Inertia–Dilatancy Interplay Governs Shear-Thickening Drop Impact

Anahita Mobaseri, Leonardo Gordillo, Charles Burton, Soyoon Yoon, Dong Lee, Satish Kumar, Michelle M. Driscoll, Xiang Cheng · 2026

Read Inertia–Dilatancy Interplay Governs Shear-Thickening Drop Impact by Anahita Mobaseri, Leonardo Gordillo, Charles Burton, Soyoon Yoon, Dong Lee, Satish Kumar, Michelle M. Driscoll, Xiang Cheng (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-12642.txt.

Introduction

Anahita Mobaseri and seven co authors study what happens when a drop of cornstarch and water hits a surface. Such mixtures are a premier example of shear thickening fluids. They flow like liquid until stressed, then suddenly act almost solid. The team combine high speed photography with direct force measurements.

They vary impact conditions across a wide range in their tests. The study identifies three distinct impact regimes. The title names the interplay that governs the behavior: inertia versus dilatancy. Dilatancy is the tendency of the packed grains to expand under shear. Knowing the regimes helps predict splashes, armor response, and industrial flows of such fluids.

Catalog record

CREATORAnahita Mobaseri, Leonardo Gordillo, Charles Burton, Soyoon Yoon, Dong Lee, Satish Kumar, Michelle M. Driscoll, Xiang Cheng
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-12642

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Inertia–Dilatancy Interplay Governs Shear-Thickening Drop Impact Preprint: APS/123-QED Anahita Mobaseri, Leonardo Gordillo, Charles Burton, Soyoon Yoon, Dong Lee, Satish Kumar, Michelle M. Driscoll, Xiang Cheng Abstract Combining high-speed photography with direct force measurements, we investigate the impact dynamics of drops of cornstarch–water mixtures—a premier example of shear-thickening fluids—across a wide range of impact conditions. Our study identifies three distinct impact regimes. In addition to the liquid-like and solid-like behaviors generally expected for the impact-induced response of shear-thickening fluids, we uncover a counterintuitive regime in which high-concentration cornstarch–water mixtures display a liquid-like response at the onset of impact when shear rates are high and only transition to a solid-like behavior at later times as shear rates reduce. By integrating the classic drop-impact theory with the Reynolds–Darcy mechanism for dilatancy, we develop a unified model that quantitatively describes the impact dynamics of shear-thickening drops across all regimes. Our work reveals the unexpected response of shear-thickening fluids to ultra-fast deformation and advances fundamental understanding of drop impact for complex fluids. From raindrops battering a windshield to coffee droplets splashing onto a table, everyday drop impact often belies the extreme mechanics underlying this ubiquitous fluid process 53 ; 24 ; 10 . Indeed, drop impact provides an elegant platform for probing fluid behavior under rapid deformation, inaccessible to standard rheometric techniques 29 . Motivated by this fundamental interest as well as its broad relevance in industrial, agricultural, and biomedical applications, the impact of drops of complex fluids with diverse rheological properties has been extensively studied 43 ; 33 . Among these, shear-thickening fluids—most famously exemplified by cornstarch-water mixtures 5 ; 17 —stand out due to their dramatic viscosity increase and striking shear jamming behavior at high shear rates 50 ; 9 ; 7 ; 34 , giving rise to rich and complex impact dynamics 3 ; 4 ; 42 . Nevertheless, compared with the in-depth studies on drop impacts of many other complex fluids and on the complementary problem of the response of bulk shear-thickening fluids under the impact of solid projectiles 51 ; 11 ; 48 ; 36 ; 19 ; 23 ; 26 ; 30 ; 2 ; 35 ; 12 ; 28 , our understanding of the impact of shear-thickening drops remains elementary, despite growing interest on shear-thickening drops in applications such as 3D printing 1 and soft robotics 39 . Here, we study the impact dynamics of drops of cornstarch-water mixtures, subjected to a characteristic shear rate up to 2,000 s -1 . Unlike previous studies that solely focused on the kinematics of impacting drops using high-speed photography 3 ; 4 ; 42 , we directly measure the transient impact force of the drops, which reveals previously inaccessible dynamic features. Our combined kinematic and dynamic measurements challenge the prevailing view that a shear-thickening drop behaves like an elastic or viscoelastic sphere at high shear rates 28 ; 42 ; 12 ; 30 ; 7 and uncover an unexpected impact regime, where, despite extremely high shear rates, the drop shows a liquid-like response at short times, before transitioning to a solid-like behavior as the shear rates decrease over time. Our study provides new insights into the unusual behavior of shear-thickening fluids under ultra-fast deformation and offers a comprehensive understanding of the impact dynamics of shear-thickening drops, significantly advancing our knowledge of the impact of complex fluid drops. We prepare suspensions of cornstarch (Carolina Biological Supply) in water with volume fractions \phi ranging from 0.30 to 0.43 , spanning rheological regimes from shear thinning to continuous and discontinuous shear thickening (Fig. S1) 41 . Synchronized with a high-speed camera (Photron, SA-X2) that visualizes drop spreading, a force sensor (PCB, 209C11) simultaneously measures the transient normal impact force, F(t) . For each experiment, a drop of a diameter of D_{0}=4.0\pm 0.2 mm impacts an aluminum surface at a velocity, U_{0} , ranging from 0.5 up to 7.2 m/s. The density of the mixtures is \rho=\rho_{c}\phi+\rho_{w}(1-\phi) , with the densities of cornstarch and water being \rho_{c}=1.55 g/cm 3 and \rho_{w}=1.0 g/cm 3 . Figure 1: Phase diagram of the impact dynamics of shear-thickening drops. (a–c) Temporal evolution of the impact force, F(t) , for drops of cornstarch–water mixtures at: (a) volume fraction \phi=0.35 , impact velocity U_{0}=1.2 m/s; (b) \phi=0.43 , U_{0}=3.5 m/s; and (c) \phi=0.41 , U_{0}=5.1 m/s. Solid lines show averages over five experiments, with shaded regions indicating the standard deviation, while dashed lines correspond to model predictions. Vertical dashed and dotted lines indicate the time of maximum force t_{\text{max}}^{F} and the time of maximum spreading t_{\text{max}}^{D} , respectively. F is normalized by \rho U_{0}^{2}D_{0}^{2} , and time t by D_{0}/U_{0} . (d) Ratio of the two times, t_{\text{max}}^{F}/t_{\text{max}}^{D} , plotted as a function of \phi and characteristic shear rate U_{0}/D_{0} . Three regimes are indicated: ① Inertial, ② Dilatant, and ③ Inertial–dilatant. Circled points correspond to the examples shown in (a–c). The dashed line shows the onset of discontinuous shear thickening, while the dot-dash line indicates the model prediction for the boundary between Regime (2) and (3), corresponding to \text{ID}=1 (Eq. 6 ). Symbol shapes denote samples with different \phi (the y -axis), and symbol colors indicate the value of t_{\text{max}}^{F}/t_{\text{max}}^{D} . The gray region marks the shear rates inaccessible to conventional rheometry. A three-dimensional representation of the dataset is provided in Fig. S2 41 . By examining the correlation between the kinematic and dynamic features of drops, we identify three distinct impact regimes. Specifically, we measure the ratio of the time of maximum force, t_{\text{max}}^{F} , to the time of maximum drop spreading, t_{\text{max}}^{D} , as a function of volume fraction \phi and characteristic shear rate U_{0}/D_{0} (Fig. 1 (d)). Regime (1) (Movie S1): At low volume fractions \phi<0.37 where mixtures exhibit continuous shear thickening, we observe t_{\text{max}}^{F}/t_{\text{max}}^{D}\ll 1 and a distinctly asymmetric impact force profile F(t) about t_{\text{max}}^{F} (Fig. 1 (a)), both hallmarks of the inertia-driven impact of liquid drops 18 ; 32 . Regime (2) (Movie S2): For \phi>0.37 , mixtures exhibit discontinuous shear thickening at high shear rates. At relatively low impact velocity U_{0} —or equivalently, low shear rate U_{0}/D_{0} —the ratio t_{\text{max}}^{F}/t_{\text{max}}^{D} approaches one (Fig. 1 (d)), and the impact force F(t) becomes more symmetric about t_{\text{max}}^{F} (Fig. 1 (b)), features typically associated with the impact of solid spheres 15 . Regime (3) (Movie S3): For mixtures of high \phi , as the impact velocity and therefore the shear rate increase further, one might expect an even more pronounced solid-like response due to strong shear thickening at higher shear rates. Surprisingly, t_{\text{max}}^{F}/t_{\text{max}}^{D} decreases in this third regime, reaching values comparable to those observed in liquid-drop impact (Fig. 1 (d)). The force profile F(t) exhibits new intriguing features (Fig. 1 (c)): it rises sharply at early times, similar to liquid-drop impact, maintains a high plateau after reaching the peak force, and finally plummets to zero, reminiscent of solid-sphere impact. To understand these multifaceted observations, we analyze the detailed impact dynamics and elucidate the physical mechanisms governing each of the three regimes. Regime (1) (small \phi ): For low- \phi mixtures showing continuous shear thickening (Fig. S1), inertia dominates the impact process. The impact force is well described by the theory of liquid drop impact (Fig. 1 (a))

Read the complete text