Orbital Stability of Closely-Spaced Four-planet Systems Journal: Icarus
Bennet Outland, Gretchen Noble, Andrew W. Smith, Jack J. Lissauer · 2026
Read Orbital Stability of Closely-Spaced Four-planet Systems Journal: Icarus by Bennet Outland, Gretchen Noble, Andrew W. Smith, Jack J. Lissauer (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-11692.txt.
Introduction
Bennet Outland, Gretchen Noble, Andrew Smith, and Jack Lissauer test tight four-planet systems. Their 2026 preprint studies orbital stability in such systems. Each system holds four Earth-mass planets around one star. The star has one solar mass in the simulations.
Planets start on circular, coplanar orbits at set spacing. The innermost planet sits at 1 AU from the star. Later semimajor axes are spaced by mutual Hill radii. Equal Hill spacing packs the planets closely together. The team runs simulations to see how long order lasts. Closely spaced systems may collide or eject a planet. The results inform how packed real exoplanet systems can be.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bennet Outland, Gretchen Noble, Andrew W. Smith, Jack J. Lissauer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-11692
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Orbital Stability of Closely-Spaced Four-planet Systems Journal: Icarus Bennet Outland, Gretchen Noble, Andrew W. Smith, Jack J. Lissauer Abstract We investigate the orbital dynamics of four-planet systems consisting of Earth-mass planets on initially-circular, coplanar orbits around a star of one solar mass. In our simulations, the innermost planet’s semimajor axis is set at 1 AU, with subsequent semimajor axes spaced equally in terms of planets’ mutual Hill radii. Several sets of initial planetary longitudes are investigated, with integrations continuing for up to 10 10 10^{10} orbits of the innermost planet, stopping if a pair of planets pass within 0.01 AU of each other or if a planet is ejected from the system. We find that the simulated lifetimes of four-planet systems follow the general trend of increasing exponentially with planetary spacing, as seen by previous studies of closely-spaced planets. Four-planet system lifetimes are intermediate between those of three- and five-planet systems and more similar to the latter. Moreover, as with five-planet systems, but in marked contrast to the three-planet case, no initial semimajor axes spacings are found to yield systems that survive several orders of magnitude longer than other similar spacings. First- and second-order mean-motion resonances (MMRs) between planets correlate with reductions in system lifetimes. Additionally, we find that third-order MMRs between planets on neighboring orbits also have a substantial, though smaller, destabilizing effect on systems very near resonance that otherwise would be very long-lived. Local extrema of system lifetimes as a function of planetary spacing occur at slightly smaller initial orbital separation for systems with planets initially at conjunction relative to those in which the planets begin on widely-separated longitudes. This shift is produced by the asymmetric mutual planetary perturbations as the planets separate in longitude from the initial aligned configuration that cause orbits to spread out in semimajor axis. 1 Introduction Over the past two decades, \sim 1000 multi-planet systems have been discovered, most by NASA’s Kepler and TESS spacecraft and radial velocity observations. Analysis of photometric data from Kepler ’s prime mission has revealed 709 candidate multi-planet systems, many of which include planets on closely-spaced orbits ( 10 ) . Pioneering numerical calculations of the stability of multi-planet systems were done at the dawn of the exoplanet era by 3 , followed by numerous subsequent studies, including several that focused on systems of three or five Earth-mass planets orbiting a solar mass star as in 17 , 11 , and 1 . 18 studied systems with many co-orbital planets. However, the stability of four-planet systems has not been studied extensively. We numerically investigate the orbital dynamics of tens of thousands of hypothetical four-planet systems consisting of Earth-mass planets on initially-circular, geometrically-spaced, coplanar orbits around a star of one solar mass over a wide range of initial semimajor axes spacings and with several different initial longitudinal prescriptions. This is done to also study the effects of initial longitudes on the system lifetimes and thereby build upon the investigation of 9 . In Section 2 , we describe the integration techniques used and the orbital parameter space investigated. Results of our four-planet integrations are presented in Section 3 , together with parameters for exponential fits to system lifetime as a function of initial orbital separation for various sets of initial longitudes and number of planets in the system, where the exponential trend was analytically elucidated in 12 . Section 4 compares lifetimes of systems with three, four and five planets and examines the effects of mean-motion resonances (MMRs). When comparing the lifetimes of systems with different initial longitudinal spacings, we observe a “phase-shifting”, an offset in the orbital spacing corresponding with local maxima or minima in lifetimes, explored in Section 5 . A summary of our results and their implications can be seen in Section 6 . 2 Methods Each of the simulated planetary systems consists of a star with one solar mass, M \bigodot , that is orbited by (in most cases four) planets, each with mass equal to that of Earth, M \bigoplus . The planets are coplanar and travel in the same direction on initially-circular orbits. The innermost planet has an initial semimajor axis of 1 AU, and subsequent planets are spaced such that the initial orbital period ratios of neighboring planets are equal, in keeping with several previously published studies such as 17 , 11 , 9 , 1 , and 7 . Numerical integrations in this work assume Newtonian mechanics and are performed using a symplectic (Hamiltonian-based) integrator. The systems are integrated step-wise using an implementation of the Wisdom-Holman algorithmic integrator, WHFast, in the Rebound integration package by 15 . A simulation time step of 1/(20+1/\lambda)\approx 0.0485 times the inner planet’s initial orbital period was used, where \lambda is the golden ratio: \lambda\equiv\frac{5^{\frac{1}{2}}+1}{2}. (1) Thus, the time step is slightly less than 5% of the inner planets’ orbital period, with the ratio being an irrational number to minimize the possibility of a resonance between the number of orbits and the number of time steps. This time step further strikes a balance between computational efficiency and accuracy, following 7 . 2.1 Initial Semimajor Axes We measure the initial semimajor axis separation of neighboring planets in units of their mutual Hill radius, R_{H_{j,j+1}} , using the following recursive equation to calculate the mutual Hill radius for each neighboring pair of planets: R_{H_{j,j+1}}=\left[\frac{2M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}}{3M_{j}}\right]^{\frac{1}{3}}\frac{(a_{j}+a_{j+1})}{2}=\left[\frac{2M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}}{3(M\textsubscript{$\bigodot$}+(j-1)M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$})}\right]^{\frac{1}{3}}\frac{(a_{j}+a_{j+1})}{2}, (2) where a_{j} is the semimajor axis of the j th planet. The innermost planet has j=1 and the index of each succeeding planet is one greater than that of its immediate inner neighbor. The mass within the orbit of the j th planet is denoted M_{j} and is given by: M_{j}=M_{\star}+\sum_{k=1}^{j-1}m_{k}=M\textsubscript{$\bigodot$}+(j-1)M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}, (3) where M_{\star} and m_{k} are the central star’s mass and the mass of the k th planet (whose orbit is interior to that of the j th planet), respectively. We define a non-dimensional quantity, \beta , to specify the spacing between the initial semimajor axes of neighboring planets: \beta\equiv\frac{a_{j+1}-a_{j}}{R_{H_{j,j+1}}}. (4) Substituting Equation ( 2 ) into Equation ( 4 ) yields a recursive equation for the semimajor axes of the planets: a_{j}+\beta\left(\frac{M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}}{12(M\textsubscript{$\bigodot$})+(j-1)M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$})}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}}\frac{(a_{j}+a_{j+1})}{2}=a_{j+1}. (5) Algebraic manipulations of Equation ( 5 ) yield: a_{j+1}=a_{j}\left[1+\beta\left(\frac{M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}}{12(M\textsubscript{$\bigodot$}+(j-1)M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$})}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}}\right]\left[1-\beta\left(\frac{M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$}}{12(M\textsubscript{$\bigodot$}+(j-1)M\textsubscript{$\bigoplus$})}\right)^{\frac{1}{3}}\right]^{-1}, (6) which can be used to calculate the initial semimajor axes of the (j+1)^{\rm th} planet from that of its inner neighbor. 2.2 Initial Longitudes Given the assumptions of coplanar, initially-circular orbits, the only remaining orbital parameters that we need to specify are the initial orbital longitudes for each planet. We choose coordinates so that this angle is zero for the innermost planet. For the remaining planets, we investigate multiple sets of initial longitudes, including the longitudes used by 17 (henceforth referred to as the SL09 longitudes), Aligned longitudes (all planets with a true anomaly of zero), Hexagonal longitudes, three distinct sets of longitudes with the planets approaching conjunction, and random, independently-drawn, longitudes. The formulas for each set of longitudes are given in Table 1 , and a visual representation of four of these longitude combinations (including the most widely-spaced set of longitudes approaching conjunction, \Delta_{10} ) is displayed in Figure 1 . Table 1 : Initial longitude prescriptions (in radians) used for our investigation into four-planet systems. For each of the formulas, j is the planetary index. Longitudes