Unbounded Harms, Bounded Law: Liability in the Age of Borderless AI

Ha-Chi Tran · 2026

Read Unbounded Harms, Bounded Law: Liability in the Age of Borderless AI by Ha-Chi Tran (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-12646.txt.

Introduction

Ha-Chi Tran writes on liability law in the age of artificial intelligence that crosses borders. AI systems can cause harm in many countries at once, while law stays bounded by place. The rapid growth of AI has exposed deep flaws in risk governance. Much work has gone into spotting and preventing harm before it happens.

Far less work treats what should happen after harm occurs. That ex post side covers liability, compensation, and blame. Tran argues this side of responsible AI scholarship is underdeveloped. Courts and lawmakers need rules for harms that no single state contains. The paper maps that gap and presses for stronger legal responses.

Catalog record

CREATORHa-Chi Tran
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-12646

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unbounded Harms, Bounded Law: Liability in the Age of Borderless AI Ha-Chi Tran Abstract The rapid acceleration of artificial intelligence (AI) has exposed fundamental deficiencies in prevailing risk governance: despite substantial advances in ex ante harm identification and prevention, Responsible AI scholarship remains comparatively underdeveloped in its treatment of ex post risk governance. Core legal questions regarding compensation, mitigation, attribution of responsibility, liability allocation, and the effectiveness of remedial mechanisms remain inadequately theorized and underinstitutionalized, particularly in relation to transboundary AI harms, AI-induced risks, and damages that transcend national borders, legal jurisdictions, and regulatory authority. Drawing on contemporary AI risk analyses, we argue that such harms are not exceptional but structurally inherent to the AI supply chains, and are likely to increase in both frequency and severity due to globalized deployment, cross-border data infrastructures, and asymmetric national capacities in AI development and oversight, thereby rendering territorially bounded liability regimes increasingly inadequate. Adopting a comparative and interdisciplinary approach, the paper examines compensation and liability mechanisms from adjacent high-risk and transnational domains, including vaccine injury compensation, financial systemic risk governance, commercial nuclear energy liability, and international environmental harm regimes, to identify transferable legal design principles, such as strict liability, pooled compensation mechanisms, and collective risk-sharing, as well as the structural constraints limiting their application to AI-related harms. Situated within an international order increasingly shaped by AI arms race dynamics rather than cooperative governance, the paper outlines the contours of a global AI compensation and accountability architecture, underscoring the tension between geopolitical rivalry and the collective action required to govern transboundary AI risk. 1 Introduction The black-boxed, diffuse, and distributed nature of contemporary artificial intelligence (AI) systems, particularly those based on sub-symbolic architectures such as deep neural networks, poses fundamental challenges for legal systems, especially with respect to risk governance and liability allocation [ 32 , 84 , 28 , 30 ] . To date, the rapidly expanding discourse on Responsible AI has been dominated by ex ante approaches to risk management. Scholarly and regulatory efforts have prioritized preventive tools such as risk taxonomy and impact assessments [ 75 , 36 , 98 , 6 ] , technical and organizational safeguards [ 27 , 61 ] , and algorithmic audits [ 5 , 58 ] designed to promote safety, fairness, and compliance across the AI lifecycle. The European Union’s risk-based regulatory framework under the AI Act [ 23 ] , and its growing potential influence on AI governance in other jurisdictions through the Brussels Effect [ 1 , 74 ] , exemplifies this preventive paradigm by classifying AI systems according to perceived risk and subjecting them to differentiated regulatory obligations. However, the intrinsic characteristics of contemporary AI systems—most notably their emergent behaviors, adaptive learning capacities, reliance on continuously evolving datasets, and context-dependent performance—fundamentally limit the effectiveness of predictive, ex ante risk governance [ 71 , 99 , 69 ] . A growing body of legal scholarship has accordingly exposed the structural inadequacy of prevailing liability regimes, including both strict and fault-based frameworks, in addressing AI-related harms [ 37 , 96 , 55 , 91 , 77 ] . The defining features of modern AI systems—such as epistemic opacity, autonomous and adaptive decision-making, distributed and modular functionality, and complex multi-actor development and deployment chains—destabilize the core doctrinal assumptions underpinning traditional liability law. In particular, they challenge foundational premises of linear causation, demonstrable negligence, and the clear attribution of product defects in design, warning, or operation [ 7 , 71 , 96 , 16 ] . These structural mismatches generate persistent evidentiary asymmetries that systematically disadvantage claimants, thereby constraining access to compensation and undermining the corrective, allocative, and deterrent functions that liability law traditionally serves. Legal frameworks premised on the assumption of relatively stable technologies, traceable causal chains, and identifiable human agency are thus increasingly ill-equipped to address harms arising from AI systems. Even highly sophisticated ex ante risk taxonomies and compliance mechanisms cannot reliably anticipate emergent or downstream harms that materialize only through real-world deployment and interaction [ 96 , 45 ] . This irreducible uncertainty, inherent in AI, a technology that is actively reshaping global socio-economic trajectories, has in turn catalysed a shift toward adaptive governance instruments—most notably regulatory sandboxes [ 25 , 59 ] —which enable regulators and firms to engage in iterative learning through controlled experimentation and empirical observation, thereby surfacing risks that evade conventional predictive assessment and audit [ 25 , 52 ] . At a systemic level, the emergence and increasing reliance on adaptive governance tools reflect a deeper condition of epistemic uncertainty in global AI governance. Not only is knowledge about the nature of potential AI risks inherently incomplete, but the probability and severity of those risks are likewise indeterminate, a Knightian uncertainty [ 81 ] . In such a governance environment, an exclusive emphasis on ex ante risk prevention is insufficient. Instead, greater attention must be directed toward ex post governance mechanisms capable of responding once harm has occurred. Despite this necessity, legal and policy scholarship has devoted comparatively little attention to the ex post dimensions of AI governance [ 95 ] . Key post-harm questions remain underexamined: who is responsible for AI-induced harm, what constitutes fair and effective compensation, and whether current remedies can deliver timely redress while mitigating future risks. Recent legal reforms, most notably within the European Union, including the revised Product Liability Directive and the proposed (but ultimately unadopted) AI Liability Directive, reflect a growing institutional recognition of a structural liability gap in the governance of AI-related harms, particularly by explicitly acknowledging the evidentiary and procedural disadvantages faced by individuals harmed by AI systems [ 62 , 3 ] . When read alongside an expanding body of broader scholarly proposals advocating several liability architectures modifications, these developments point to an emerging consensus that conventional liability paradigms are increasingly ill-suited to addressing harms generated by autonomous and adaptive AI systems. By recalibrating the role of fault, lowering evidentiary thresholds, and reallocating elements of the burden of proof to developers and deployers—most notably through the introduction of rebuttable presumptions or per se rule of AI defectiveness and dangerousness to shift the burden of proof away from the claimants [ 29 ] —these reforms and proposals collectively signal an incipient doctrinal shift toward stricter for high-risk systems [ 50 ] , and in certain contexts, no-fault liability models [ 37 , 96 , 55 ] . This shift is normatively oriented toward restoring the compensatory, corrective, and risk-allocative functions of liability law under conditions of technological opacity, autonomy, and adaptive learning. Notwithstanding these important legal reforms, prevailing debates on AI liability remain confined mainly within nationally bounded regimes. This orientation is consistent with the territorial logic of legal sovereignty that underpins the contemporary international legal order and reflects states’ enduring preference to retain regulatory authority over emerging technologies within their own jurisdictions. Yet such a territorially constrained focus risks obscuring a critical and increasingly salient category of AI-related risk: transboundary, regional, and global harms. These encompass injuries and losses arising from AI systems that are developed, trained, deployed, and operated across multiple jurisdictions, as well as harms whose scale, diffusion, or systemic character exceeds the regulatory, adjudicative, and compensatory capacities of any single state. This paper

Read the complete text