Handcrafted Feature–Assisted One-Class Learning for Artist Authentication in Historical Drawings

Hassan Ugail, Jan Ritch-Frel, Irina Matuzava · 2026

Read Handcrafted Feature–Assisted One-Class Learning for Artist Authentication in Historical Drawings by Hassan Ugail, Jan Ritch-Frel, Irina Matuzava (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-11627.txt.

Introduction

Hassan Ugail, Jan Ritch-Frel, and Irina Matuzava authenticate historical drawings. Their 2026 preprint uses handcrafted features with one-class learning. Attribution of works on paper is a persistent challenge. Reference corpora are often small for a given artist.

Style in drawings lives in line and limited tonal range. The team builds a verification-based computational framework. One-class autoencoders learn from genuine works alone. Their inputs are a compact set of handcrafted features. Those features are interpretable, not black-box embeddings. The system judges if a new drawing fits the artist. Cultural heritage gains a tool for disputed sheets. Small corpora are the norm the design respects.

Catalog record

CREATORHassan Ugail, Jan Ritch-Frel, Irina Matuzava
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE54 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-11627

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Handcrafted Feature–Assisted One-Class Learning for Artist Authentication in Historical Drawings Hassan Ugail, Jan Ritch-Frel, Irina Matuzava Abstract Authentication and attribution of works on paper remain persistent challenges in cultural heritage, particularly when the available reference corpus is small and stylistic cues are primarily expressed through line and limited tonal variation. We present a verification-based computational framework for historical drawing authentication using one-class autoencoders trained on a compact set of interpretable handcrafted features. Ten artist-specific verifiers are trained using authenticated sketches from the Metropolitan Museum of Art open-access collection, the Ashmolean Collections Catalogue, the Morgan Library and Museum, the Royal Collection Trust (UK), the Victoria and Albert Museum Collections, and an online catalogue of the Casa Buonarroti collection and evaluated under a biometric-style protocol with genuine and impostor trials. Feature vectors comprise Fourier-domain energy, Shannon entropy, global contrast, GLCM-based homogeneity, and a box-counting estimate of fractal complexity. Across 900 verification decisions (90 genuine and 810 impostor trials), the pooled system achieves a True Acceptance Rate of 83.3% with a False Acceptance Rate of 9.5% at the chosen operating point. Performance varies substantially by artist, with near-zero false acceptance for some verifiers and elevated confusability for others. A pairwise attribution of false accepts indicates structured error pathways consistent with stylistic proximity and shared drawing conventions, whilst also motivating tighter control of digitisation artefacts and threshold calibration. The proposed methodology is designed to complement, rather than replace, connoisseurship by providing reproducible, quantitative evidence suitable for data-scarce settings common in historical sketch attribution. Keywords: Art authentication; one-class learning; autoencoder; anomaly detection; sketch analysis; cultural heritage; biometric verification; handcrafted features 1 Introduction 1.1 Context and motivation The authentication and attribution of historical artworks are central concerns in art history, conservation, and the art market. For works on paper, these concerns are intensified by the material and documentary conditions under which drawings survive: sketchbooks may be dispersed, sheets may be trimmed or mounted, and many works exist in multiple states or workshop contexts. Connoisseurship remains indispensable in this domain, yet it is intrinsically difficult to formalise, reproduce, and quantify, particularly when disputes arise, and decision-makers require transparent evidence beyond expert opinion [ 1 , 2 ] . Computational methods offer a complementary mode of evidence. In particular, the evaluation logic of biometric verification provides an appealing analogue: an input sample is verified against a target identity, and system performance is characterised by false acceptance and false rejection under explicit operating points. In art authentication, the “identity” is the target artist, and impostor trials represent non-target artists (and, in principle, forgeries). This framing aligns with the open-set nature of attribution, where it is rarely possible to enumerate all plausible non-target classes. Recent advances in machine learning have demonstrated impressive results for art attribution when large labelled datasets are available. A comprehensive review of the use of artificial intelligence in art authentication is provided by Cetinic and She (2022), who document the field’s shift from traditional computer vision methods toward deep neural networks [ 3 ] . Building on this trend, vision transformers have been applied to artist attribution, with self-attention mechanisms enabling state-of-the-art performance [ 4 ] . In parallel, graph neural networks have been shown to effectively model stylistic relationships between artworks, capturing higher-level structural dependencies beyond pixel-based features [ 5 ] . Despite these advances, such approaches generally depend on thousands of examples per artist, a requirement that is rarely met in the context of historical sketches. 1.2 Data scarcity and the rationale for one-class verification Deep supervised attribution methods generally require large labelled datasets and benefit from broad negative sampling [ 6 ] . Historical sketches rarely satisfy these conditions. Even for major artists, the number of authenticated drawings available as consistent digital surrogates is limited; moreover, intra-artist variability can be substantial because sketches are often rapid, exploratory studies rather than finished works [ 7 ] . These constraints motivate one-class learning, where the model learns a representation of the authentic distribution of a single artist and flags deviations as anomalous [ 8 , 9 ] . One-class verification is particularly appropriate when negative classes are heterogeneous, incompletely characterised, or strategically adversarial (as in forgery scenarios) [ 10 ] . The challenge of limited training data is not unique to art authentication. Few-shot learning approaches have been explored in various domains [ 11 ] , but these typically still require more examples than are available for many historical artists. Transfer learning from pre-trained models offers another avenue [ 12 ] , but the domain gap between natural images and historical sketches can be substantial. One-class learning sidesteps these issues by focusing solely on modelling the authentic distribution without requiring comprehensive negative examples. 1.3 The role of handcrafted features in data-scarce settings Whilst end-to-end deep learning has dominated recent work in computer vision, handcrafted features retain important advantages in data-scarce scenarios. They reduce sample complexity through dimensionality reduction, provide interpretability enabling expert validation, incorporate domain knowledge, and offer robustness to distribution shift [ 13 ] . For sketch authentication, where colour information is limited and style is expressed primarily through line work, tonal distribution, and mark-making patterns, carefully designed handcrafted features can capture essential stylistic signals whilst remaining trainable with minimal data. Texture features derived from Grey-Level Co-occurrence Matrices have proven effective for distinguishing artistic techniques [ 14 , 15 ] . Frequency domain analysis reveals characteristic patterns in how artists distribute spatial frequencies [ 16 , 17 ] . Fractal analysis captures the hierarchical complexity of mark-making [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Information-theoretic measures quantify tonal complexity and distributional properties [ 21 , 22 ] . By combining complementary features operating at different scales, we can construct compact yet informative representations suitable for one-class learning. 1.4 Scope and contributions This study develops a reproducible verification framework for sketch authentication under severe data constraints. The central methodological contribution is an artist-specific, one-class autoencoder verifier trained on interpretable handcrafted features that are well suited to line-dominant media. The empirical contribution is a multi-artist evaluation across ten historical artists, reporting both pooled and artist-specific biometric metrics with Wilson confidence intervals, along with a structured attribution of false-accept pathways to identify systematic confusability between artists. Our principal contributions are as follows: • A novel application of one-class autoencoder architecture to historical sketch authentication, demonstrating effective discrimination despite severe data scarcity (20 training images per artist). • Identification and formal definition of five complementary handcrafted features—Fourier energy, Shannon entropy, contrast, GLCM homogeneity, and box-counting fractal dimension—that effectively capture artistic style in sketch media. • Comprehensive multi-artist evaluation using a rigorous biometric verification framework with 900 trials, reporting performance metrics with Wilson binomial confidence intervals appropriate for small sample sizes. • Pairwise confusion attribution revealing structured error pathways that provide insights into artistic relationships and stylistic proximity. • A methodological framework suitable for extension to other historical artists and potentially applicable to other domains of art authentication where training data is inherently limited. 2 Related Work 2.1 Machine learning in art authentication Research on computational art analysis spans traditional feature engineering, modern deep learning, and hybrid approaches. Surveys in computer vision applied to art have highlighted both the promise of machine learning for attribution and the practical

Read the complete text