Is open robotics innovation a threat to international peace and security?
Ludovic Righetti, Vincent Boulanin · 2026
Read Is open robotics innovation a threat to international peace and security? by Ludovic Righetti, Vincent Boulanin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10877.txt.
Introduction
Ludovic Righetti and Vincent Boulanin ask whether open robotics innovation threatens peace and security. Open access to papers, software, and hardware is central to robotics. It lowers entry barriers, supports reproducible science, and speeds reliable system building. The same openness, they note, sharpens the dual-use risk built into robotics research.
Open tools lower the bar for states and non-state actors to build robots for military or harmful ends. The authors weigh that risk against the clear gains of openness. Their essay speaks to researchers, funders, and policymakers who must set the terms of sharing. It asks the field to face its security shadow without giving up what makes it thrive.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ludovic Righetti, Vincent Boulanin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10877
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Is open robotics innovation a threat to international peace and security? Ludovic Righetti, Vincent Boulanin Abstract Open access to publication, software and hardware is central to robotics: it lowers barriers to entry, supports reproducible science and accelerates reliable system development. However, openness also exacerbates the inherent dual-use risks associated with research and innovation in robotics. It lowers barriers for states and non-state actors to develop and deploy robotics systems for military use and harmful purposes. Compared to other fields of engineering where dual-use risks are present – e.g., those that underlie the development of weapons of mass destruction (chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear weapons) and even the field of AI, robotics offers no specific regulation and little guidance as to how research and innovation may be conducted and disseminated responsibly. While other fields can be used for guidance, robotics has its own needs and specificities which have to be taken into account. The robotics community should therefore work toward its own set of sector-specific guidance and possibly regulation. To that end, we propose a roadmap focusing on four practices: a) education in responsible robotics; b) incentivizing risk assessment; c) moderating the diffusion of high-risk material; and d) developing red lines. I Introduction The conflict in Ukraine has starkly illustrated the dual-use nature of robotics (see definition in Box 1). The ingenuity displayed by Ukrainian soldiers in repurposing and modifying commercially available drones for military applications has captured global attention [ 27 ] . The increasing affordability of commercial drones was certainly the main enabling factor, but it was not the only one. Advances in 3D printing and readily available open-source software and hardware have also made the production and modification of robotic systems easier and cheaper. Beyond Ukraine, this has notably increased the use of robotics by a much larger range of actors, including malicious actors such as rogue states, militias or terrorist groups. Dual-use risks associated with robotics have been known for a long time and are regularly discussed in policy conversations on arms control and international peace and security (e.g. the intergovernmental process on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems at the United Nations Conventions on Certain Conventional Weapons [ 34 ] ) and in debates within the technical and scientific community on responsible innovation and ethically aligned design [ 32 ] . These conversations, however, have so far paid little attention to the role of openness and especially open-source software and hardware in the dual-use risk equation. Admittedly, the breakthrough of generative AI has sparked a vivid debate in the technical and scientific community, and in mainstream media, on the risk of harm associated with openly publishing certain learned models [ 18 , 22 ] . That debate, however, has focused on advanced AI models and has primarily involved actors from the AI industry. To our knowledge, little has been written or said (at least publicly) about the dual-use challenges associated with openness in the specific context of robotics. Box 1. Defining dual-use [ 12 ] The term dual-use was coined in the 1990s by the US Office of Technology Assessment to underline that technologies that were underlying the development of weapons of mass destruction also had civilian and peaceful purposes. Over time, the use of the term has evolved. In arms control and export control circles, it commonly refers to technology that has both civilian and military use. In broader discussions about societal impact of technology, it is often used in an even broader sense to convey the general idea that technology may have “an intended use or primary purpose which is good (or at least not bad) and a secondary purpose or use which is potentially harmful and is not intended by those who developed the technology in the first place”. This framing is intended to encompass a broader series of uses than military activity. We use that latter broad definitional approach here. Fig. 1: Risk pathways: how openness in robotics creates risk to international peace and security. This article aims to lay the ground for an informed and nuanced discussion within the robotics community about the dual-use risks associated with open robotics. The immediate objective is to ensure that these risks are adequately considered in the conversations around “responsible robotics”. The longer-term objective is to support the emergence of norms and practices that can help roboticists uphold the principles of open research and innovation, which have been instrumental in the field’s rapid progress, while effectively mitigating the inherent dual-use risks associated with robotics technology. To that end, the article addresses three interrelated questions: 1) How openness in robotics may exacerbate dual-use risks associated with robotics research and innovation (Section II ), 2) What lessons can be learned from other disciplines as to how dual-use risk associated with openness may be mitigated (Section III ), and 3) What concrete steps could the robotics community take to ensure it is better prepared to address that problem (Section IV ). II Openness and dual-use risks in robotics Openness plays a pivotal role in accelerating the development of robotics technology. Open-access publication, software and educational content democratize state-of-the-art knowledge, facilitate reproducibility, accelerate research, and, importantly, foster a collaborative international community of scientists. There is no doubt that such resources should remain openly accessible. However, openness can also exacerbate the dual-use risks and cyber-security risks associated with robotics and represents for that reason a challenge for arms control, proliferation and international peace and security more broadly (cf. Figure 1 for an illustration of risk pathways). II-A Openness already exacerbates dual-use and misuse Recent history already provides evidence that openness in robotics could lower barriers to entry for state and non-state actors to develop and deploy robotics systems for military use and harmful purposes, or be used to enhance certain capabilities in existing weapon systems such as vision-based navigation, autonomous targeting, or swarming [ 37 ] . ROS, an open software ecosystem originally intended for civilian purposes, now supports the development of military robotic autonomous systems through ROS-M [ 26 ] . Meta’s Llama models are reportedly used by both the US [ 4 ] and Chinese [ 22 ] military. Betaflight, an open source multi-rotor flight control software, is now widely used by Ukrainian drone makers to develop kamikaze drones [ 17 ] . For almost a decade now, non-state armed groups, like the Islamic State, have been misusing commercially available drones and open source software like QGround to create novel ways to wage war and terrorist attacks in the Middle East and counter no-fly-zones [ 36 ] [ 3 ] . Obviously, military use does not necessarily equate misuse or harmful use. The point here is to recognize that the work roboticists make openly accessible can find totally different uses than the ones initially intended and that such uses can have implications for international peace and security. II-B Openness and the cybersecurity risk Furthermore, unless proper security measures and development practices are adopted, open-source software for robotics systems may also be vulnerable to cyberattacks [ 7 ] . Hackers could exploit vulnerabilities to gain control of robots, causing them to malfunction or be used for malicious purposes. The Open Source Security Foundation and Open JS Foundation reported recently that unknown