Chemically decisive benchmarks on the path to quantum utility

Srivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng ∗, Ayush Asthana ∗ · 2026

Read Chemically decisive benchmarks on the path to quantum utility by Srivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng ∗, Ayush Asthana ∗ (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10813.txt.

Introduction

Srivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng, and Ayush Asthana set out benchmarks meant to be decisive for quantum chemistry. Progress toward quantum utility needs more than better algorithms. It needs chemical problems whose electronic structure truly strains classical methods. Only then can a quantum machine prove its worth on a task that matters.

The authors curate a hierarchy of such benchmark systems. The sets probe distinct regimes of electron correlation. They span molecular, bioinorganic, and heavy-element chemistry. A shared ladder of hard cases lets teams compare machines and methods fairly. It also keeps the field honest about where quantum advantage is real and where it is still a hope.

Catalog record

CREATORSrivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng ∗, Ayush Asthana ∗
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10813

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Chemically decisive benchmarks on the path to quantum utility Preprint: APS/123-QED Srivathsan Poyyapakkam Sundar, Vibin Abraham, Bo Peng ∗, Ayush Asthana ∗ Abstract Progress towards quantum utility in chemistry requires not only algorithmic advances, but also the identification of chemically meaningful problems whose electronic structure fundamentally challenges classical methods. Here, we introduce a curated hierarchy of chemically decisive benchmark systems designed to probe distinct regimes of electronic correlation relevant to molecular, bioinorganic, and heavy-element chemistry. Moving beyond minimal toy models, our benchmark set spans multireference bond breaking (N 2 ), high-spin transition-metal chemistry (FeS), biologically relevant iron–sulfur clusters ([2Fe–2S]), and actinide–actinide bonding (U 2 ), which exhibits extreme sensitivity to active-space choice, relativistic treatment, and correlation hierarchy even within advanced multireference frameworks. As a concrete realization, we benchmark a recently developed automated and adaptive quantum algorithm based on generator-coordinate–inspired subspace expansion, ADAPT-GCIM, using a black-box workflow that integrates entropy-based active-space selection via the ActiveSpaceFinder tool. Across this chemically diverse problem set, ADAPT-GCIM achieves high accuracy in challenging correlation regimes. Equally importantly, these benchmarks expose general failure modes and design constraints—independent of any specific algorithm—highlighting the necessity of problem-aware and correlation-specific strategies for treating strongly correlated chemistry on quantum computers. To support systematic benchmarking and reproducible comparisons, the Hamiltonians for all systems studied are made openly available. I Introduction Quantum computers are expected to greatly expand our capacity to solve quantum chemistry problems with the most challenging electron correlation landscapes 68 ; 48 ; 13 ; 56 ; 47 ; 35 ; 12 ; 23 ; 47 . Although significant advances have been made in hardware and algorithms, we are still far from general quantum utility on useful problems. On computations side, major current challenges in the field include: (i) recognizing the problems to solve that are well suited for quantum computation, and (ii) developing quantum algorithms that solve them and are compatible with current hardware or the hardware of the foreseeable future. In selecting the suitable problems, the targets should be scientifically consequential—so that their solution yields genuine advances in understanding—and exhibit electronic correlation strong enough to lie beyond the reach of state-of-the-art classical quantum chemistry methods 34 ; 53 ; 1 ; 54 , including selected configuration-interaction methods and tensor network methods 31 ; 15 . On the algorithms side, the algorithms to use should be compatible with quantum computers available today or anticipated in the near future, spanning advanced NISQ devices and early fault-tolerant systems with the order of 10^{2}-10^{3} qubits 34 ; 1 ; 54 . In the algorithms developed to solve chemical problems using quantum computers, the variational quantum eigensolvers (VQE) are currently one of the most popular algorithms 56 ; 7 ; 2 ; 72 . However, VQE ansätze generally have many parameters and lack guarantees of exactness, leading to challenges in achieving desired quantum advantage in strongly correlated systems. These limitations have motivated the development of adaptive ansätze, such as ADAPT-VQE proposed by Grimsley et al. 26 , which aim to construct more compact and problem-tailored wavefunctions. Nevertheless, in the pre-fault-tolerant quantum hardware era, optimization-based algorithms, such as VQE and ADAPT-VQE, remain vulnerable to noise-induced instabilities, as the repeated evaluation of gradients and energy landscapes can be severely affected by hardware imperfections 9 . To address some of these challenges, Zheng et al. introduced the generator coordinate-inspired method, in particular its ADAPT version, the ADAPT-GCIM algorithm 75 ; 74 . ADAPT-GCIM dynamically builds a problem-tailored subspace by iteratively selecting operators with the largest energy gradients and diagonalizing the Hamiltonian within the resulting subspace. By shifting the focus from direct variational optimization to subspace expansion and diagonalization, ADAPT-GCIM reduces reliance on deep parameter optimization and constitutes a non-optimization-based dynamic variational quantum algorithm. In benchmark studies, ADAPT-GCIM has been shown to span a substantial portion of the relevant Hilbert space and to achieve high accuracy for a range of test systems, indicating its potential as a practical approach for quantum chemistry in the pre-fault-tolerant era. ADAPT-GCIM also reduces the simulation cost by orders of magnitude, making it easier to test on classical hardware 74 . However, like other subspace-based methods, its ultimate performance and scalability remain system-dependent and do not, by themselves, resolve all challenges associated with strongly correlated electronic structure. Other related diagonalization- and sampling-based approaches have also been proposed recently, including sampling quantum diagonalization (SQD) 63 ; 6 and cyclic VQE 73 . These methods can be formulated in either optimization-based or non-optimization-based variants and typically employ shallow circuits and lower shot count scaling. Nevertheless, it remains an open question whether such approaches can consistently outperform the classical selected configuration interaction methods they closely resemble 57 . In identifying chemical problems where quantum computers may ultimately establish a clear and defensible quantum utility, much attention has been focused on strongly correlated systems that are central to chemistry and material sciences, including metalloclusters, such as the FeMoco 50 . These systems are widely regarded as flagship targets for quantum simulation due to their complex electronic structure and the limitations of existing classical methods. At present, however, such large and strongly correlated systems remain beyond the reach of both classical exact simulators and most available quantum hardware. As a result, the majority of quantum chemistry algorithm development and benchmarking has historically relied on small molecules and minimal test cases, including hydrogen chains (H 4 , H 6 , etc.) and simple diatomics or triatomics and organic compounds 28 ; 3 ; 38 ; 32 ; 62 . While valuable for method validation, these systems probe only a narrow range of correlation regimes. Recent experimental progress has slowly begun to bridge this gap. Notably, quantum simulations of chemically realistic molecules using nontrivial basis sets, such as benzene in a Dunning-type basis, have now been demonstrated on quantum hardware, marking an important step beyond minimal toy models 8 . In parallel, quantum advantage has also been demonstrated in adjacent domains, such as nuclear magnetic resonance dynamics simulated using quantum echo algorithms on superconducting processors 54 . Taken together, these developments highlight the need for a more systematic and representative set of benchmark systems—intermediate in size and correlation complexity—that better reflect the classes of problems quantum chemistry algorithms are ultimately intended to address. Establishing such benchmarks would not only enable more meaningful performance comparisons, but also inform algorithm design choices, including the construction of operator pools and problem-adapted ansätze. The developments presented in this manuscript are organized around two complementary focus points: (i) the construction of a curated set of chemically meaningful benchmark systems spanning distinct regimes of electronic correlation, and (ii) the development of a practical black-box workflow for applying and benchmarking automated and adaptive quantum algorithms on these systems, including automated active-space selection and ansätze preparation. In the first focus point, we introduce a curated set of molecular systems that pose progressively more challenging tests for quantum algorithms. These benchmarks are designed to be easily imported into Python-based workflows and treated in active spaces of varying sizes, enabling systematic assessment across qualitatively distinct correlation regimes while moving beyond traditional minimal toy models. The simplest system in this collection is the N 2 molecule, which provides a well-established test of multireference bond breaking arising from its strong triple

Read the complete text