Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 2024 Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 – 13

Lea S. Schimak, Timothy R. Bedding, Courtney L. Crawford, Paul G. Beck, Yaguang Li (李亚光), Daniel Huber, Joel Ong, Benjamin T. Montet, May Gade Pedersen, Desmond H. Grossmann, Savita Mathur, Rafael A. García · 2026

Read Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 2024 Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 – 13 by Lea S. Schimak, Timothy R. Bedding, Courtney L. Crawford, Paul G. Beck, Yaguang Li (李亚光), Daniel Huber, Joel Ong, Benjamin T. Montet, May Gade Pedersen, Desmond H. Grossmann, Savita Mathur, Rafael A. García (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-12773.txt.

Introduction

Lea S. Schimak and eleven co authors test red clump star models with a rare binary system. Binaries where both stars pulsate are rare but extremely valuable. Their system pairs a core helium burning red clump star with a red giant branch star. The binary is cataloged as KIC 10841730, and it pulsates in ways seismology can read.

Theirs is the first study of an asteroseismic binary of this exact makeup. Asteroseismology uses star vibrations to probe interiors that light cannot reach. Two pulsating stars in one system give cross checks no single star can. Red clump stars serve as standard candles for galactic distances. Testing their models sharpens the distance ladder of astronomy.

Catalog record

CREATORLea S. Schimak, Timothy R. Bedding, Courtney L. Crawford, Paul G. Beck, Yaguang Li (李亚光), Daniel Huber, Joel Ong, Benjamin T. Montet, May Gade Pedersen, Desmond H. Grossmann, Savita Mathur, Rafael A. García
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-12773

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 2024 Testing Red Clump Models with the Asteroseismic Binary KIC 10841730 – 13 Lea S. Schimak, Timothy R. Bedding, Courtney L. Crawford, Paul G. Beck, Yaguang Li (李亚光), Daniel Huber, Joel Ong, Benjamin T. Montet, May Gade Pedersen, Desmond H. Grossmann, Savita Mathur, Rafael A. García Abstract Binaries in which both stars are pulsating are rare but extremely valuable. We present the first study of an asteroseismic binary system consisting of a core helium-burning red clump (RC) star and a red giant branch (RGB) star. The Kepler target KIC 10841730 is a wide binary (period 2917 ± 8 2917\pm 8 d) that provides ideal conditions to test the accuracy of RC models. While prior studies of RC stars have revealed discrepancies in modelling the period spacings of mixed modes, other model parameters remain largely untested. We perform a detailed modelling analysis using individual mode frequencies and cover a large parameter space in mass, metallicity, He-abundance, mixing length, overshooting, and mass-loss, and we also explore different methods to correct for surface effects. We find two possible results for the red clump models. One solution requires introducing an unexpected offset of the phase shift in the red clump model, yielding an age consistent with the companion star and current masses of 1.01 ± 0.06 1.01\pm 0.06 and 1.08 ± 0.06 1.08\pm 0.06 M ⊙ for the RC and RGB star, respectively. Alternatively, we find that excluding the identification of two questionable radial modes resolves the phase-shift offset issue but results in a higher mass and thus a much younger age for the red clump star, contradicting the age obtained from its companion. We conclude that uncertainties in red clump models affect not only the g-mode period spacings but also the properties of the p modes. We show the power of asteroseismic binaries in validating and constraining stellar models and highlight the need for refining red-clump models. 1 Introduction Accurate stellar modelling, constrained by observations, is essential for testing stellar theories. Asteroseismology, in particular, is a valuable tool to probe the internal structure, complementing analyses based on surface properties alone (see, e.g., 59 ; 1 ; 97 , for a review) . Extensive research on modelling low-mass stars has focused on main sequence (MS) and red giant branch (RGB) stars. The red clump (RC) stars, which burn helium after lifting the degeneracy in their core during the He-flash, remain comparatively less explored due to the increased computational demands and uncertainties associated with modelling these stars. The value of asteroseismic studies of red-giant binary systems has been repeatedly demonstrated ( 72 ; 13 ; 16 ) , especially those with eclipses ( 71 ; 56 ; 14 ; 141 ; 60 ; 31 ; 61 ; 127 ; 20 ; 160 ; 30 ; 161 ) . Born from the same gas and dust cloud and being gravitationally bound, they provide additional constraints that a single star cannot provide. However, binaries in which oscillations are detected in both components are still a rarity. Such joint constraints are thus generally limited to stellar clusters, where all members share a common age and composition ( 4 ; 109 ; 29 , e.g.) . 111 predicted that we should be able to find only about 200 asteroseismic binaries in the Kepler data, with the majority having two RC components ( 107 , see also) . Most of those systems will have their oscillations at similar frequencies, which leads to complex power spectra ( 38 ) . Considering this, the list of binary systems containing evolved stars is even shorter than expected. 100 found one system containing two subgiants (KIC 7107778). 15 and 66 studied a subgiant and RGB star (KIC 9163796), and 117 studied a \delta Scuti and a secondary clump star (KIC 9773821). A potential binary was found by 159 with an RGB and RGB/AGB component (KIC 2568888). 18 identified 30 lightcurves showing two power excesses. Recently, 53 reported 16 additional Kepler targets with two solar-like power excesses, identifying a few more promising binaries but concluding that most are chance alignments. We expanded the list by adding KIC 10841730, the first studied RGB and RC double-oscillating binary system. The components have similar masses, but the primary is an RC star while its companion is still on the RGB. This system offers an ideal laboratory because the shared age and composition of the two components allow us to test the accuracy of the RC model against the more robust RGB model. This is supported by a spectroscopic analysis to further constrain the models generated by mesa and gyre . RC stars have been studied in large samples to examine trends and relations between global asteroseismic parameters such as the frequency of maximum oscillation power ( \nu_{\mathrm{max}} ), frequency separation of p modes ( \Delta\nu ), the period spacing of the dipole g modes ( \Delta\Pi_{\mathrm{1}} ) ( 12 ; 17 ; 114 ; 174 ) , the p-mode phase shift ( \epsilon_{\mathrm{p}} ) ( 90 ) and the behaviour of glitches ( 112 ; 41 ; 173 ; 47 ; 175 ) . The glitches were further analysed using a few selected models that focused on either p modes ( 41 ) or g modes ( 47 ; 105 ) . However, a direct comparison of observed individual frequencies with models is generally avoided by the community because of both the computational resources needed and the high model uncertainties. Even secondary clump stars, which ignite helium before the core becomes degenerate and therefore avoid the computationally expensive He-flash, have only been modelled in detail in a few cases (e.g. 117 ; 29 , Chowhan in prep.) . We aim to fill this gap. We focus on a detailed analysis of individual oscillation modes instead of global parameters, to compare model predictions with observations. First attempts to match the observed \Delta\Pi_{\mathrm{1}} to models by 113 proved promising in testing the core masses of RGB stars, but a discrepancy between models and observations for RC stars became evident, most likely driven by the uncertain description of the growth of the convective core. The radiative zone bordering on this convective core acts as the propagation region for the g modes, which means that \Delta\Pi_{\mathrm{1}} is sensitive to the treatment of the convective boundary. The growth of the core can lead to a splitting of its convective zone in models ( 52 ) , and it is debated how efficient mixing in these regions would be. Further, when helium is nearly exhausted, so-called breathing pulses could occur ( 36 ) . The core grows rapidly when fresh He is added, but the He is burned quickly and the core shrinks again. The discrepancy between the observed and modelled \Delta\Pi_{\mathrm{1}} , the uncertain description of the possible splitting of the convection zone and the debated occurrence of the breathing pulses, have all motivated studies to improve and test various descriptions ( 113 ; 28 ; 27 ; 44 ; 45 ; 46 ; 23 ; 119 ; 120 ; 131 ; 132 ) . Overall, these studies point to the need for a bigger convective core and faster growth rate but there

Read the complete text