their make-up must be inferred from mass–radius–composition models that link assumed stellar abundances to the direct observables: planetary mass and radius. There are a variety of such models in the literature, each adopting different equations of state (EOS) to describe the materials’ properties at depth and varying assumptions about the minerals present within the planets. These EOS+mineral suites provide the foundations for compositional inferences, but they have not yet been systematically compared. In this work, we review several suites, with a detailed description of the basic structure, mineral physics, and materials within standard small planet models. We show that EOS+mineral suites predict planet densities whose differences are comparable to current observational uncertainties, which present a challenge for robustly interpreting and classifying small planets. We apply a powerful small-planet characterization framework, which illustrates that variations among EOS+mineral suites lead to inconsistent conclusions for both individual planets and sample-level demographics. Our results demonstrate the need for more careful considerations of the materials and EOS used in mass-radius-composition models, especially given the current focus on finding and characterizing potentially habitable rocky planets. We conclude with recommendations for best practices so that future interpretations of small planets and their formation are accurate and consistent. I Introduction Small planets ( R_{p}<2\mathrm{R}_{\oplus} ) outside the Solar System (or exoplanets) are some of the most common planets in the galaxy ( 34 ; 70 ; 23 , e.g.,) . Drawing upon the Solar System’s rocky planets and icy moons, small exoplanets are thought to be made primarily from the major rock-building elements : Fe, Mg, and Si. Planets form from the same gas-dust disk as their host star(s). Leftover debris orbit around the new star, where the first materials to condense into solids from the disk are Ca- and Al-bearing minerals (e.g., corundum, Ca-silicate-perovskite, anorthite) followed by Fe-alloys and Mg-bearing silicates (e.g., forsterite, enstatite, and bridgmanite). In the inner regions of the gas-dust disk, where the temperatures are too high for H 2 O to solidify, planet-building materials are dominated by Fe and silicates. As planetesimals accrete enough material to gravitationally reshape, they compositionally differentiate with Fe settling to the center to form a core surrounded by a silicate mantle. While Ca and Al are incorporated into the mantle, they are less abundant than Si and Mg by a factor of \sim 10-16 within the disk ( 62 ) , and are therefore referred to as minor mantle elements. Together with O, the major rock-building elements make up 95 mol % of Earth ( 66 ) . As such, we expect planets forming in these inner, hot regions of the disk to be effectively volatile- and water-free rocky planets with Fe cores and silicate mantles. Some distance away from the host star, the temperatures of the gas-dust disk drop below the condensation temperature of H 2 O, commonly referred to as the snow-, frost-, or ice-line. Beyond the snow-line, a disk of solar composition is expected to have approximately equal amounts of H 2 O-ice and rocky materials by mass ( 62 ) , where small planets may have water mass fractions (WMF) of \sim 0.5 (or 50%), such as icy moons like Ganymede or Callisto ( 86 ; 61 , e.g.,) . With a structure of Fe-dominated core, silicate mantle, and outer hydrosphere, a small planet’s bulk density is determined primarily by two compositional parameters: the WMF and molar Fe/Mg ratio. The WMF is the relative amount of rocky materials (core+mantle) to H 2 O-ice and/or liquid water on the surface, with \mathrm{WMF}=0 corresponding to a H 2 O-free rocky planet. Increasing the WMF at a fixed planet mass trades rocky material for lower-density H 2 O, which results in a reduction in the average, or bulk, density of the planet. The Fe/Mg ratio is the primary control on the relative ratio of the denser Fe core to the less-dense silicate mantle. At a fixed planet mass, increasing the Fe/Mg ratio increases the mass ratio of core-to-mantle: the planet must trade less dense mantle material for more dense core material to maintain its mass leading to an increase in bulk planet density. The Fe-dominated cores of small planets may also be enriched in some amount of ‘light elements’ (compared to the molar mass of Fe) like H, C, O, Si, and S, but are soluble in Fe during differentiation. While the exact elements remain unknown, Earth’s core is estimated to have \sim 10 wt % light elements and Mars’ core, while less precisely known, is estimated to have \sim 20 wt % ( 66 ; 48 ; 52 ; 83 ; 12 , e.g.,) . Introduction of light elements into the core lowers the density of the core relative to pure Fe which, in turn, reduces the bulk density of the planet. Similarly, imperfect settling of Fe into the core and oxidation of Fe during planetary formation retains oxidized Fe in the mantle at the expense of Fe in the core. It’s estimated that the Earth has \sim 8 wt % FeO in its mantle ( 66 ) while Mars has \sim 18 wt % ( 107 ) . This results in competing effects: the relative mass of the core is reduced, implying a reduction in planet density, while the density of the mantle is increased, implying an increase in planet density. The exact composition of a small planet is inextricably linked to its formation history. The major rock-building elements condense into solids over a narrow temperature range ( 62 , \sim 1310-1350 K,) , meaning the bulk Fe/Mg ratios of rock-dominated planets should not be significantly altered relative to the Fe/Mg ratio of their host stars ( 95 ) . In other words, we expect a nearly 1:1 relationship between the relative molar ratios of moderately-refractory and refractory elements (e.g, Fe, Mg, Si, Ca, Al) in a star and the make-up of its rocky planet, known as the rock-star relationship. This relationship is true when considering the Earth and Mars 1 1 1 While the composition of Venus is poorly constrained, it is expected to be consistent with Earth and therefore the rock-star relationship ( 117 ) . with respect to the Sun, and is generally true for small exoplanets with precise densities and measured host abundances of the major rock-building elements ( 95 ; 84 ; 2 ; 100 ; 1 , e.g.,) . The rock-star relationship does not hold for Mercury, which has a molar Fe/Mg ratio \gtrsim 5\times greater than that of the Sun ( 67 ; 72 ; 38 ; 62 ) , meaning it is significantly Fe-enriched. There is also growing evidence for exoplanets more massive than Mercury with similar levels of Fe-enrichment (or super-Mercuries) like Kepler-107 c, HD 137496