Build Boy’s Surface

Richard Evan Schwartz · 2026

Read Build Boy’s Surface by Richard Evan Schwartz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10755.txt.

Introduction

Richard Evan Schwartz writes a personal, hands-on account of Boy's surface. Boy's surface is a famous immersed copy of the projective plane in three-dimensional space. It twists through itself in ways that defy easy mental pictures. Schwartz admits his own past tries to grasp it faded fast. The image would form, then slip away without a trace.

His paper is a fresh attempt to build the surface and hold it steady. The tone is that of a working geometer thinking aloud. Readers get both the construction and an honest record of struggle with a classic object. It suits anyone who has met a math shape that refuses to sit still in the mind.

Catalog record

CREATORRichard Evan Schwartz
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10755

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Build Boy’s Surface Richard Evan Schwartz Abstract 1 Introduction Boy’s surface [ B ] is a famous immersed copy of the projective plane in \mbox{\boldmath{$R$}}^{3} . I have tried at various times to understand Boy’s surface, but somehow the effort has never met with joy. From time to time I have been able to concentrate enough so that its crazy twists and turns fit together in my mind (or seemed to), but then rather quickly the image went away without a trace. Moira Chas recently gave me one of her beautiful wire-knit models [ C ] of Boy’s surface, and this inspired me to try again. Now I have it straight. For a nice and succinct alternate description of Boy’s surface, see [ K ]. These notes give a fairly conceptual description of Boy’s surface that does not draw too much on three dimensional visualization. As I discuss in § 7 , the approach I take owes a big intellectual debt to a beautiful youtube video [ S ], produced by the Serbian Academy of Sciences, showing an airplane flying around and constructing Boy’s surface. You could view these notes as an elaboration of the video. I will explain how to build Boy’s surface out of simple pieces. All the pieces except the last one are easy to make out of cardstock and tape, and the last piece is determined automatically from the others by a coning procedure. For the coning procedure to work most gracefully it is useful to think of Boy’s surface as living in the 3 -sphere, which I model as \mbox{\boldmath{$R$}}^{3}\cup\infty . I will include a kit that lets you print out and assemble all but the last piece. The kit works. Katherine Williams Booth made a model from it. Here is her photograph of her model. Figure 0: An assembled kit! Here is an outline of these notes. \bullet In §2, I discuss the octahedral graph in some detail. This discussion gives a combinatorial explanation of why the boundary of the immersed surface in Figure 0 is a single loop. Of course, you can also just build the thing and trace the boundary around with your finger. \bullet In §3, I define the octacross . This piece is homeomorphic to the union of the 3 coordinate planes. It is the central piece in Figure 0. \bullet In §4, I define the crossbridge . This piece is homeomorphic to the union of 2 coordinate planes. The 3 crossbridges are the big hoops in Figure 0. \bullet In §5, I assemble most of Boy’s surface: You attach 3 crossbridges to the octacross and then glue in 3 round disks. The disks are visible in Figure 0. The union M of these 7 pieces turns out to be an immersed Moebius band. This is what Figure 0 shows. \bullet In §6, I attach the final piece P , which I call the pizza . It turns out that the boundary \partial M is cone-friendly : Each ray through the origin intersects \partial M at most once. We set P=\{tp|\ p\in\partial M,\ t\geq 1\} . Here P is a topological disk we get by coning \partial M to \infty . The reason for the name is that \partial M has the combinatorial structure of an 18 -gon, and correspondingly P is made from 18 pizza slices , each one a topological triangle. Boy’s surface is M\cup P . \bullet In §7, I compare and contrast these notes with the youtube video [ S ]. I also make a connection to paper Moebius bands [ Sch ] and raise an optimization question related to the construction here. \bullet In §8, I include the kit which lets you make M , as in Figure 0. \bullet In §9, I present an alternate model using rectilinear pieces. I thank Moira Chas, Peter Doyle, and Dan Margalit for helpful conversations about these notes. Finally, I thank Katherine Williams Booth for making the model in Figure 0. 2 The Octahedral Graph Let G be the octahedral graph . This graph is the union of vertices and edges of the octahedron. A perfect matching for G is a union of 3 edges of G such that every vertex of G is contained in exactly one edge in the union. Figure 1 shows a perfect matching for G , drawn in a symmetric way. Figure 1: A perfect matching for the octahedral graph We call the 3 edges in the matching bridges , and the remaining 9 edges roads . The reason for the name is that each bridge e connects the roads that are incident to vertices on either side of e . We can thicken e slightly and then replace e with three parallel copies. (I like to think of these parallel copies as lanes on the bridge.) This defines 3 paths of length 3 , each of which has the form road-bridge-road. Figure 2 shows this. Figure 2: A bridge between incident roads Figure 3 shows what happens when we do this construction simultaneously for all three bridges. The result is a length 18 circuit that alternates between roads and bridges. I have added numbers and directions to the roads to help you trace out the circuit. Figure 3: A circuit of length 18 Figure 4 is the same as Figure 3, but with different labels. The labels correspond to the usual choice of octahedron having vertices (\pm 1,0,0) and (0,\pm 1,0) and (0,0,\pm 1) . Geometrically, you are staring at the octahedron along the axis X=Y=Z . The vertex (\pm 1,0,0) is labeled by (\pm,0,0) . etc. We label the roads by the signs of the coordinates of points on them. Figure 4: Same path as in Figure 3, with different labels All our constructions below are invariant under the order 3 rotation about the axis X=Y=Z , namely the map (X,Y,Z)\to(Y,Z,X) . Likewise, all our constructions are invariant under the order 2 rotations that respectively fix the lines X+Y=0 and Y+Z=0 and Z+X=0 . The first of these rotations is given by the map (X,Y,Z)\to(-Y,-X,-Z) . The labelings in Figure 4 reflect these symmetries. Referring to Figure 0, the 18 vertices in Figure 4 correspond to the 18 points of non-smoothness on the surface boundary – i.e., the 18 points where the octacross attaches to the crossbridges. Most of the tape appears around these points. 3 The Octacross We first mention some notation which we will use repeatedly. • Given a set A_{XY} , we get A_{YZ} and A_{ZX} by cycling the coordinates. • D_{r}(p) denotes the closed disk of radius r centered at p . • A^{o} and \partial A respectively denote the interior and boundary of A . As in Figure 5, define O_{XY}=\bigg([-1,1]^{2}-\bigcup D^{o}_{2/3}(\pm 1,\pm 1)\bigg)\times\{0\}. (1) The union is taken over the 4 disks we get by taking all sign choices. Figure 5: The set O_{XY} The set O_{XY} is an octagon made from 8 sides, with curved and straight sides alternating. The octacross is O_{XYZ}=O_{XY}\cup O_{YZ}\cup O_{ZX}. (2) The octacross has 24 edges, 12 curved and 12 straight. We call the curved edges roads . The 12 straight edges cross each other in pairs, making 6

Read the complete text