Pink Dwarfs and the Paths to Stardom: How Brown Dwarfs Pushed Above the Hydrogen Burning Limit Evolve

Jaime Luisi, John C. Forbes, Heather V. Rusk, Benjamin Gullick · 2026

Read Pink Dwarfs and the Paths to Stardom: How Brown Dwarfs Pushed Above the Hydrogen Burning Limit Evolve by Jaime Luisi, John C. Forbes, Heather V. Rusk, Benjamin Gullick (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10908.txt.

Introduction

Jaime Luisi, John C. Forbes, Heather V. Rusk, and Benjamin Gullick follow brown dwarfs that gain mass and cross into stardom. A brown dwarf that steals mass from a binary partner can pass the hydrogen burning limit. That limit divides brown dwarfs from true low-mass stars. The authors call the crossers pink dwarfs and trace their fates.

Some reach the main sequence and end up looking like ordinary low-mass stars. Others stay brown dwarf-like, unable to burn hydrogen fast enough to power their glow. The split decides what telescopes will see millions of years later. The work helps astronomers read odd stars whose past hides a stolen-mass chapter.

Catalog record

CREATORJaime Luisi, John C. Forbes, Heather V. Rusk, Benjamin Gullick
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10908

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pink Dwarfs and the Paths to Stardom: How Brown Dwarfs Pushed Above the Hydrogen Burning Limit Evolve Jaime Luisi, John C. Forbes, Heather V. Rusk, Benjamin Gullick Abstract Brown dwarfs that gain mass through binary interactions may be pushed above the boundary that divides brown dwarfs from low-mass stars: the hydrogen burning limit (HBL). Some of these objects will make their way to the main sequence and may eventually be indistinguishable from ordinary low-mass stars, while others will remain brown dwarf-like, unable to burn hydrogen at a high enough rate to power their surface luminosity. We study the evolution of both types of object to provide a taxonomy and testable observational predictions for these objects depending on their evolutionary path. Using MESA simulations, we find that a subset of the objects that will eventually become stars experience an extended luminosity plateau, where their surface luminosity remains nearly constant on 100 Myr - Gyr timescales. We find that the plateau timescale is set by the amount of energy required to re-heat the cores of these objects to a level sufficient to sustain convection. The timescales required for the cores of these objects to “unfreeze” and arrive at the main sequence is long enough that surveys may be able to find objects in this evolutionary stage. These objects, along with those that never reach the main sequence, occupy a unique space in a mass-luminosity diagram, and would provide a unique constraint on binary mass transfer physics. \journalinfo The Open Journal of Astrophysics 1 Introduction Brown dwarfs are popularly known as ‘failed stars’. They have too little mass to stably burn hydrogen in their cores, so they exist below the hydrogen burning limit (HBL). The existence of brown dwarfs was first predicted theoretically by S. Kumar in the 1960s ( Kumar 1962a ; Kumar 1962b ; Kumar 1963a ; Kumar 1963b ; Kumar 2003 ) , and they were definitively discovered over 30 years later ( Nakajima et al. 1995 ; Oppenheimer et al. 1995 ) . Brown dwarfs have served as important test cases for the physics of stellar and planetary atmospheres given the complexities of cloud formation and chemistry ( Burrows et al. 1997 ; Allard et al. 1997 ; Allard et al. 2001 ; Allard et al. 2011 ; Allard et al. 2012 ; Morley et al. 2012 ; Marley et al. 2021 , e.g.) . Figure 1: A schematic diagram. The coloured arrows represent the paths the different stellar and substellar objects take as they evolve on a plot of mass against \psi , the thermal energy per particle in units of the Fermi energy in the star’s core. Lower values of \psi indicate colder and more degenerate cores. The separately coloured regions and their corresponding outline arrows indicate what direction an object would move. In the pink region within the parabola, objects have a nuclear luminosity, L_{\mathrm{nuc}} , greater than their surface luminosity, L_{\mathrm{surf}} and they evolve to the right as their cores heat up. In the blue region, L_{\mathrm{surf}}>L_{\mathrm{nuc}} , so objects evolve to the left as they radiate more energy than they generate. The black parabola is where L_{\mathrm{nuc}}=L_{\mathrm{surf}} . The solid right-hand side of the parabola represents the main sequence; it is stable to perturbations in \psi . The dashed left-hand side is unstable. The lowest mass on the parabola is the hydrogen burning limit, M HBL . The arrows for the red dwarf and brown dwarf are horizontal as these objects do not change their mass throughout their lives without an outside influence. Maroon, pink, and beige dwarfs begin as brown dwarfs and evolve leftwards until an episode of mass accretion results in them splitting off from the brown dwarf arrow vertically, at least in the case of fast accretion. When accretion has stopped, they then evolve horizontally to the left or right. Maroon dwarfs, like red dwarfs, evolve left and settle on the main sequence. Beige dwarfs end up above the hydrogen burning limit, but outside of the parabola, and so evolve left like a brown dwarf, never reaching the main sequence. A pink dwarf is located inside the parabola when mass has stopped accreting and then evolves to the right to settle on the main sequence. The ‘frozen cores/plateaus’ region in the parabola is the area in which a subset of our pink dwarf models have a frozen core or luminosity plateau (see Section 3 ). Brown dwarfs are typically distinguished from low-mass stars by their mass. Objects below the HBL mass M_{\mathrm{HBL}}\sim 0.075\ M_{\odot} at Solar metallicity 1 1 1 As metallicity increases, M_{\mathrm{HBL}} decreases ( Kumar 1963b ; Saumon et al. 1994 ) ( Chabrier et al. 2023 ) may be able to burn hydrogen in their cores, but not enough to supply the luminosity they radiate at their surface ( L_{\mathrm{surf}} ). Objects with masses exceeding M_{\mathrm{HBL}} however, will reach the main sequence, at which point their surface luminosity will be supplied solely by the luminosity of hydrogen burning ( L_{\mathrm{nuc}} ). Just above the HBL stars can remain in this stable hydrogen-burning state for \sim 10^{13} years, whereas just below M_{\mathrm{HBL}} , objects steadily cool, contract, and become more degenerate ( Burrows et al. 1997 ; Forbes & Loeb 2019 ) . While this mass-based distinction between brown dwarfs and stars holds broadly, binary interactions can complicate the picture. In particular, if a brown dwarf gains enough mass that it exceeds the HBL some time after its formation, it may take one of several paths depending on the degeneracy of its core at the time. If the core is sufficiently degenerate, Forbes & Loeb 2019 showed that the object would remain essentially brown dwarf-like, cooling and contracting, despite exceeding the HBL. They called these objects overmassive brown dwarfs. Forbes & Loeb 2019 proposed gravitational wave driven mass transfer in binary brown dwarf systems via Roche lobe overflow as the most plausible mechanism by which overmassive brown dwarfs could be formed astrophysically. This conclusion was based on the requirement that the mass transfer needed to happen gigayears after the formation of the brown dwarf to allow its core to become sufficiently degenerate. Majidi et al. 2022 showed, however, that this mechanism requires some fine-tuning because the brown dwarfs need to be extremely close together to merge in a Hubble time, in fact closer than the sizes of the brown dwarfs early in their lives. While this formation channel is still a possibility with dynamical capture or hardening of a tight binary, the intrinsic rarity of brown dwarf-brown dwarf binaries ( Close et al. 2003 ; Burgasser et al. 2006 ; Gelino et al. 2011 ; Fontanive et al. 2018 ; Fontanive et al. 2023 ) and the additional dynamical processing necessary, suggests that this channel should be rare. Majidi et al. 2022 instead considered the case of mass transfer from the slow winds of an asymptotic giant branch star being accreted by a brown dwarf companion, which can plausibly add enough mass to a brown dwarf to push it over the HBL gigayears after the formation of the brown dwarf (the main sequence lifetime of the donor star). This mechanism would result in an overmassive brown dwarf in a

Read the complete text