On the reconstruction of kinematic distributions computed with Monte Carlo methods using orthogonal basis functions Preprint: TTP26-001, P3H-26-002
Kirill Melnikov, Ivan Novikov, Ivan Pedron · 2026
Read On the reconstruction of kinematic distributions computed with Monte Carlo methods using orthogonal basis functions Preprint: TTP26-001, P3H-26-002 by Kirill Melnikov, Ivan Novikov, Ivan Pedron (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10420.txt.
Introduction
Kirill Melnikov, Ivan Novikov, and Ivan Pedron rebuild smooth curves from Monte Carlo runs. In high energy work, a curve is oft made by binning chance events in a chart. Binning yields a jagged curve. Fine traits can hide in the steps. Each bin holds few events at the tails.
The team use a new path. They fit the curve as a sum of smooth base forms. The weights come from the same chance run. No binning is used. The fit is smooth by build. It gives a clean curve from one run of events. That helps labs read tails and peaks with more trust.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kirill Melnikov, Ivan Novikov, Ivan Pedron |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10420
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the reconstruction of kinematic distributions computed with Monte Carlo methods using orthogonal basis functions Preprint: TTP26-001, P3H-26-002 Kirill Melnikov, Ivan Novikov, Ivan Pedron Abstract Reconstruction of one-dimensional kinematic distributions from calculations based on high-dimensional Monte-Carlo integration is a standard problem in high-energy physics. Traditionally, this is done by collecting randomly-generated events in histograms. In this article, we explore an alternative approach, whose main idea is to approximate the target distribution by a weighted sum of orthogonal basis functions whose coefficients are calculated using the Monte-Carlo integration. This method has the advantage of directly yielding smooth approximations to target distributions. Furthermore, in the context of high-order perturbative calculations with local subtractions, it eliminates the so-called bin-to-bin fluctuations, which often severely affect the quality of conventional histograms. We also demonstrate that the availability of a high-quality approximation to the target distribution, for example the leading-order result in the perturbative expansion, can be exploited to construct an optimized orthonormal basis. We compare the performance of this method to conventional histograms in both toy-model and real Monte-Carlo settings, applying it to Higgs boson production in weak boson fusion as an example. I Introduction Monte-Carlo methods play a key role in high-energy physics 15 ; 16 ; 19 . A particular application of such methods that will concern us in this paper, is the computation of distributions of observables in collider processes in the context of perturbative QCD 5 . A key step in the usage of these methods is to organize the simulated events into histograms with finite bins which, if a smooth approximation to the target distribution is desired, can be fitted with a parametric model. An interesting question is whether it is possible to construct the smooth approximation directly from a Monte-Carlo simulation, bypassing histograms as an intermediate step. One possible approach, that we investigate in this paper, is to decompose the unknown target distribution into a complete orthonormal set of basis functions, and compute their coefficients using conventional Monte-Carlo methods. These coefficients can be thought of as moments of distributions, since they are given by their weighted integrals. Importantly, this procedure is as efficient as constructing a histogram, and can be used to compute a large number of observables simultaneously. We note that this idea may not be entirely new 20 . For example, it has been used in Ref. 22 to determine the distribution of scattering angles in molecular collisions, and it is possible that there are other examples that we are not aware of. At the same time, histograms have become a method of choice in theoretical high-energy physics due to their conceptual simplicity, robustness, and ability to handle kinematic distributions spanning multiple orders of magnitude. A complete set of basis functions is, in general, infinite-dimensional, and in any practical calculation it needs to be truncated. Although one may think that this is a challenge for accurately reproducing the target functions, we note that many kinematic distributions in high-energy physics are smooth and, roughly, have the shape of an asymmetric bell curve (transverse momenta distributions) or a smoothed rectangle (rapidity distributions). Because of this, one can expect that a limited number of basis functions would be sufficient to adequately describe them. The method of moments has an additional key benefit when used with perturbative calculations based on local subtraction schemes 13 ; 8 ; 14 ; 10 ; 6 ; 11 ; 7 ; 18 ; 12 . Real and virtual corrections to differential cross sections exhibit infrared singularities, when taken separately. Local subtraction schemes add terms to the real corrections to subtract these singularities in the soft and collinear limits. From a computational Monte Carlo perspective, subtraction terms provide counter-events for each generated event, making their combination integrable. Although these counter-events are only needed in kinematic regions where additional radiation becomes indistinguishable from the no-radiation case, the counter-events often extend to the whole phase space. Since the kinematics of an event and counter-events differ, they may end up in separate histogram bins. Although this rarely happens, such events are, in some sense, catastrophic, and it takes a significant amount of CPU time to recover from them. Moments, on the other hand, are largely immune to this issue. Indeed, since weights that are used to calculate moments are continuous functions of the kinematic observables, all events and counter-events contribute to each moment, which provides a natural way to smooth the potentially offending contributions. An important question when using moments is the choice of basis functions. Obviously, there is significant freedom in their choice, which can be exploited to construct the most suitable basis for describing a particular target distribution. Indeed, one can employ known sets of orthogonal functions such as harmonic functions, Legendre or Chebyshev polynomials etc. 21 ; 4 . However, as we will argue below, this is often not an optimal choice . Partially, this is related to the fact that kinematic distributions in collider physics can change by several orders of magnitude on the interval of interest. This feature is not conducive to the reconstruction of the target distribution from a relatively small number of moments. However, if a fairly high-quality approximation to a particular target distribution is available, it can be used to construct an orthonormal basis that is optimized for describing this distribution using moments. 1 1 1 We note that a similar idea was discussed in Ref. 17 in the context of designing a flexible parametrization for the B -meson shape function. However, we believe that it was never applied for computing higher-order QCD effects in kinematic distributions relevant for collider physics. In the context of perturbative computations for collider physics, such approximations can be obtained from the leading-order distributions, which are much easier to calculate than the same distributions at higher perturbative orders. From the perspective of moments calculations, leading-order results provide high-quality approximations because QCD corrections change their shapes by tens of percent at most, whereas distributions themselves can change by orders of magnitude. When such an optimized basis is used, the first basis function is proportional to the chosen initial approximation, and other basis functions are variations needed to describe higher-order corrections to the shape of such a distribution. In comparison to e.g. Legendre moments, an optimized basis converges faster and avoids large fluctuations in regions where the target distribution is small. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II we introduce the idea of moments as an alternative to histograms, and provide the relevant mathematical details. We also discuss how to choose the highest moment to retain in the calculation, and estimate the truncation error based on the decay rate of the moments coefficients. In Section III we compare how the method of Legendre moments 2 2 2 We have used different orthogonal polynomials and found rather similar results. For this reason, we will focus on Legendre polynomials in the rest of this paper. performs in comparison to conventional histograms for a number of toy Monte-Carlo examples. In Section IV we apply these ideas to a real-world example – the calculation of the next-to-next-to-leading-order (NNLO) QCD corrections to Higgs boson production in weak-boson fusion (WBF). In Section V we show how to use an initial approximation to