Birman–Hilden theory for big mapping class groups

Nestor Colin, Rubén A. Hidalgo, Rita Jiménez Rolland, Israel Morales, Saúl Quispe · 2026

Read Birman–Hilden theory for big mapping class groups by Nestor Colin, Rubén A. Hidalgo, Rita Jiménez Rolland, Israel Morales, Saúl Quispe (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-09897.txt.

Introduction

Nestor Colin and four co-authors extend a classic symmetry theorem to huge surfaces. Their 2026 arXiv paper proves a Birman-Hilden result for big mapping class groups. The surfaces involved are connected, without boundary, and either infinite in type or of negative Euler characteristic.

Given a fully ramified branched covering between two such surfaces, the authors prove it has the Birman-Hilden property. That property lifts symmetries of the base to the cover. Big mapping class groups govern infinite surfaces like flute surfaces. Work of this kind gives the field shared ground rules it did not have before. Extending the theorem there strengthens tools for a fast-growing area of study, one that more and more young researchers are now choosing to enter.

Catalog record

CREATORNestor Colin, Rubén A. Hidalgo, Rita Jiménez Rolland, Israel Morales, Saúl Quispe
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-09897

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Birman–Hilden theory for big mapping class groups Nestor Colin, Rubén A. Hidalgo, Rita Jiménez Rolland, Israel Morales, Saúl Quispe Abstract . Let S S and X X be two connected topological surfaces without boundary, and assume that S S is either of infinite type or has negative Euler characteristic. In this paper, we prove that if p : S → X p:S\rightarrow X is a fully ramified branched covering map, then p p satisfies the Birman–Hilden property . This generalizes a theorem of Winarski, and the known results in the literature, to the context of surfaces of infinite type and branched covering maps of infinite degree. As an application, we show that the mapping class group (respectively, the braid group on k k -strands) of a non-orientable surface of infinite type can be realized as a subgroup of the mapping class group (respectively, the braid group on 2 ​ k 2k -strands) of its orientable double cover. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 57M12, 57K20; Secondary 57M60, 57M07 1. Introduction The study of the interaction between mapping class groups through branched covers has its foundation in the work of Birman and Hilden in the 1970s [ 10 ] , [ 11 ] , [ 12 ] . They established a criterion, now known as the Birman-Hilden property , which provides a connection between certain subgroups of the mapping class groups of the total and base spaces of a branched cover. Specifically, a branched covering map p:S\to X satisfies the Birman-Hilden property if every fiber-preserving homeomorphism of S that is isotopic to the identity admits an isotopy through fiber-preserving homeomorphisms. In Section 2.3 , we review some equivalent formulations of this property for branched covers of topological surfaces, and its interpretation in terms of mapping class groups. The purpose of this article is to extend the known results in the literature to the context of surfaces of infinite type and certain branched covering maps of infinite degree. Recall that a topological surface is of finite type if its fundamental group is finitely generated, and of infinite type otherwise. Let us consider a branched covering map p:S\rightarrow X of surfaces. We say that p is fully ramified if for every branch point b\in X of p , every point \tilde{b} in the fiber p^{-1}(b) is a critical point, i.e., the ramification number of p at \tilde{b} is at least two. Our main result applies to fully ramified branched covering maps. Theorem 1 (Birman–Hilden property for big mapping class groups) . Let S and X be two connected topological surfaces without boundary, where S is either of infinite type or of finite type with negative Euler characteristic. If p:S\to X is a fully ramified branched covering map, then p has the Birman-Hilden property. As regular branched covering and unbranched covering maps are fully ramified, the above provides the following. Corollary 2 . Let S and X be two connected topological surfaces without boundary, where S is either of infinite type or of finite type with negative Euler characteristic. If p:S\to X is either a regular branched covering or an unbranched covering map, then p has the Birman-Hilden property. We prove Theorem 1 by generalizing the strategy of Winarski’s proof of [ 33 , Theorem 1] ; see also [ 18 , Section 9.4.3] . Our approach uses combinatorial topology of curves on surfaces and relies on the Alexander method for finite and infinite type surfaces. A key step that allows us to include infinite-sheeted branch covers in our proof is Lemma 3.8 ; it gives a description of the structure of branched covers from the closed annulus and the closed infinite strip to a compact surface with two boundary components. Furthermore, we work on the category of Klein surfaces to obtain some auxiliary lemmas. This allows us to consider a unified argument which includes infinite-sheeted branched covering maps, and surfaces of finite and infinite type, orientable and non-orientable. 1.1. Relation with known results in the literature Under the assumption that the surfaces are closed, orientable and hyperbolic, Winarski proved in [ 33 , Theorem 1] that fully ramified branched coverings maps (so necessarily finite-sheeted) satisfy the Birman-Hilden property. Her result recovers the case of regular branched covers originally due to Birman and Hilden [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] , to Zieschang [ 36 ] , and to Maclachlan and Harvey [ 29 ] , and the case of unbranched covers proved by Aramayona, Leininger and Souto [ 4 , Proposition 3] . The work of Birman and Hilden also includes regular unbranched covers between closed surfaces that may be non-orientable, including the orientable double cover of a closed non-orientable surface; see [ 11 , Section 4] . Furthermore, Atalan and Medetogullari [ 5 , Theorem 1.1] extended Winarski’s result for fully ramified branched covers of non-orientable closed hyperbolic surfaces using the orientable double cover. A survey of the work of Birman and Hilden, and a brief history of the evolution of this theory for finite-sheeted branched covers can be found in [ 30 ] ; see also references therein. For the case of infinite-sheeted branched covers, a result where the Birman–Hilden property has been explicitly proved is the following. Let L be the Jacob ladder and h:L\rightarrow L be the handle shift homeomorphism. In [ 17 , Lemma 4.1] , Dey, Dhanwani, Patil, and Rajeevsarathy showed that the induced regular unbranched covering map p_{g}\colon L\rightarrow S_{g} induced by the action of \langle h^{g-1}\rangle on L satisfies the Birman-Hilden property for every g\geqslant 2 . On the other hand, as we explain in Section 4.1 , the original argument of Birman and Hilden [ 11 , Theorem 3] , [ 12 , Theorems 1 and 2] can be combined with the Alexander method to give a proof of the Birman–Hilden property for unbranched regular covers p:S\to X over a non-compact hyperbolic base surface X . This includes the possibility for the surface X to be non-orientable or of infinite type, and for the cover p to have infinitely many sheets. All of the above mentioned results are particular cases of Theorem 1 . Remark 1.1 . In [ 33 , Proposition 1] , Winarski gives a necessary condition, the weak curve lifting property , for when a finite-sheeted branched covering map p:S\to X satisfies the Birman–Hilden property. She applies this condition to obtain examples of non-fully ramified covering maps with finitely many sheets that do not satisfy the Birman–Hilden property. To stablish the weak lifting property, Winarsky uses that the liftable mapping class group (see Definition 2.7 ) is a finite index subgroup of the mapping class group, which is true for finite-sheeted branched covers over a surface X of finite type. When the branched cover has infinitely many sheets or the surface X is of infinite type her argument cannot be replicated. This motivates the following question: is there a necessary condition, like the curve lifting property, for when an infinite-sheeted branched cover satisfies the Birman–Hilden property? 1.2. Some applications to geometrically characteristic covers Our Corollary 2 is satisfied, in particular, by unbranched geometrically characteristic covers (see Definition 5.1 ). We use this in Section 5 to obtain injective homomorphisms between certain

Read the complete text