Quantum Kernel Machine Learning for Autonomous Materials Science
Felix Adams, Daiwei Zhu, David W. Steuerman, A. Gilad Kusne, Ichiro Takeuchi · 2026
Read Quantum Kernel Machine Learning for Autonomous Materials Science by Felix Adams, Daiwei Zhu, David W. Steuerman, A. Gilad Kusne, Ichiro Takeuchi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-11775.txt.
Introduction
Felix Adams, Daiwei Zhu, David W. Steuerman, A. Gilad Kusne, and Ichiro Takeuchi bring quantum kernel methods to self-run materials work. In such work, a smart loop picks the next test to run. The aim is to find good new materials with as few tests as can be done.
Each test costs time and stock, so data stay scarce by design. Kernel methods judge how alike two mixes are, which guides the search. A quantum kernel may map mixes in ways that are hard on plain machines. The study links this tool to the search for new mixes across a wide space of choices.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Felix Adams, Daiwei Zhu, David W. Steuerman, A. Gilad Kusne, Ichiro Takeuchi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-11775
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Quantum Kernel Machine Learning for Autonomous Materials Science Felix Adams, Daiwei Zhu, David W. Steuerman, A. Gilad Kusne, Ichiro Takeuchi Abstract Autonomous materials science, where active learning is used to navigate large compositional phase space, has emerged as a powerful vehicle to rapidly explore new materials. A crucial aspect of autonomous materials science is exploring new materials using as little data as possible. Gaussian process-based active learning allows effective charting of multi-dimensional parameter space with a limited number of training data, and thus is a common algorithmic choice for autonomous materials science. An integral part of the autonomous workflow is the application of kernel functions for quantifying similarities among measured data points. A recent theoretical breakthrough has shown that quantum kernel models can achieve similar performance with less training data than classical kernel models. This signals the possible advantage of applying quantum kernel machine learning to autonomous materials discovery. In this work, we compare quantum and classical kernels for their utility in sequential phase space navigation for autonomous materials science. Specifically, we compute a quantum kernel and several classical kernels for x-ray diffraction patterns taken from an Fe-Ga-Pd ternary composition spread library. We conduct our study on both IonQ’s Aria trapped ion quantum computer hardware and the corresponding classical noisy simulator. We experimentally verify that a quantum kernel model can outperform some classical kernel models. The results highlight the potential of quantum kernel machine learning methods for accelerating materials discovery and suggest complex x-ray diffraction data is a candidate for robust quantum kernel model advantage. I Introduction Discovery and optimization of new materials play a crucial role in advancing technology in modern society. However, the space of possible compositions and synthesis parameters is immense. Researchers are increasingly relying on high-throughput experimental and computational approaches to identify new functional compounds for their use in a variety of technological areas. Autonomous materials science has emerged as an effective vehicle for navigating the space of possible materials. Autonomous experimental methods can self-navigate multi-dimensional parameter space through continuous updating of a Bayesian surrogate model without having to survey every point in the parameter space. There have been a number of demonstrations of closed-loop autonomous workflows for successful optimization of compositional parameters (with respect to specific materials characteristics) with only a limited number of experimental iterations in self-guided sequences 12 ; 26 ; 28 ; 1 ; 29 . Combinatorial libraries, where large compositional variations are laid out on individual wafers/chips, are particularly useful physical platforms for materials optimization. Autonomous optimization within libraries can be used to quickly chart materials within fixed composition variations such as ternary phase diagrams 3 . Figure 1 shows a schematic of an example typical active learning workflow as applied to the Fe-Ga-Pd ternary composition space. The goal of the autonomous workflow is to determine the distribution of the different crystalline phases throughout the composition space (“phase map”), obtained using XRD measurements, using as few measurements as possible. The iterative workflow has 4 steps: measurement, clustering, extrapolation, and decision. First, an XRD measurement is performed at a particular composition. Second, all the XRD patterns measured so far are clustered into groups (representing different crystal phases). Third, the clusters are then extrapolated to the unmeasured compositions. Fourth, the predictions and their uncertainties are used to determine which composition should be measured next. To minimize the total uncertainty in the predicted phase map, the composition with the largest uncertainty is chosen at each iteration. Once the total uncertainty falls below a threshold, we have a reasonable prediction of the phase map of the entire composition space after only measuring a fraction of the composition space. Autonomous experiments require a machine learning surrogate model for the property of interest. Popular methods such as deep learning require lots of training data, which aren’t available for novel materials. The machine learning subfield of Few-Shot Learning (FSL) studies methods for such data-limited regimes 21 . Experimental materials science data are expensive and therefore limited in general, making some FSL techniques such as transfer learning (where knowledge from one data-rich task is transferred to another data-limited task) challenging 21 . Gaussian processes are a kernel machine learning method commonly used for the extrapolation step of the autonomous materials science workflow. Gaussian processes are an extension of Gaussian distributions: a Gaussian distribution describes the probability distribution of a random value, while a Gaussian process describes the probability distribution of a function 23 . A multivariate Gaussian distribution has a covariance matrix describing the relations between variables, and a Gaussian process has a covariance function describing the relations between function values. This covariance function is the kernel function of the Gaussian process. For more information on Gaussian processes and Gaussian process classification, see reference 23 . We used Gaussian process classification as implemented in GPflow 17 . Quantum kernel machine learning is an emerging area of research that may enable certain functions to be learned with less training data than classical kernel methods, making it a promising tool for autonomous materials discovery. Recent work by Huang et al. demonstrated that classical kernel models can predict the output of quantum kernel models if they are given sufficient training data 6 . However, we are especially interested in the data-limited regime where classical kernel models don’t have enough data to outperform quantum kernel models, such as in the first few iterations of the autonomous materials science workflow. As highlighted by the well-known ”No Free Lunch” Theorems 31 , the performance of a machine learning model fundamentally depends on the specific problem it is applied to. Therefore, the value of quantum kernel methods hinges on identifying problem domains where they offer a genuine advantage. Diffraction data might be such a domain where quantum kernel methods have an advantage. Scattering and diffraction (using X-ray, electrons, and neutrons) are ubiquitous characterization tools in materials science as they provide reciprocal representations of periodic atomic positions as well as their electronic and magnetic structures 9 . Diffraction data might provide a data platform on which quantum kernel models can learn faster than classical kernel models because the techniques used to represent diffraction (matrix inversion and the Fourier transform) are thought to be faster on quantum computers. The transformation from real space to reciprocal space can be written as a matrix inversion 9 , which is an application where quantum computers have an exponential advantage using the Harrow Hassidim Lloyd (HHL) algorithm 4 . While we don’t use either the HHL algorithm or the quantum Fourier transform in this work, the centrality of those problems to analysis of diffraction data suggests that diffraction datasets are a fruitful area to explore for a quantum kernel model advantage. In this work, we evaluate how well a quantum kernel model can learn an x-ray diffraction (XRD) dataset using IonQ’s Aria trapped ion quantum computer (see NIST Disclaimer). We introduce the XRD dataset and a corresponding typical autonomous materials science workflow, describe the classical and quantum kernels used, explain how we compared the kernels, show the results of the comparison, and discuss their implications. Lourenço et al. recently performed similar work with other, non diffraction materials science datasets: perovskite properties and doped nanoparticle relaxation 15 . This work presents a novel