A note on strong similarity and the Connes embedding problem ORCID 0000-0002-3091-2049
by · 2026
Read A note on strong similarity and the Connes embedding problem ORCID 0000-0002-3091-2049 by by (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10654.txt.
Introduction
A short note in operator algebra takes up the Connes embedding problem, a long-running question about von Neumann algebras. The note shows that a certain completely bounded map exists. The map runs from a C*-algebra with the lifting property into a QWEP von Neumann algebra. The key point is what the map cannot be.
The map is not strongly similar to a *-homomorphism, the nicest kind of map between such algebras. That gap between bounded maps and star-shaped maps carries the result. Notes of this kind sort out which algebra maps can be cleaned up and which cannot.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | by |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10654
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A note on strong similarity and the Connes embedding problem ORCID 0000-0002-3091-2049 by Abstract We show that there exists a completely bounded (c.b. in short) homomorphism u u from a C ∗ C^{*} -algebra C C with the lifting property (in short LP) into a QWEP von Neumann algebra N N that is not strongly similar to a ∗ * -homomorphism, i.e. the similarities that “orthogonalize” u u (which exist since u u is c.b.) cannot belong to the von Neumann algebra N N . Moreover, the map u u does not admit any c.b. lifting up into the WEP C ∗ C^{*} -algebra of which N N is a quotient. We can take C = C ∗ ( 𝔽 ) C=C^{*}(\mathbb{F}) (full C ∗ C^{*} -algebra) where 𝔽 \mathbb{F} is any nonabelian free group and N = B ( H ) ⊗ ¯ M N=B(H)\bar{\otimes}M where M M is the von Neumann algebra generated by the reduced C ∗ C^{*} -algebra of 𝔽 \mathbb{F} . In this note (which is not intended for publication) we produce a c.b. homomorphism u from a C^{*} -algebra C with LP (which we could choose to be C^{*}(\mathbb{F}_{n}) if we wish using free Haar unitaries in place of (x_{j}) ) into a QWEP von Neumann algebra N which is NOT strongly similar to a * -homomorphism, here by strongly similar we mean that the similarity can be chosen in the von Neumann algebra N . This means that a certain statement from [ 6 ] crucially used in [ 1 ] is not valid, as well as the application proposed in [ 1 ] to the Connes embedding problem. If N=B/I with B WEP ( I closed two sided ideal in B ) the map u does not admit any c.b. lifting. Indeed the paper [ 1 ] shows that if it did then u would be strongly similar to a * -homomorphism. Remark 0.1 . By known results (see [ 2 ] ) there are c.b. maps u:C\to B/I that do not admit any c.b. lifting. Apparently the existence of a c.b. homomorphism is new. Let \ell_{j} (resp. r_{j} ) denote the left (resp. right) creators on the full Fock space H so that x_{j}=\ell_{j}+\ell_{j}^{*}\quad(1\leq j\leq n) are free semicirculars generating the von Neumann algebra M\subset B(H) and their commutant M^{\prime} is generated by y_{j}=r_{j}+r_{j}^{*}. Let C=\ast_{j}C^{*}(x_{j}) (full free product). Let \sigma:C\to M be the natural representation, so that M=\sigma(C)^{\prime\prime} , and let \pi:C\to M\bar{\otimes}B(H) be defined by \pi(x)=\sigma(x)\otimes 1 . Let N=B(H)\bar{\otimes}M . We will produce a c.b. derivation \delta:C\to N relative to \pi with \|\delta\|_{cb}\leq 2 but such that any T in N such that \delta(x)=[T,\pi(x)] satisfies \|T\|\geq\sqrt{n}/4 . Then we will show that the associated homomorphism u:C\to M_{2}(N) defined by C\ni x\mapsto\left(\begin{matrix}x\otimes 1&\ \delta(x)\\ 0&\ x\otimes 1\end{matrix}\right) is also c.b. but if n=\infty it is not strongly similar to a * -homomorphism. An estimate will also be given for large finite n ’s. The construction we use is a particular case of the one described in [ 4 ] . Let S=\sum-r_{j}\otimes\ell_{j}^{*}+r_{j}^{*}\otimes\ell_{j}\in B(H\otimes H) Clearly \|\sum\ell_{j}\ell_{j}^{*}\|=\|\sum r_{j}r_{j}^{*}\|\leq 1 and hence \|S\|\leq 2. Let C=\ast_{j}C^{*}(x_{j}) (full free product) We denote by \pi:C\to M\otimes 1 the representation from the full free product to M taking x_{j} to x_{j}\otimes 1 . Note that C has the LP. Let \delta:C\to B(H\otimes H) be defined by \delta(x)=[x\otimes 1,S]. Then \delta is inner with (0.1) \|\delta\|_{cb}\leq 2. Since [x_{i},y_{j}]=0 we have \delta(x)=[x\otimes 1,\sum r_{j}^{*}\otimes\ell_{j}^{*}+r_{j}^{*}\otimes\ell_{j}]=[x\otimes 1,\sum r_{j}^{*}\otimes x_{j}]=\sum[x,r_{j}^{*}]\otimes x_{j}=-\sum[x,r_{j}]\otimes x_{j}. Clearly the von Neumann algebra generated by \pi(C) and \delta(C) is included in B(H)\bar{\otimes}\{x_{j}\}^{\prime\prime}=B(H)\bar{\otimes}M . Let T\in B(H)\bar{\otimes}M be such that for all x\in C \delta(x)=[x\otimes 1,T]. Since we have a projection P on M with range the span of (x_{j}) with \|P\|_{cb}\leq 2 we must have \delta(x)=(Id\otimes P)\delta(x)=[x\otimes 1,T_{1}] with T_{1}=(Id\otimes P)(T). It follows that T_{1}=\sum z_{j}\otimes x_{j} and (0.2) \max\{\|\sum z_{j}z_{j}^{*}\|^{1/2},\|\sum z_{j}^{*}z_{j}\|^{1/2}\}\leq\|T_{1}\|\leq 2\|T\|. Moreover since \delta(x)=\sum[x,r_{j}^{*}]\otimes x_{j}=-\sum[x,r_{j}]\otimes x_{j}=\sum[x,z_{j}]\otimes x_{j} we must have r_{j}^{*}-z_{j}\in M^{\prime}\text{ and }r_{j}+z_{j}\in M^{\prime} y_{j}=(r_{j}+z_{j})+(r_{j}^{*}-z_{j}) and hence \sqrt{n}=(\sum\|y_{j}\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2}\leq(\sum\|(r_{j}+z_{j})\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2}+(\sum\|(r_{j}^{*}-z_{j})\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2} but by the trace identity in M^{\prime} (\sum\|(r_{j}+z_{j})\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2}=(\sum\|(r_{j}+z_{j})^{*}\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2}=(\sum\|z_{j}^{*}\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2} and clearly (\sum\|(r_{j}^{*}-z_{j})\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2}=(\sum\|z_{j}\Omega\|^{2})^{1/2} so that we obtain by ( 0.2 ) (0.3) \sqrt{n}\leq\|\sum z_{j}z_{j}^{*}\|^{1/2}+\|\sum z_{j}^{*}z_{j}\|^{1/2}\leq 2\|T_{1}\|\leq 4\|T\|. Now it remains to check that the von Neumann algebra generated N by \pi(C) (or M\otimes 1 ) and \delta(C) is QWEP. We will show that N=B(H)\bar{\otimes}M , which is clearly QWEP since M being QWEP is exactly the original observation of Connes in the 1976 paper where he raised what is now known as the Connes embedding problem. Recall \delta(x)=\sum[x,r_{j}^{*}]\otimes x_{j}=-\sum[x,r_{j}]\otimes x_{j} Observe that [l_{k},r_{j}]=[l_{k}^{*},r_{j}^{*}]=0 for all k,j and also [l_{k},r_{j}^{*}]=0 if k\not=j and [l_{k},r_{k}^{*}]=P_{\Omega} . Thus \delta(x_{k})=P_{\Omega}\otimes x_{k} which implies that N contains all elements of the form aP_{\Omega}b\otimes x_{k} ( a,b\in M ), i.e. all elements in F(H)\otimes x_{k} where F(H) denotes the space of finite rank operators on H . It follows that N contains F(H)\otimes M and hence N\supset B(H)\bar{\otimes}M . Since we already noted that the converse is obvious, this proves as announced N=B(H)\bar{\otimes}M . The arguments in [ 1 ] give the following: Proposition 0.2 . Consider u:C\to N a unital cb homomorphism with values in a von Neumann algebra N in B(H) . Let v:N^{\prime}\to B(H) be the inclusion map. Then u is strongly similar to a * -homomorphism iff the map u.v:C\otimes N^{\prime}\to B(H) (defined by u.v(a\otimes b)=u(a)v(b) extends to a c.b. map w from C\otimes_{\max}N^{\prime} to B(H) . Moreover \|w:C\otimes_{\max}N^{\prime}\to B(H)\|_{cb}=\inf\{\|T\|\|T^{-1}\|\} where the (attained) inf runs over all invertible T\in N such that Tu(.)T^{-1} is a * -homomorphism. Proof. Assume w c.b. Clearly w is still a homomorphism, and hence if it is c.b. it must be similar to a * -homomorphism whence the existence of an invertible T on H (with \|T\|\|T^{-1}\|=\|w\|_{cb} ) such that x\mapsto Tw(x)T^{-1} is a * -homomorphism. But restricting this to 1\otimes N^{\prime} we find that N^{\prime}\ni y\mapsto TyT^{-1} is a * -homomorphism which implies by a simple calculation ( TyT^{-1}=(Ty^{*}T^{-1})^{*} and hence T^{*}Ty=yT^{*}T ) that |T|\in N^{\prime\prime}=N . Now T=U|T| with U unitary and the map C\ni x\mapsto U(|T|u(x)|T|^{-1})U^{-1} is a * -homomorphism. Since U is unitary C\ni x\mapsto(|T|u(x)|T|^{-1}) is a * -homomorphism, proving the strong similarity of u . Conversely, if T\in N is such that C\ni x\mapsto(Tu(x)T^{-1}) is a * -homomorphism denoted by \rho:C\to N , then obviously \rho.v is a (completely contractive) * -homomorphism from C\otimes_{\max}N^{\prime} to B(H) . Then a\otimes b\mapsto T^{-1}\rho.v(a\otimes b)T has cb-norm at most \|T\|\|T^{-1}\| on C\otimes_{\max}N^{\prime} and since T commutes with v(b) , we have T^{-1}\rho.v(a\otimes b)T=u.v(a\otimes b) . Thus we conclude that \|u.v:C\otimes_{\max}N^{\prime}\to B(H)\|_{cb}\leq\|T\|\|T^{-1}\| . The converse inequality was proved in the first part. ∎ Let \delta be as before. Then C\ni x\mapsto u(x)=\left(\begin{matrix}x\otimes 1&\ \delta(x)\\ 0&\ x\otimes 1\end{matrix}\right) is a c.b. homomorphism u into M_{2}(N) . We have \|u\|_{cb}\leq 1+\|\delta\|_{cb}\leq 3 by ( 0.1 ) (and replacing \delta by (\varepsilon/2)\delta we could get \|u\|_{cb}\leq 1+\varepsilon if desired). We know that M_{2}(N) is QWEP, so we have M_{2}(N)=B/I with B WEP. Lemma 0.3 . Let S be an invertible in M_{2}(N) such that x\mapsto Su(x)S^{-1} is a * -homomorphism. Then there is T in N with \|T\|\leq(\|S\|\|S^{-1}\|)^{2} such that \delta(x)=[x,T] for any x\in C . Proof. See [ 3