Distributional Fitting and Tail Analysis of Lead-Time Compositions: Nights vs. Revenue on Airbnb
Harrison Katz, Jess Needleman, Liz Medina · 2026
Read Distributional Fitting and Tail Analysis of Lead-Time Compositions: Nights vs. Revenue on Airbnb by Harrison Katz, Jess Needleman, Liz Medina (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-12175.txt.
Introduction
Harrison Katz, Jess Needleman, and Liz Medina fit the spread of booking lead times on Airbnb. They treat each day's split of demand across lead days, from 0 to 365, as a compositional vector. They do this for two metrics: nights booked, a volume count, and gross booking value, a revenue count.
The data span 2,557 days, from January 2019 through December 2025, in a large North American region. They report three findings on how the two spreads differ in shape and tail. Hosts and platforms can use lead shapes to plan price and stock.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harrison Katz, Jess Needleman, Liz Medina |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-12175
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Distributional Fitting and Tail Analysis of Lead-Time Compositions: Nights vs. Revenue on Airbnb Harrison Katz, Jess Needleman, Liz Medina Abstract We analyze daily lead-time distributions for two Airbnb demand metrics—Nights Booked (volume) and Gross Booking Value (revenue)—treating each day’s allocation across 0–365 days as a compositional vector. The data span 2,557 days from January 2019 through December 2025 in a large North American region. Three findings emerge. First, GBV concentrates more heavily in mid-range horizons: beyond 90 days, GBV tail mass typically exceeds Nights by 20–50%, with ratios reaching 75% at the 180-day threshold during peak seasons. Second, Gamma and Weibull distributions fit comparably well under interval-censored cross-entropy—Gamma wins on 61% of days for Nights and 52% for GBV, with Weibull close behind at 38% and 45%. Lognormal rarely wins ( < < 3%). Nonparametric GAMs achieve 18–80 × \times lower CRPS but sacrifice interpretability. Third, generalized Pareto fits suggest bounded tails ( ξ < 0 \xi<0 ) for both metrics at thresholds below 150 days, though this may partly reflect right-truncation at 365 days; above 150 days, estimates destabilize. Bai–Perron tests with HAC standard errors identify five structural breaks in the Wasserstein distance series, with early breaks coinciding with COVID-19 disruptions. The results show that volume and revenue lead-time shapes diverge systematically, that simple two-parameter distributions capture daily pmfs adequately, and that tail inference requires care near truncation boundaries. 1 Introduction Lead-time data—how far in advance travelers book—is compositional data that matters for pricing, staffing, and cash-flow forecasting ( 10 ; 20 ) . Each day’s bookings form a probability vector across possible lead times, summing to one. Two natural questions arise: what parametric family best describes these daily shapes, and do volume-based and revenue-based bookings distribute differently across lead times? Research on travel lead times has a long history in tourism demand forecasting and revenue management ( 24 ; 41 ; 38 ; 27 ; 12 ; 29 ) . Most of this work uses aggregate demand as a single indicator, overlooking the fact that volume-based and revenue-based bookings can exhibit systematically different lead-time patterns ( 33 ; 10 ; 40 ; 21 ) . The rise of platforms like Airbnb, with their hybrid and peer-to-peer accommodation offerings, has amplified interest in how advanced vs. last-minute bookings distribute across traveler segments ( 17 ; 45 ; 9 ; 39 ; 34 ) . Some studies focus on pricing or occupancy strategies ( 4 ; 44 ; 43 ; 36 ) , but few examine detailed distributional properties of volume vs. revenue bookings, especially in the context of disruptive events like COVID-19 ( 14 ; 37 ; 31 ; 28 ) . Recent work on Airbnb stay lengths documents that the pandemic induced structural shifts in the distribution of trip durations, not merely changes in averages ( 22 ) ; similar distributional thinking applies to lead times. Lead-time forecasting has emerged as a specialized subfield within hospitality analytics ( 11 ; 8 ; 20 ) . Early vs. late bookings directly influence capacity, staffing, and dynamic pricing decisions ( 27 ; 10 ) . Recent econometric work also underscores the role of structural breaks, whereby exogenous shocks cause persistent shifts in time-series behavior ( 5 ) . In travel contexts, such shocks include financial crises, pandemics, and policy changes that reshape patterns of arrivals, spending, and booking windows ( 15 ; 31 ; 35 ) . Although the tourism literature documents regime shifts in aggregated arrivals ( 25 ) and some segment-specific disruptions ( 16 ; 18 ) , fewer studies compare volume-based vs. revenue-based lead-time distributions at daily granularity. A separate literature addresses the distributional fitting of duration and lead-time data. The lognormal, Weibull, and Gamma families are standard candidates for right-skewed, positive-valued data ( 19 ) . In hospitality contexts, 11 apply these families to hotel booking data, and 8 compare parametric and nonparametric approaches for lead-time prediction. Compositional methods add another layer: when the object of interest is a probability vector rather than a scalar, standard regression and ARMA techniques do not apply directly. The compositional data analysis literature ( 1 ; 2 ; 32 ) provides transformations (additive log-ratio, centered log-ratio, isometric log-ratio) that map the simplex to Euclidean space, enabling multivariate methods. The Katz framework for Bayesian Dirichlet time-series models ( 20 ; 23 ) applies these ideas to lead-time forecasting; we draw on its conceptual foundations here. Extreme-value methods offer tools for tail analysis. The generalized Pareto distribution (GPD) is the canonical model for exceedances above a threshold ( 7 ; 6 ) . In hospitality, 11 use GPD to characterize rare long-horizon bookings. A key diagnostic is threshold stability: if the GPD is appropriate, the shape parameter should stabilize as the threshold increases ( 6 ) . Failure to stabilize suggests model misspecification or data artifacts such as truncation. We address these literatures with data from Airbnb. The platform records both Nights Booked (a volume measure) and Gross Booking Value (a revenue measure) at each check-in date, enabling direct comparison of their lead-time compositions. We analyze 2,557 days from January 2019 through December 2025 in a large North American region. Our methodological contributions include: (1) cross-entropy minimization for parametric fitting on truncated support, which respects the discrete nature of observed lead times while assuming an underlying continuous process; (2) strictly proper scoring rules (CRPS) for model comparison; (3) robust GPD fitting with threshold stability diagnostics; and (4) HAC-robust structural break detection applied to distributional divergence. Three substantive findings emerge. First, GBV has systematically heavier mid-range tails than Nights: beyond 90 days, the GBV share typically exceeds Nights by 20–50%, with ratios reaching 75% at the 180-day threshold during peak seasons. Second, Gamma and Weibull provide nearly equivalent fits for daily pmfs, with Gamma holding a slight edge (winning 55–60% of days by cross-entropy), while Lognormal is dominated. GAMs achieve superior CRPS but at the cost of interpretability. Third, GPD tail estimates are reliable only for thresholds below 150 days; beyond that, right-truncation at 365 days induces instability that could mislead inference. These findings have practical implications for revenue forecasting—models that ignore the volume-revenue divergence will systematically mispredict cash-flow timing—and methodological implications for applied extreme-value analysis of truncated data. Section 2 describes the data and preprocessing. Section 3 details the methods: Wasserstein distance, structural breaks, GPD fitting, interval-censored likelihood, and scoring rules. Section 4 presents results. Section 5 discusses implications and limitations. 2 Data and Preprocessing 2.1 Data Source and Scope The data are proprietary Airbnb bookings from a large North American region, January 1, 2019 through December 31, 2025. For each calendar day d , we observe two quantities at each integer lead time \ell\in\{0,1,\ldots,365\} : the total Nights Booked with check-in at day d+\ell , and the corresponding Gross Booking Value. Dividing by daily totals yields probability vectors: the proportion of that day’s bookings (by volume or revenue) allocated to each lead-time bin. Bookings beyond 365 days comprise less than 0.5% of the total and are excluded. This truncation is standard in lead-time analysis and captures the vast majority of booking behavior, but it has implications for tail inference that we address in Section 4 . The final sample contains 2,557