EARTH EMBEDDINGS AS PRODUCTS: TAXONOMY, ECOSYSTEM, AND STANDARDIZED ACCESS 1 These authors contributed equally to this work.
Heng Fang 2 1 Adam J. Stewart 3 1 Isaac Corley 4 Xiao Xiang Zhu 3 Hossein Azizpour 2 · 2026
Read EARTH EMBEDDINGS AS PRODUCTS: TAXONOMY, ECOSYSTEM, AND STANDARDIZED ACCESS 1 These authors contributed equally to this work. by Heng Fang 2 1 Adam J. Stewart 3 1 Isaac Corley 4 Xiao Xiang Zhu 3 Hossein Azizpour 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-13134.txt.
Introduction
Heng Fang, Adam J. Stewart, Isaac Corley, Xiao Xiang Zhu, and Hossein Azizpour sort a fast growth field, Earth data in ready baked form. Models that learn the face of the Earth need huge compute. Baked data sets, called embeddings, give a frozen swap that costs far less to use.
Yet such sets now come in a mess of forms and grid sizes that do not match. That mess blocks fair tests and makes work hard to repeat. The team maps the kinds, the groups who make them, and the ways in. They also push for a shared way in for all sets. For Earth data staff, the map turns a wild field into one that can be used side by side.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Heng Fang 2 1 Adam J. Stewart 3 1 Isaac Corley 4 Xiao Xiang Zhu 3 Hossein Azizpour 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-13134
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EARTH EMBEDDINGS AS PRODUCTS: TAXONOMY, ECOSYSTEM, AND STANDARDIZED ACCESS 1 These authors contributed equally to this work. Heng Fang 2 1 Adam J. Stewart 3 1 Isaac Corley 4 Xiao Xiang Zhu 3 Hossein Azizpour 2 Abstract Geospatial Foundation Models (GFMs) provide powerful representations, but high compute costs hinder their widespread use. Pre-computed embedding data products offer a practical “frozen” alternative, yet they currently exist in a fragmented ecosystem of incompatible formats and resolutions. This lack of standardization creates an engineering bottleneck that prevents meaningful model comparison and reproducibility. We formalize this landscape through a three-layer taxonomy: Data, Tools, and Value. We survey existing products to identify interoperability barriers. To bridge this gap, we extend TorchGeo with a unified API that standardizes the loading and querying of diverse embedding products. By treating embeddings as first-class geospatial datasets, we decouple downstream analysis from model-specific engineering, providing a roadmap for more transparent and accessible Earth observation workflows. I Introduction Recent years have witnessed a surge in Geospatial Foundation Models (GFMs), task-agnostic models pre-trained on vast data sources capable of producing low-dimensional fixed-length vectors that capture semantic, spatial, and temporal information [ 1 ] . While models like AlphaEarth [ 2 ] and Clay [ 3 ] promise powerful representations, the ecosystem for their derived products, Earth Embeddings , remains unstructured. The field is rapidly emerging, with approximately 20—25 distinct works appearing in recent literature. While recent position papers have provided valuable perspectives on the potential and research roadmap of these representations [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] , they primarily address the theoretical landscape. A systematic review focused on the operational ecosystem is still absent. Consequently, for practitioners, the barrier to entry remains high. The current landscape is fragmented, with embedding products differing significantly in file formats, spatial resolutions, and licensing terms. There is no unified methodology to load or evaluate them. To address this fragmentation, we present a unified framework that bridges the gap between theoretical vision and practical access. We identify the lack of a common interface as the primary bottleneck and resolve this through integration with the TorchGeo library [ 7 ] . Our specific contributions are: • A Comprehensive Survey : We organize seven existing embedding products into a structured taxonomy and provide a detailed metadata atlas (resolution, license, etc.). • Unified Integration : We implement standardized data loaders for these embeddings in TorchGeo, enabling users to access diverse embeddings via a single API. {forest} Fig. 1: Taxonomy of the Earth Embedding Landscape. We organize the ecosystem into three functional layers: Data, Tools, and Value. Highlighted blocks indicate the specific scope of the assessment in Section III . II The Earth Embedding Landscape TABLE I: Embedding products available as of December 2025. Global coverage only implies land surfaces, no existing products cover oceans. Temporal resolution is divided into “snapshot” for embeddings generated from a single mosaic and “annual” for embeddings generated from annual time series data. *Product has sparse spatial or temporal coverage. Spatial Temporal Product Kind Extent Resolution Extent Resolution Dimensions Dtype License Clay Embeddings [ 3 ] Patch Global* 5.12 km 2018–2023* Snapshot 768 float32 ODC-By-1.0 Major TOM Embeddings [ 8 ] Patch Global 2.14–3.56 km 2015–2024* Snapshot 2048 float32 CC-BY-SA-4.0 Earth Index Embeddings [ 9 ] Patch Global 320 m 2024– 2024 Snapshot 384 float32 CC-BY-4.0 Copernicus-Embed [ 10 ] Patch Global 0.25° 2021– 2021 Annual 768 float32 CC-BY-4.0 Presto Embeddings [ 11 ] Pixel Togo 10 m 2019–2020 Annual 128 uint16 CC-BY-4.0 Tessera Embeddings [ 12 ] Pixel Global* 10 m 2017–2025* Annual 128 int8 \rightarrow float32 CC-BY-4.0 Google Satellite Embedding [ 2 ] Pixel Global 10 m 2017–2024 Annual 64 int8 \rightarrow float64 CC-BY-4.0 II-A Distinction: Foundation Models vs. Embedding Products To clarify our scope, we first distinguish between the generator (the model) and the asset (the generated embedding). Foundation Models (Dynamic Inference) : These architectures are distributed as public weights (e.g., DOFA [ 13 ] , OlmoEarth [ 14 ] ). While they serve as embedding generators, utilizing them requires an active inference pipeline. Users must manage data preprocessing and leverage GPU resources to compute representations from raw imagery. This offers flexibility but imposes hardware and engineering barriers. Embedding Products (Static Data) : In contrast, embedding products (e.g., Google Satellite Embedding [ 2 ] ) are distributed as static, pre-computed vector archives. These are “frozen” assets. They decouple the representation from the computational cost of generation, allowing users to conduct analysis directly without accessing the original model. Why this matters : In practice, this distinction is not merely academic. Treating a static embedding product as a proxy for a foundation model allows for efficient application but limits generalizability. Confusing the two often leads to invalid performance claims, as products are constrained by the specific data snapshot they were computed on. II-B Taxonomy of Earth Embeddings Based on our curated community repository Awesome-Geospatial-Embeddings , we structure the current ecosystem into three functional layers, as visualized in Fig. 1 : II-B 1 Embeddings (Data) This layer encompasses the pre-computed representations themselves. To clarify their structural properties and intended utility, we categorize them by their spatial granularity : Location Embeddings : Representations that encode spatiotemporal coordinates \{x,y,t\} independent of imagery. Models like SatCLIP [ 15 ] and LocationEncoder [ 16 ] map global latitude/longitude coordinates to latent vectors, capturing environmental contexts (e.g., climate zones). Patch-level Embeddings : Single vector representations summarizing an entire image chip (e.g., 256\times 256 pixels). Products in this category, such as Clay [ 3 ] or Major TOM [ 8 ] embeddings, compress high-dimensional sensor data into compact global descriptors. These are optimized for identifying semantic similarity, making them the fundamental unit for search and retrieval tasks. Pixel-level Embeddings : Spatially preserved feature maps where each pixel is assigned a vector, with or without context of neighboring pixels. Unlike global descriptors, these embeddings retain local structural information. They are essential for fine-grained mapping tasks, such as semantic segmentation, where spatial precision is paramount. II-B 2 Analysis Frameworks (Tools) To understand the utility and behavior of these representations, the community has established specific analytical resources: Benchmarks & Evaluation: Standardized frameworks are emerging to probe embedding quality. Examples include NeuCo-Bench [ 17 ] for general vision-based embedding evaluation and GeoINRID [ 18 ] for measuring the intrinsic dimension of coordinate-based embeddings. Open Challenges: Competitions such as the Embed2Scale Challenge (CVPR 2025) [ 19 ] and TerraMind Blue-Sky Challenge [ 20 ] play a crucial role in driving standardization and testing embeddings under compression or retrieval constraints. II-B 3 Downstream Applications (Value) Finally, the landscape demonstrates the practical utility of frozen embeddings. While most research focuses on mapping (e.g., cropland mapping [ 11 ] , poverty mapping [ 21 ] ), we find a clear split in utility: dense pixel-level features excel at fine-grained segmentation, whereas sparse patch-level vectors are ideal for retrieval , an emerging area with significant potential. III The Embedding Product Ecosystem Excluding foundation models and location encoders that require the user to run the model themselves to generate new embeddings, we explore all known Earth embedding products listed in Table I and compare them on their spatial and temporal extent and resolution, compression, and license. We also provide an