The Effective Theory of μ → e \mu\to e Conversion

W. C. Haxton 1,2,3 and Evan Rule 1,4 · 2026

Read The Effective Theory of μ → e \mu\to e Conversion by W. C. Haxton 1,2,3 and Evan Rule 1,4 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10704.txt.

Introduction

W. C. Haxton and Evan Rule sum up work on an effective theory of muon-to-electron conversion. In this rare process, a muon captured by a nucleus turns into an electron with no neutrinos. Seeing it would prove new physics beyond the standard model. Making sense of any signal needs a theory that splits the problem into clean parts.

Their expansion in speeds and momenta yields a complete set of low-energy operators. Rates then split into sums of particle physics factors and nuclear response factors. The particle side uses a set of low-energy constants; the nuclear side is computed from the target nucleus. This split lets lab results test many new-physics models at once.

Catalog record

CREATORW. C. Haxton 1,2,3 and Evan Rule 1,4
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10704

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Effective Theory of μ → e \mu\to e Conversion W. C. Haxton 1,2,3 and Evan Rule 1,4 Abstract We summarize recent work to develop an effective theory of μ → e \mu\rightarrow e conversion, based on a complete set of low-energy effective operators that are developed from a systematic expansion in velocities and momenta. The expansion effectively factors rates into sums of particle physics and nuclear physics terms, where the former are expressed as bilinears in the LECs (the low-energy constants of the effective theory) and the latter are the associated nuclear responses. One can view the nuclear responses as “dials” that can be adjusted — for example, by selection of targets with specific properties — in order to isolate the former. We show that an important dial, in the case of Mu2e and COMET, will be inelastic transitions to certain low-energy nuclear states that are resolvable in 27 Al. If these transitions are exploited, the experiments have the potential not only to discover charged lepton flavor violation (CLFV), but to determine the operators responsible for the CLFV. We also discuss how such low-energy results can be “ported” to higher energies through a tower of matched EFTs, so they can be combined with other experimental limits to further constrain CLFV. \recdate January 11, 2026 1 Introduction The discovery of neutrino oscillations [ 1 , 2 ] established that lepton flavor is not only violated in interactions among neutral leptons, but also among the charged leptons, due to the charged-lepton flavor violation (CLFV) induced by neutrino loop corrections. However, this source of CLFV is suppressed by the tiny scale of neutrino masses, yielding rates too small to be observed experimentally. Consequently, any detection of CLFV would be evidence of new physics. There are many plausible modifications of the standard model (SM) — including supersymmetry, leptoquarks, heavy neutrinos, or a more complicated Higgs sector — that could induce observable levels of CLFV. Current upper bounds on CLFV branching ratios thus provide stringent constraints on such UV BSM extensions [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . Among the most sensitive CLFV measurements are those performed using stopped muons. The current best limits on the CLFV branching ratios B(\mu^{+}\rightarrow e^{+}\gamma)<1.5\times 10^{-13} and B(\mu^{+}\rightarrow e^{+}e^{-}e^{+})<1.0\times 10^{-12} were obtained at 90% confidence level (C.L.) by MEG II [ 6 ] and SINDRUM [ 7 ] , respectively. The former bound is expected to improve by another factor of two due to continued data collection at MEG II [ 8 ] , while the latter bound will be tightened by at least three orders of magnitude by the Mu3e experiment [ 9 ] . However, as described in talks presented at this meeting, a major advance in sensitivity to CLFV is expected in the next few years due to new experiments on muon-to-electron conversion, \mu^{-}+(A,Z)\rightarrow e^{-}+(A,Z) . This process can be observed by stopping muons in a thick target, where they capture into the first Bohr orbit of the target nucleus, then searching for electrons emitted with an energy of m_{\mu} (neglecting small corrections due to atomic binding and nuclear recoil). Mu2e and COMET, under construction at Fermilab and J-PARC respectively, are expected to improve limits on the \mu\rightarrow e rate by approximately four orders of magnitude. Given the many CLFV mechanisms that have been suggested in the literature, several questions naturally arise: As these measurements are done at low energies, what information can they provide on the BSM source(s) of CLFV? Is it just one rate that can be measured, or can multiple constraints be obtained by changing target properties, etc? In other words, in principle, how many \mu\rightarrow e particle physics observables exist, and what can be done to separately determine each observable? How does one ensure that the analysis framework one uses to interpret an experimental limit is complete, to avoid being misled by one’s assumptions? Finally, assuming one has properly analyzed an experiment, what does the extracted constraint (or constraints) imply for the BSM source of the CLFV, which presumably operates at a much higher energy scale? How does one relate the measurement to possible BSM theories of CLFV, or alternatively, to experimental CLFV limits from other processes, including those obtained at collider energies? There is a theory tool ideal for this situation — effective field theory. An EFT formulation appropriate for \mu\rightarrow e conversion has been developed by us over the past three years, in collaboration at different times with Ken McElvain, Tony Menzo, Michael Ramsey-Musolf, and Jure Zupan, who we gratefully acknowledge. Because the work is published [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] , both the original presentation at SSP2025 and this summary are designed as overviews, with the references available to readers interested in more detailed information. 2 Muon-to-Electron Conversion The quantity extracted from experiment is the branching ratio for \mu\rightarrow e conversion B(\mu^{-}\rightarrow e^{-})=\frac{\Gamma\left[\mu^{-}+(A,Z)\rightarrow e^{-}+(A,Z)\right]}{\Gamma\left[\mu^{-}+(A,Z)\rightarrow\nu_{\mu}+(A,Z-1)\right]}, (1) with respect to ordinary muon capture in a nucleus with A nucleons and Z protons. SM muon capture rates are generally available for targets of interest, due to the long history of measurements [ 15 ] . The most stringent current bounds on \mu\rightarrow e branching ratios are B(\mu^{-}+ Ti \rightarrow e^{-}+ Ti )<6.1\times 10^{-13} [ 16 ] and B(\mu^{-}+ Au \rightarrow e^{-}+ Au )<7\times 10^{-13} [ 17 ] . Both of these 90% C.L. limits were established by the SINDRUM II collaboration. By the end of this decade, the new Fermilab (Mu2e [ 18 , 19 ] ) and J-PARC (COMET [ 20 , 21 ] ) experiments are expected to reach branching ratio sensitivities of about 10 -17 , probing new physics scales in excess of 10^{4} TeV. Both experiments will measure electrons produced from the conversion of a muon bound in the 1s atomic orbital of 27 Al. The properties of nuclear targets — the nucleon number A and proton number Z , the ground-state spin and isospin, and their responses to operators that involve orbital angular momentum \vec{\ell} , spin \vec{s} , or spin-orbit correlations \vec{\ell}\cdot\vec{s} — affect the relationship between \mu\rightarrow e conversion bounds and underlying sources of CLFV. Comparable branching ratio limits obtained from different nuclear targets will differ in their sensitivity to a given source of CLFV. This is an attractive feature of \mu\rightarrow e conversion that distinguishes this process from \mu\rightarrow e\gamma or \mu\rightarrow 3e : by using several nuclear targets, one can place multiple constraints on the CLFV mechanism. Were \mu\rightarrow e conversion to be discovered in a given target, one could conduct additional studies with suitably selected targets to further characterize the CLFV source. On the other hand, the interpretation of experimental limits on \mu\to e conversion is, compared to \mu\rightarrow e\gamma and \mu\rightarrow 3e , significantly more complicated due to the use of nuclear targets. Although the literature on \mu\rightarrow e conversion is extensive (see the summary in [ 11 ] ), most existing work has focused on the special case of coherent conversion, where the leading response is governed by a scalar, isoscalar operator that sums coherently over all nucleons in the target. With this operator choice, the nuclear physics simplifies dramatically, allowing one to compute the \mu\rightarrow e conversion rate using experimentally determined

Read the complete text