Optimal e-values for testing the mean of a bounded random variable against a composite alternative

Sebastian Arnold, Eugenio Clerico · 2026

Read Optimal e-values for testing the mean of a bounded random variable against a composite alternative by Sebastian Arnold, Eugenio Clerico (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-11347.txt.

Introduction

Sebastian Arnold and Eugenio Clerico find best e-values for a mean test. Their 2026 preprint deals with bounded random variables in statistics. An e-value is a newer tool for testing claims with data. It can grow as evidence piles up against a null claim.

The test asks if a mean beats a set rival value. The rival side is composite, a range and not a point. The team derives the unique e-values with best growth. Growth is judged in the worst case, in relative terms. The quality bar comes from work by Grunwald and others. Their frame first asked for matching hypothesis setups. This work is the first use past that strict setup.

Catalog record

CREATORSebastian Arnold, Eugenio Clerico
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-11347

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Optimal e-values for testing the mean of a bounded random variable against a composite alternative Sebastian Arnold, Eugenio Clerico Abstract We derive the unique e-values with optimal (relative) growth rate in the worst case for testing the mean of a bounded random variable, hereby contributing with the first application beyond the assumption of mutually absolutely continuous hypotheses of the (RE)GROW quality criteria for e-values originally proposed by Grünwald et al. (2024). For both criteria, we characterise explicitly the alternatives for which it is most difficult to test against, which also admit a meaningful interpretation. We give two important examples of interest where REGROW provides a powerful quality criterion to choose optimal e-variables whereas GROW leads to trivial solutions. Keywords: e-variable; optimal growth rate; nonparametric mean-testing; convex envelope. 1 Introduction E-values are a statistical tool for measuring evidence against a null hypothesis that has attracted increasing interest in recent years as a flexible and safe alternative to p-values; see, e.g., 4 , 14 , and 9 . Formally, an e-value is the observed value (on the data) of an e-variable , a non-negative random variable whose expectation is bounded by 1 under the null hypothesis. From this definition, Markov’s inequality ensures that large e-values are unlikely under the null (for any \alpha\in[0,1] , the probability that an e-value is larger than 1/\alpha is at most \alpha ). As a consequence, the magnitude of an observed e-value directly quantifies statistical evidence against the null hypothesis: the larger an e-value the stronger the evidence in favour of rejection. Thus, by rejecting for sufficiently large values, e-values can be used to obtain valid type-I error control in hypothesis testing problems. Notably, the primary strength of e-values does not lie in the classical testing framework, in which both the data set and the significance level are fixed in advance (and where p-values are often more powerful), but rather in the fact that their validity is preserved under natural operations, such as convex combinations and, under independence, multiplication. This makes e-values a flexible tool for aggregating evidence across multiple experiments, or for adaptive analyses when data come in sequentially over time. For a comprehensive introduction to the theory and use of e-values, we refer to the recent monograph by 10 . A natural question when testing with e-values is how to choose an appropriate e-variable to use. This choice is typically tackled after specifying an alternative hypothesis: in addition to the null \mathcal{P} , we fix a particular alternative hypothesis \mathcal{Q} that we consider especially relevant, in the sense that we would like to ensure rejection of \mathcal{P} whenever the data are generated from \mathcal{Q} . In the classical Neyman-Pearson framework, this leads to selecting a test that, for a fixed significance level, maximises power against \mathcal{Q} (namely the probability of a rejection under \mathcal{Q} ) subject to type-I error control. In analogy, we aim to construct valid \mathcal{P} -e-variables that are as ‘powerful’ as possible against \mathcal{Q} . However, the Neyman-Pearson notion of power is often not the most informative criterion for e-values. Indeed, optimising rejection probability at a fixed significance level \alpha ties the construction to that level, thereby discarding information about the magnitude of the evidence, and effectively reduces the output to a binary decision. This is at odds with the interpretation of e-values as quantitative measures of evidence that can be meaningfully accumulated across experiments independent of an accept/reject decision ( 12 ) , and ignores the fact that e-values allow for post-hoc choices of \alpha ( 3 ) . The classical notion of power is therefore not a suitable criterion for e-values. When the alternative hypothesis \mathcal{Q} is simple (namely, it consists of a single distribution Q ), the most commonly adopted notion of ‘power’ for an e-variable E is the expected growth rate (or e-power ) \mathbb{E}_{Q}[\log E] , which quantifies the rate at which evidence accumulates under the alternative. Maximising this quantity is well motivated by arguments from gambling theory, information theory, and finance (see, for instance, 4 and 12 , while 6 provides a discussion of alternative utility functions beyond the logarithm). A central result in the theory of e-values states that there exists a ( Q -almost surely) unique e-variable E^{\star}_{Q} maximising \mathbb{E}_{Q}[\log E] among all valid e-variables. This optimal e-variable can always be expressed as a generalized likelihood ratio between Q and a (sub)probability measure in the effective null, and is referred to as the growth-rate optimal (GRO) or numéraire e-variable; see 4 and 6 . Whereas the expected growth rate provides a natural optimality criterion for simple alternatives, its extension to composite alternatives (namely families of distributions) is far from straightforward. In this paper, following 4 , we study two possible optimality criteria for e-variables when facing a composite alternative \mathcal{Q} : GROW (growth rate optimal in the worst case) and REGROW (relative growth rate optimal in the worst case). 4 show that both criteria admit almost surely unique maximisers, referred to as GROW e-variable and REGROW e-variable , respectively, if we assume that all the measures in both the null \mathcal{P} and the alternative \mathcal{Q} admit densities with respect to a common reference measure. We refer to this condition as the absolute continuity assumption . At present, general existence and characterisation results for GROW and REGROW e-variables are only known under the absolute continuity assumption, and extensions to broader settings of non-dominated hypotheses remain largely unexplored. In this paper, we consider these criteria for the problem of testing the mean of a bounded real-valued random variable. More precisely, we focus on hypotheses like \mathcal{P}=\{\text{The mean is ($\leq$) $\mu_{0}$}\} against \mathcal{Q}=\{\text{The mean is ($>$) $\mu_{1}$}\} . Although this pair of hypotheses does not satisfy the absolute continuity assumption, we show that the GROW and REGROW e-variables are nevertheless well defined and admit a simple characterisation. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first result of this kind for non-dominated hypotheses. Existence and characterisation of (RE)GROW e-variables beyond the absolute continuity assumption addresses open problems of current research. Indeed, counter-intuitive examples of e-variables which have infinite expected log-growth, and at the same moment very high probability being strictly smaller than 1 under the alternative (or vice-versa, e-variables with expected log growth -\infty , and simultaneously very high probability for being significantly large) show that there are many subtleties in defining powerful or optimal e-variables and that further research and analysis is needed to fully understand e-power’s advantages and limitations ( 15 ) . Our analysis builds on recent work by 1 , which shows that the coin-betting e-class , a simple subclass of e-variables parametrised by a single scalar parameter, forms the minimal complete e-variable class for the testing problem that we consider. Informally, this implies that every valid e-variable is pointwise dominated by a member of this class. As a consequence, when searching for (RE)GROW e-variables, it is sufficient to restrict attention to the coin-betting e-class. This, together with standard convex analysis tools, allows us to characterise the resulting optimal e-variables analytically. 2 Preliminaries Notations and definitions. Let \mathcal{X}=[a,b] , for -\infty<a<b<\infty , endowed with the standard real topology and its Borel sigma-field. We let \mathscr{P} be the set of Borel probability measures

Read the complete text