Canceling Effects of Conjunctions Render Higher Order Mean Motion Resonances Weak

Elizabeth K. Jones, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo · 2026

Read Canceling Effects of Conjunctions Render Higher Order Mean Motion Resonances Weak by Elizabeth K. Jones, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10585.txt.

Introduction

Elizabeth K. Jones, Samuel Hadden, and Daniel Tamayo study mean motion resonances, a key effect in orbital dynamics. A resonance occurs when two orbiting bodies fall into a steady rhythm of periods. Old theory ranks these resonances by strength. First-order ones look strong, while higher orders fade fast as orbits grow round.

The authors show that conjunctions, the close passes of the two bodies, can cancel each other out. Those canceling effects make higher-order resonances weaker than the old ranking suggests. The finding helps explain why first-order resonances rule in practice. It matters for models of planets and moons whose orbits lock into step.

Catalog record

CREATORElizabeth K. Jones, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10585

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Canceling Effects of Conjunctions Render Higher Order Mean Motion Resonances Weak Elizabeth K. Jones, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo Abstract Mean motion resonances (MMRs) are a key phenomenon in orbital dynamics. The traditional disturbing function expansion in celestial mechanics shows that, at low eccentricities, p p : p − q p-q MMRs exhibit a clear hierarchy of strengths, scaling as e q e^{q} , where q q is the order of the resonance. This explains why first-order MMRs (e.g., 3:2 and 4:3) are important, while the infinite number of higher order integer ratios are not. However, this relationship derived from a technical perturbation series expansion provides little physical intuition. In this paper, we provide a simple physical explanation of this result for closely spaced orbits. In this limit, interplanetary interactions are negligible except during close encounters at conjunction, where the planets impart a gravitational “kick” to each other’s mean motion. We show that while first-order MMRs involve a single conjunction before the configuration repeats, higher order MMRs involve multiple conjunctions per cycle, whose effects cancel out more precisely the higher the order of the resonance. Starting from the effects of a single conjunction, we provide an alternate, physically motivated derivation of MMRs’ e q e^{q} strength scaling. I Introduction Configurations where two bodies’ orbital periods form an integer ratio (e.g., 3:2 or 5:3) are known as mean motion resonances (MMRs) and play an outsized role in orbital dynamics. When planets are not in resonance, they overtake one another at effectively random azimuthal locations, and the associated gravitational perturbations largely average out. In resonance, however, these conjunctions recur at nearly fixed longitudes, allowing weak gravitational effects to accumulate coherently to large amplitudes. These MMRs exhibit rich dynamics that can act to either stabilize or destabilize systems, playing a central role in shaping the architectures of planetary systems, rings, and disks ( 2 ; 10 ) . But why do only some MMRs matter? Although any given period ratio is arbitrarily close to some integer ratio (e.g., 1532:867), only a small subset of these ratios play a meaningful role in nature. The reason is that, at small eccentricities e , the strength of a p:(p-q) MMR scales as e^{q} ( 10 ) , establishing a hierarchy in resonance strengths. First-order ( q=1 ) MMRs are strongest (e.g., 2:1, 3:2 etc.), while higher-order resonances are progressively weaker at small eccentricities. This hierarchy is key to the existence of stable orbital regions; if all MMRs were comparably strong, their resonant regions would overlap and drive rapid chaos and instabilities ( 15 ; 4 ) , precluding the existence of multiplanet systems. However, this only pushes the underlying question backward. Why do the strengths of MMRs scale as e^{q} ? Traditionally, this scaling is derived from detailed perturbation theory expansions of the gravitational potential between two planets. Each MMR corresponds to a single cosine term in this “disturbing function" expansion, and its amplitude scales as e^{q} at leading order in eccentricity ( 10 , e.g.,) . This is a powerful formalism, but it yields little physical intuition. 14 recently provided a simple qualitative answer. The order of a resonance corresponds to the number of conjunctions that occur before the cycle repeats. For example, in a 8:5 MMR, the inner planet must overtake the outer planet 3 times to complete 3 additional orbits during the cycle. 14 argued that the reason higher order MMRs were weak was that the effects of such multiple conjunctions tend to cancel out. However, their simple arguments could only show that the effects canceled out at first order in the eccentricity. In this paper we perform a more careful analysis demonstrating that this intuition is correct, and that for higher order MMRs the cancellation extends to higher powers of the eccentricity. Indeed, we provide an alternate derivation of the traditional e^{q} strength scaling of MMRs, starting from the effects of individual conjunctions. This provides a physical answer to a central principle in orbital dynamics, and yields a different approach that could be useful for various dynamical problems. We begin in Sec. 2 by defining our dynamical model and evaluating the effects of individual conjunctions building on work by 11 . In Sec. 3, we apply this formalism to evaluate the strength of a first-order MMR. In Sec. 4 we extend the argument to higher-order MMRs, and show that that the kicks within a resonant cycle largely cancel. Finally, we show that the residual effect of such multiple conjunctions leads to the traditional e^{q} MMR strength scaling. II Dynamical Model II.1 Hill Limit We begin by noting that at low eccentricities, most strong resonances correspond to close orbital spacings. Even the 2:1, the most widely spaced first-order MMR, corresponds to a fractional separation (a_{2}-a_{1})/a_{2}\approx 0.37 . This motivates exploring the problem in the Hill limit of close orbital spacings where it is easier to make analytical progress ( 9 ) . The first advantage for tightly spaced orbits is that the interplanetary separation becomes so small at conjunction that one can ignore the gravitational interactions at all other times. This allows the dynamics to be accurately modeled as as a discrete map with impulsive gravitational “kicks” applied at each close approach, with the planets following unperturbed Keplerian orbits between conjunctions ( 1 ) . The second major advantage is that in a close analogy to the two-body problem, the dynamics of two planets in the Hill limit separates into center-of-mass and relative degrees of freedom that can be independently solved ( 7 ) . This makes it possible to identify a one-to-one mapping between the general problem of two massive planets on coplanar eccentric orbits and the much simpler circular restricted 3-body problem (CR3BP), with a massive planet on a fixed, interior circular orbit, and an exterior test particle on an eccentric orbit ( 4 ) . For a discussion of this equivalence and physical arguments for its existence, see 14 . For mathematical and conceptual simplicity we therefore restrict ourselves to the CR3BP (Fig. 1 ) where one only needs to consider a single planet mass m (of the massive inner planet), and eccentricity e and longitude of pericenter \varpi (of the outer test particle). One can translate between this simpler problem and the general one of two massive planets on eccentric orbits using Table 1 of 14 . This correspondence is exact in the Hill limit, and approximate at wider separations ( 5 , for more powerful and general results with traditional perturbative approaches, see) . Finally, we note that an absolute eccentricity e is not particularly informative in the closely spaced limit, as even small values might be orbit-crossing. A more physically motivated quantity is \displaystyle\tilde{e}=\frac{e}{e_{c}} (1) which measures how large the eccentricity is as a fraction of the crossing value e_{c} at which the orbits would intersect one another. 4 show that expressing eccentricities in this way normalizes out the dependence of the dynamics on the orbital separation. This implies that the numerical coefficients for MMRs of the same order (e.g., the 5:4 and 9:8), which are different in the traditional disturbing function ( 10 ) , become equal under this normalization for MMRs ( 5 ) , resulting

Read the complete text