Coherence Limits in Interference-Based cos(2 φ \varphi ) Qubits

S. Messelot, A. Leblanc, J.-S. Tettekpoe, F. Lefloch, Q. Ficheux, J. Renard, É. Dumur · 2026

Read Coherence Limits in Interference-Based cos(2 φ \varphi ) Qubits by S. Messelot, A. Leblanc, J.-S. Tettekpoe, F. Lefloch, Q. Ficheux, J. Renard, É. Dumur (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-10209.txt.

Introduction

S. Messelot and co authors test how long a shielded qubit can hold its state. The qubit is of cos two phi type. It is built from two Josephson parts in a loop. Their clash makes the state hard to disturb. That shield is its main draw.

A shield is of use only if the state lasts. The team probe what cuts the life of the state. Noise in phase, charge, or flux can each play a role. They map which noise bites most. The work helps judge if this qubit can scale to real chips.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Messelot, A. Leblanc, J.-S. Tettekpoe, F. Lefloch, Q. Ficheux, J. Renard, É. Dumur
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-10209

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Coherence Limits in Interference-Based cos(2 φ \varphi ) Qubits S. Messelot, A. Leblanc, J.-S. Tettekpoe, F. Lefloch, Q. Ficheux, J. Renard, É. Dumur Abstract We investigate the coherence properties of parity-protected cos ⁡ ( 2 ​ φ ) \cos(2\varphi) qubits based on interferences between two Josephson elements in a superconducting loop. We show that qubit implementations of a cos ⁡ ( 2 ​ φ ) \cos(2\varphi) potential using a single loop, such as those employing semiconducting junctions, rhombus circuits, flowermon and KITE structures, can be described by the same Hamiltonian as two multi-harmonic Josephson junctions in a SQUID geometry. We find that, despite the parity protection arising from the suppression of single Cooper pair tunneling, there exists a fundamental trade-off between charge and flux noise dephasing channels. Using numerical simulations, we examine how relaxation and dephasing rates depend on external flux and circuit parameters, and we identify the best compromise for maximum coherence. With currently existing circuit parameters, the qubit lifetime T 1 T_{1} can exceed milliseconds while the dephasing time T φ T_{\varphi} remains limited to only a few microseconds due to either flux or charge noise. Our findings establish practical limits on the coherence of this class of qubits and raise questions about the long-term potential of this approach. The transmon qubit 25 is arguably the most widely used superconducting qubit due to its simplicity and long coherence times, with state-of-the-art decay and dephasing times reaching T_{1},T_{\varphi}\sim 1\text{\,}\mathrm{ms} 46 ; 3 . Interestingly, the transmon qubit was originally introduced as a “charge insensitive qubit” extending the charge noise protection of the quantronium 47 from first to all orders. As the ratio of Josephson energy to charging energy, E_{\mathrm{J}}/E_{\mathrm{C}} , increases, the sensitivity to charge noise decreases exponentially, providing excellent protection against dephasing. However, the qubit remains susceptible to energy decay via electrical coupling to environmental degrees of freedom, owing to its large charge matrix element of the order of unity. Noise protection against dephasing can be extended to create qubits that are also resistant to energy relaxation 5 ; 14 ; 38 ; 17 ; 2 . The key concept behind this protection is to leverage the internal symmetry of the system, encoding the ground and excited states with wave functions that have different parities 20 ; 21 ; 43 ; 15 ; 49 ; 24 . For example, the Hamiltonian of the circuit can be engineered to preserve the parity of the number of Cooper pairs by only allowing the coherent tunneling of pairs of Cooper pairs through an operator |N\rangle\langle N+2|+|N+2\rangle\langle N| , which couples the charge states of the same parity. This is known as the \cos(2\varphi) qubit. In practice, it resembles a transmon, but instead of a Josephson junction with a 2\pi -periodic potential -E_{\mathrm{J}_{1}}\cos(\varphi) , we have a \pi -periodic circuit element. This element allows only pairs of Cooper pairs to be transmitted, resulting in a potential described by E_{\mathrm{J}_{2}}\cos(2\varphi) . The ground and excited state wavefunctions have different parities in the charge basis, leading to disjoint wavefunction supports and, therefore, suppressed matrix elements. One method to engineer a \pi -periodic potential is to leverage phase interferences between two circuit elements with non-sinusoidal current-phase relations embedded in a loop. When the loop is biased at half a magnetic flux quantum, the odd harmonics of the current interfere destructively, while the even harmonics remain. Several interference-based parity-protected circuits have been proposed, such as the Rhombus 14 , the Bifluxon 24 , the Kinetic Interference coTunneling Element (KITE) 42 ; 6 and the 0- \pi 37 . The aforementioned circuits rely on standard aluminum - aluminum oxide (Al/AlOx) Josephson junctions, and current-phase relation (CPR) higher harmonics stem from the detailed architecture of the \cos(2\varphi) element. Alternatively, intrinsically multi-harmonic Josephson junctions based on semiconductor weak links have been demonstrated, using material platforms such as InAs nanowires 44 , InAs 53 ; 32 and Ge/SiGe 29 two dimensional electron gas, graphene 35 ; 33 and other 2D materials 16 . Other intrinsically multi-harmonic junctions include pinhole Al junctions 19 or twisted cuprate van der Waals heterostructures 8 . However, only a handful of experiments 2 ; 28 have successfully demonstrated effective protection against energy relaxation using \cos(2\varphi) elements. To date, none have managed to combine this protection with protection against dephasing. This naturally raises the question of potential decoherence mechanisms specific to such an implementation. In this article, we conduct a comprehensive investigation of coherence properties of a general model of \cos(2\varphi) qubits, where Cooper-pair pairing is achieved through interferences between two bi-harmonic Josephson elements. We study the resilience of the energy relaxation protection as a function of circuit parameters, imperfections, and finite temperature effects. Furthermore, we show that the introduction of a loop in the circuit brings an unavoidable trade-off between charge and flux noise protection for the dephasing time. We show that biasing the circuit loop away from the frustration point can be advantageous, as it helps to balance the circuit’s susceptibility to these two noise sources and allows to reach coherence times of several microseconds with currently experimentally accessible circuit parameters. We start with a detailed description of the circuit, its Hamiltonian, and the various platforms that implement it. This is followed by a discussion of the effects of magnetic flux and charge offset. In the second part, we focus on energy relaxation protection mechanisms and their robustness to variations in circuit parameters. In a third part, we describe the specific coherence issue faced by the \cos\left(2\varphi\right) qubit, and in the fourth part, we optimize the circuit parameters to achieve maximum coherence. I Interference-based cos(2 \varphi ) I.1 Hamiltonian Figure 1: Electrical circuit. The circuit is made of two junctions A and B in parallel. Each junction has its own Josephson energies ( E_{\mathrm{J_{ij}}} ), where i=A,B denotes the junction and j=1,2 is the order of the harmonic of the Josephson junction. A large shunt capacitance creates the charging energy E_{\mathrm{C}} . The circuit has three internal quantum operators: the charge number of the common metallic island \widehat{n} , in red, and the two phases of the junctions \widehat{\varphi}_{A,B} , in purple. It can be controlled via two classical external knobs shown in blue with the applied voltage, n_{\mathrm{g}} , and the applied magnetic flux, \Phi . The same control knobs couple to external noise densities denoted S_{n_{\mathrm{g}}} and S_{\Phi} , electrical and magnetic, respectively. The circuit investigated in this paper is composed of two bi-harmonic Josephson junctions, assembled in a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) configuration and shunted by a single capacitance. It is shown in Fig. 1 . We use as definition of the junction’s Josephson potential \widehat{U}=E_{\mathrm{J}_{1}}\cos(\widehat{\varphi})+E_{\mathrm{J}_{2}}\cos(2\widehat{\varphi}) 22 . With this definition, in typical multi-harmonic junctions, E_{\mathrm{J}_{1}}<0 and E_{\mathrm{J}_{2}}>0 . From standard circuit quantum electrodynamics (cQED) formalism 13 , we find the Hamiltonian \displaystyle\widehat{H} \displaystyle=\;4E_{\mathrm{C}}\left(\widehat{n}-n_{g}\right)^{2} (1) \displaystyle+E_{\mathrm{J_{A1}}}\cos\left(\widehat{\varphi}_{A}\right)+E_{\mathrm{J_{B1}}}\cos\left(\widehat{\varphi}_{B}\right) \displaystyle+E_{\mathrm{J_{A2}}}\cos\left(2\widehat{\varphi}_{A}\right)+E_{\mathrm{J_{B2}}}\cos\left(2\widehat{\varphi}_{B}\right) with the electron charging energy E_{\mathrm{C}}=e^{2}/(2C) , the Josephson energy E_{\mathrm{J_{ij}}}=\Phi_{0}I_{\mathrm{c_{i,j}}}/(2\pi\times j) of junction i and j -th harmonics, \widehat{n} is the quantum charge operator of the superconducting island, and n_{\mathrm{g}} the classical charge offset. Similarly, \widehat{\varphi}_{i} is the quantum phase operator of junction i . Compared to a “pure” \cos(2\varphi) Hamiltonian \widehat{H}=4E_{\mathrm{C}}\left(\widehat{n}-n_{g}\right)^{2}+E_{\mathrm{J}_{2}}\cos\left(2\widehat{\varphi}\right) , the “interference-based” \cos(2\varphi) Hamiltonian encompasses the first harmonic terms

Read the complete text