Measuring growth and convergence at the mesoscale

Isaak Mengesha, Debraj Roy · 2026

Read Measuring growth and convergence at the mesoscale by Isaak Mengesha, Debraj Roy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-12158.txt.

Introduction

Isaak Mengesha and Debraj Roy measure growth and convergence at the mesoscale, between city and nation. Global gaps have shifted inward, with more spread now inside countries than between them. They use 8,790 harmonised Functional Urban Areas, which are labour-market regions.

Those areas hold 3.9 billion people and about 80% of global GDP. At that scale, national means hide the true dynamics of growth and structural change. The pair show how that hiding has grown. Policy based on national means may thus miss where growth truly lags. City scale data show trends that nations hide in means.

Catalog record

CREATORIsaak Mengesha, Debraj Roy
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-12158

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Measuring growth and convergence at the mesoscale Isaak Mengesha, Debraj Roy Abstract Global inequality has shifted inward, with rising dispersion increasingly occurring within countries rather than between them. Using 8,790 newly harmonised Functional Urban Areas (FUAs) —micro-founded labour-market regions encompassing 3.9 billion people and representing approximately 80% of global GDP— we show that national aggregates systematically, and increasingly, misrepresent the dynamics of growth, convergence, and structural change. Drawing on high-resolution global GDP data and country-level capability measures, we find that the middle-income trampoline that previously drove global convergence is flattening. This divergence in the lower-income regime does not reflect poverty traps: low-income FUAs exhibit positive expected growth, and the transition curve displays no stable low-income equilibrium. Instead, productive capabilities—proxied by the Economic Complexity Index—define distinct growth regimes. FUAs converge within capability strata but diverge across them, and capability upgrading follows a predictable J-curve marked by short-run disruption and medium-run acceleration. These findings suggest that national convergence policies may be systematically misaligned with the geographic scale at which capability accumulation operates. 1 Introduction Global inequality has undergone a fundamental geographic reorientation. While between-country income gaps remain substantial, within-country dispersion is rising across the world economy [ 49 ] . Therefore, studying growth at the national level misses where heterogeneity is increasingly located. Yet other spatial disaggregation – i.e. sub-national administrative boundaries – introduces systematic distortions through the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem (MAUP) [ 40 ] . Statistical relationships depend on the scale and zoning of underlying spatial units. Administrative boundaries aggregate historical circumstances rather than economic integration, obscuring the mechanisms generating divergence, convergence, and structural adjustment. Evidence for multiple steady states at sub-national scales is robust, yet global convergence analysis remains constrained by administratively defined regions rather than economically meaningful spatial units [ 17 , 9 , 21 ] . When development constraints are locally embedded, national convergence strategies based on place-neutral policy reasoning are structurally misaligned with the geography of growth. [ 7 ] . Functional Urban Areas (FUAs) provide a theoretically grounded alternative. Delineated using population grids and commuting-flow thresholds, FUAs approximate integrated labour-market regions rather than political jurisdictions [ 15 ] . This matters because knowledge- and complexity-intensive activities concentrate in cities [ 6 ] , FUAs capture actual adjustment margins to labour-demand shocks [ 48 ] , and approximately 3.9 billion people live in 8,790 FUAs worldwide [ 37 ] . As a result, FUAs provide the appropriate spatial scale for studying growth heterogeneity as an outcome of endogenous adjustment and capability accumulation. Observed at the FUA level, urban systems display systematic development heterogeneity. Larger cities enjoy persistent productivity premia [ 1 ] , while mature urban systems exhibit diminishing population-growth advantages [ 38 ] . These regularities imply distinct urban growth regimes that are mechanically blurred by national aggregates. A natural candidate mechanism is productive capability accumulation. The Economic Complexity Index (ECI) captures latent productive know-how, institutional capacity, and diversification potential [ 31 ] . Higher ECI predicts subsequent growth [ 26 ] , yet subnational capability measures remain largely absent from empirical growth research [ 50 ] . If urban growth is regime-dependent, capabilities provide a plausible basis for structuring these regimes . This motivates the central question: What growth and convergence regimes become visible in the world economy when development is examined at the scale of functional urban areas, and how does spatial aggregation shape our understanding of the contribution of productive capabilities? We show that FUAs recover a substantially clearer growth signal than comparably fine administrative spatial disaggregation. At the FUA level, income dynamics exhibit stable, nonlinear laws of motion that are obscured under administratively defined regions. Capability-based growth predictions suffer analogous attenuation under spatial aggregation: the predictive content of ECI weakens mechanically as economically integrated units are fragmented. Across all spatial levels, we find no evidence of poverty traps in the sense of locally stable low-income steady states. Instead, the data support the existence of capability-conditioned growth regimes, with convergence occurring within capability strata and divergence across them—a structure that becomes most legible when growth is measured at the scale of functional urban areas. 2 Related Literature Three bodies of research inform this paper’s approach to urban growth dynamics: the convergence debate and the conditions under which economies catch up, fall behind, or cluster into distinct steady states; the role of productive capabilities in shaping development trajectories; and the use of functional urban areas as units of economic analysis. A common theoretical concern cuts across all three. New Economic Geography demonstrates that increasing returns and transport costs generate multiple spatial equilibria rather than a unique steady state [ 32 ] , and that economic outcomes depend on market access and spatial integration rather than administratively defined boundaries [ 19 ] . Aggregating heterogeneous spatial equilibria at the national level therefore mechanically obscures growth and convergence dynamics. Spatial scale is not a neutral measurement choice but a theoretically consequential one—an insight that motivates our effort to bridge these literatures by embedding capability-driven dynamics within a convergence framework operationalised at the scale of functional urban areas. Convergence, growth regimes, and structural transformation Recent work has reignited debate over whether poorer economies are catching up to richer ones. [ 41 ] documented unconditional convergence at the country level since the 1990s, yet the authors themselves have since noted a post-2010 reversal [ 42 ] , corroborated by others [ 39 ] . This instability is puzzling on its own terms, but becomes more so when paired with evidence that between-country convergence has coincided with rising inequality within countries [ 2 ] . Together, this puts the conventional approach of measuring convergence at the national level into question. To situate this concern, consider the theoretical foundations. The Solow model predicts convergence to a common steady state [ 47 ] , and early evidence among relatively homogeneous samples—OECD economies, US states—appeared consistent with this prediction [ 8 ] . Globally, however, unconditional convergence does not agree with data. The resolution proposed by [ 34 ] is conditional convergence: economies converge not to a universal equilibrium but to heterogeneous steady states determined by structural characteristics—savings rates, population growth, human capital, institutions. Convergence then operates within groups sharing similar fundamentals; across groups, income gaps persist. Models incorporating nonconvexities or complementarities go further, generating multiple locally stable equilibria [ 4 ] and the empirical implication of convergence clubs: catch-up within clusters, divergence between them [ 17 ] . What determines club membership? Cross-country variation in output per worker is measured predominantly by total factor productivity rather than factor accumulation [ 24 ] . TFP, in turn, reflects organisational efficiency, institutional quality, and technological capacity—closely related to what capability-based measures of economic complexity aim to capture [ 31 , 29 ] . If capabilities determine which equilibrium an economy converges toward, then capability accumulation provides a mechanism linking micro-level productive knowledge to macro-level growth dynamics. A related literature examines structural transformation—the reallocation of labour from agriculture to manufacturing to services that accompanies development [ 28 ] . Sectoral transitions are also capability transitions: the knowledge, institutions, and organisational forms required to operate a manufacturing economy differ fundamentally from those suited to agriculture [ 31 ] . If capability upgrading requires costly

Read the complete text