Let Me Try Again: Examining Replay Behavior by Tracing Students’ Latent Problem-Solving Pathways Conference: LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference; April 27-May 01, 2026; Bergen, Norway LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference (LAK 2026),

Shan Zhang, Siddhartha Pradhan, Ji-Eun Lee, Ashish Gurung, Anthony F. Botelho · 2026

Read Let Me Try Again: Examining Replay Behavior by Tracing Students’ Latent Problem-Solving Pathways Conference: LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference; April 27-May 01, 2026; Bergen, Norway LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference (LAK 2026), by Shan Zhang, Siddhartha Pradhan, Ji-Eun Lee, Ashish Gurung, Anthony F. Botelho (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-11586.txt.

Introduction

Shan Zhang and four coauthors trace how students replay problems in games. Their 2026 preprint studies latent problem-solving pathways in learners. Game-based learning logs each move a student makes. Pathways through problems reflect understanding and procedural skill.

Flexibility in approach also shows in those pathways. Replay behavior is the paper's special focus. Replaying may signal productive struggle or broad exploration. Both can foster deeper learning when they pay off. Little is known about how pathways unfold across problems. Timing of replays and strategies is also unclear. The team links those patterns to near and far learning outcomes.

Catalog record

CREATORShan Zhang, Siddhartha Pradhan, Ji-Eun Lee, Ashish Gurung, Anthony F. Botelho
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-11586

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Let Me Try Again: Examining Replay Behavior by Tracing Students’ Latent Problem-Solving Pathways Conference: LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference; April 27-May 01, 2026; Bergen, Norway LAK26: 16th International Learning Analytics and Knowledge Conference (LAK 2026), April 27-May 01, 2026, Bergen, Norway DOI: 10.1145/3785022.3785093 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2066-6/2026/04 CCS: Applied computing Computer-assisted instruction CCS: Applied computing Distance learning CCS: Applied computing Education Shan Zhang, Siddhartha Pradhan, Ji-Eun Lee, Ashish Gurung, Anthony F. Botelho Abstract . Prior research has shown that students’ problem-solving pathways in game-based learning environments reflect their conceptual understanding, procedural knowledge, and flexibility. Replay behaviors, in particular, may indicate productive struggle or broader exploration, which in turn foster deeper learning. However, little is known about how these pathways unfold sequentially across problems or how the timing of replays and other problem-solving strategies relates to proximal and distal learning outcomes. This study addresses these gaps using Markov Chains and Hidden Markov Models (HMMs) on log data from 777 seventh graders playing the game-based learning platform of From Here to There!. Results show that within problem sequences, students often persisted in states or engaged in immediate replay after successful completions, while across problems, strong self-transitions indicated stable strategic pathways. Four latent states emerged from HMMs: Incomplete-dominant, Optimal-ending, Replay, and Mixed. Regression analyses revealed that engagement in replay-dominant and optimal-ending states predicted higher conceptual knowledge, flexibility, and performance compared with the Incomplete-dominant state. Immediate replay consistently supported learning outcomes, whereas delayed replay was weakly or negatively associated in relation to Non-Replay. These findings suggest that replay in digital learning is not uniformly beneficial but depends on timing, with immediate replay supporting flexibility and more productive exploration. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Learning from practice is not simply a matter of doing more. Research shows that the strategic intent and quality of practice may be just as, if not more important than, the sheer quantity of opportunities ( 15 ; 8 ; 14 ) . In particular, studies have found that practice designed to deliberately vary problems and encourage learners to compare and explain alternative methods (e.g. through interleaving or side-by-side example comparisons) can support deeper knowledge as well as learning transfer (i.e. the ability to apply practiced skills in unfamiliar topics ( 52 ) ) and improved recall ( 3 ; 17 ; 51 ) ; by purposefully engaging in different problem-solving strategies, students can become more attuned to key problem features and the affordances of different approaches, which enables them to move beyond the rote application of procedure toward a stronger conceptual understanding ( 47 ; 3 ; 46 ) . This adaptability, as fostered through practice, has often been studied under the construct of procedural flexibility ( 53 ) , which can be operationalized as the capacity to generate multiple solution strategies for a given problem and the ability to adaptively select among them. Procedural flexibility reflects both the breadth and depth of a learner’s skill and knowledge, highlighting not only whether students can produce alternative approaches but also whether they can recognize which strategies are most effective under particular conditions. One common way to cultivate this flexibility is by revisiting practice problems with alternative solution methods ( 45 ) ; such an approach allows for structured comparisons to discern connections between surface features and deeper principles across problems while also revealing when certain strategies are effective or prone to error. These processes are closely linked to the development of procedural fluency, deeper conceptual understanding, and greater knowledge transfer. In game-based learning environments, opportunities to develop and demonstrate procedural flexibility emerge in distinctive ways. In such contexts, students rarely follow a single uniform path to a solution ( 33 ; 41 ) . Instead, they navigate diverse problem-solving pathways (i.e. the distinct series of attempts students make within or even across learning opportunities as they progress or revisit earlier problems), ranging from exploratory trial-and-error to more intentional strategies that build on prior knowledge. Research has shown that these varied pathways not only capture differences in efficiency but also reflect important aspects of students’ conceptual understanding, procedural knowledge, and flexibility in mathematics learning ( 33 ; 25 ; 4 ) . Examining transitions among pathways is critical, as shifts can signal moments of struggle (both productive ( 59 ) and unproductive ( 25 ; 16 ) ), disengagement ( 18 ) , or adaptive strategy use. Building on these considerations, this paper examines how students navigate problem-solving pathways both within and across problems using data from From Here to There! (FH2T) ( 41 ) , a gamified version of Graspable Math ( 31 ) ; similar to other platforms such as Spatial Temporal (ST) Math ( 34 ) , FH2T is designed to support procedural flexibility by offering learners the opportunity to re-attempt, or “replay,” problems as an optional feature rather than a structured requirement. Prior work in FH2T has categorized pathways as optimal, suboptimal, or incomplete, showing that exploratory attempts correlate with student learning, while frequent reliance on optimal solutions may reduce flexibility ( 41 ) . It remains unclear, however, how sequences and transitions among pathways — particularly around replayed attempts — relate to learning and measures of student flexibility. The present study addresses these gaps by leveraging probabilistic sequence models to capture and analyze the dynamics of students’ problem-solving pathways to examine how emergent strategies relate to both proximal (short-term) and distal (long-term) learning outcomes. Specifically, we seek to address the following research questions: RQ 1. How do students transition among different problem-solving strategies, both within individual problems and across their broader problem sequences? RQ 2. (a) What latent problem-solving states emerge when modeling students’ complete problem sequences? (b) What prominent transitions emerge across these states? RQ 3. To what extent do students’ latent problem-solving states predict their proximal and distal learning outcomes across-problem levels? RQ 4. How are students’ replay behaviors associated with their proximal and distal learning outcomes? 2. Related Work 2.1. Sub-constructs of Algebraic Learning Mastery over algebra requires not only conceptual and procedural knowledge, but also the ability to apply this knowledge flexibly ( 48 ) . 44 define conceptual understanding as the verbal and non-verbal knowledge of algebraic concepts and principles, such as algebraic symbols and conventions ( 44 ) . In complement, procedural knowledge concerns the ordering of algebraic steps or transformations (i.e., the knowledge of the rules and procedures) required to solve a problem ( 44 ) . These two forms of knowledge are closely related and often intersect; while conceptual knowledge enables the acquisition of procedural knowledge ( 43 ) , purposeful and sustained procedural practice can also build and strengthen conceptual knowledge ( 44 ; 49 ) . Together, conceptual and procedural knowledge provide the foundation for math flexibility, defined as a student’s capacity to generate multiple potential solutions and then choose the one that is most efficient or appropriate for a given problem ( 45 ) . Developing this flexibility not only improves problem-solving efficiency but also supports transfer to unfamiliar problems where reliance on a single memorized procedure may be insufficient. Flexibility has been recognized internationally as a core goal of mathematics instruction ( 22 ) , but fostering it in practice is challenging. Instruction

Read the complete text