Epistemology gives a Future to Complementarity in Human-AI Interactions

Andrea Ferrario, Alessandro Facchini, Juan M. Durán · 2026

Read Epistemology gives a Future to Complementarity in Human-AI Interactions by Andrea Ferrario, Alessandro Facchini, Juan M. Durán (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-09871.txt.

Introduction

Andrea Ferrario, Alessandro Facchini, and Juan M. Durán argue that epistemology can rescue a key idea about human-AI teamwork. Their 2026 arXiv paper concerns human-AI complementarity: a human with AI support beating either one alone. The claim has spread through the human-AI interaction literature.

Complementarity generalizes the older reliance paradigm and offers a more practical frame than the contested idea of trust in AI. The authors ask what epistemology, the study of knowledge, adds. Grounding the claim in how knowledge works could tell designers when teamwork truly helps. It also clarifies what evidence would prove complementarity real.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrea Ferrario, Alessandro Facchini, Juan M. Durán
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-09871

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Epistemology gives a Future to Complementarity in Human-AI Interactions Andrea Ferrario, Alessandro Facchini, Juan M. Durán Abstract Human-AI complementarity is the claim that a human supported by an AI system can outperform either alone in a decision-making process. Since its introduction in the human–AI interaction literature, it has gained traction by generalizing the reliance paradigm and by offering a more practical alternative to the contested construct of ‘trust in AI.’ Yet complementarity faces key theoretical challenges: it lacks precise theoretical anchoring, it is formalized just as a post hoc indicator of relative predictive accuracy, it remains silent about other desiderata of human-AI interactions and it abstracts away from the magnitude-cost profile of its performance gain. As a result, complementarity is difficult to obtain in empirical settings. In this work, we leverage epistemology to address these challenges by reframing complementarity within the discourse on justificatory AI. Drawing on computational reliabilism, we argue that historical instances of complementarity function as evidence that a given human–AI interaction is a reliable epistemic process for a given predictive task. Together with other reliability indicators assessing the alignment of the human-AI team with the epistemic standards and socio-technical practices, complementarity contributes to the degree of reliability of human-AI teams when generating predictions. This supports the practical reasoning of those affected by these outputs—patients, managers, regulators, and others. In summary, our approach suggests that the role and value of complementarity lies not in providing a relative measure of predictive accuracy, but in helping calibrate decision-making to the reliability of AI-supported processes that increasingly shape everyday life. Keywords: artificial intelligence, machine learning, reliance, complementarity, human-AI interaction, computational reliabilism, epistemology 1 Introduction When we use AI systems to get assisted in our decision-making, or we are affected by decisions taken by others using these technology, what is important is that AI-assisted decision-making results in an improvement in performance. These expectations are particularly relevant in all domains where humans employ AI systems in high-stakes decision-making, such as healthcare, education, and public administration. Research on human-AI interaction captures this expectation under the label complementarity : in prediction tasks, the AI-assisted human, often referred to as ‘human-AI team,’ should outperform both the human and the AI alone ( 7 ; 6 ) . Since 7 , complementarity has attracted considerable attention in the human-AI interaction community ( 6 ; 7 ; 30 ; 31 ; 41 ; 42 ) . A growing body of work shows that human-AI teams can outperform humans alone ( 2 ; 34 ; 41 ) , and, in some settings, they can even outperform AI systems ( 20 ; 35 ; 41 ) . Here, complementarity serves as a design standard that motivates interaction protocols extending the more familiar reliance paradigm, in which the output of the human-AI interaction is constrained to equal either the human’s prediction (self-reliance) or the AI’s prediction (AI-reliance) ( 38 ; 43 ; 7 ) , by admitting interaction outputs that differ from the human and the AI’s predictions as the result, for instance, of repeated exchange of information ( 31 ) . Despite its intuitive appeal, complementarity faces four key theoretical challenges. First, complementarity is defined in terms of a performance measure called ‘complementarity team performance’ (CTP) and its theoretical anchoring remains limited ( 30 ; 31 ) . Second, like other performance metrics in supervised learning, CTP is an ex post, ground-truth-dependent measure: it is not available at decision time and its stability under AI system updates and human learning is poorly understood ( 41 ; 31 ) . Third, complementarity is defined solely over predictive and relative accuracy; in many contexts, however, accuracy is only one among several decision-relevant desiderata, such as fairness, robustness, explainability, and resource constraints among others ( 41 ) . Finally, the literature on complementarity currently abstracts from discussing the magnitude of the performance gain achieved by the human-AI team, and the cost of interaction required to obtain it. Taken together, these observations suggest that, despite the increasing body of work in human-AI interaction, complementarity is not suited to function as a stand-alone, relative accuracy-focused gold standard for human-AI collaboration. Not only do we lack a clear theoretical stance on complementarity, but empirically we still struggle to achieve it, as Vaccaro et al.’s ( 41 ) meta-analysis of 100+ studies clearly shows. So, what future lies ahead of complementarity in human-AI interactions? In this paper, we argue that by reconsidering complementarity through an epistemological lens, we can still assign it a meaningful role in human-AI interaction research despite these limitations. In fact, we show that complementarity plays a meaningful role in the epistemic justification of outputs produced by human-AI teams . To do so, we reinterpret it as one reliability indicator within the framework of computational reliabilism (CR) ( 15 ; 18 ; 19 ) , which is a process-reliabilist account that connects the historical performance and surrounding practices of computational processes such as human-AI interactions to the justification of beliefs formed on their basis. In this respect, complementarity contributes to ‘justificatory AI’ ( 24 ; 3 ; 4 ) from the novel perspectives of third parties affected by the predictions of human-AI teams, answering questions such as “When is it reasonable for a patient, a student, a manager, or a regulator to accept the output of a human-AI team as epistemically adequate for a given task?” Our work makes three contributions. First, we formalize complementarity and synthesize the main theoretical challenges identified in the human-AI interaction literature. Second, we introduce a novel epistemological twist: we conceptually reorient complementarity within CR, modeling prediction-oriented human-AI interactions as computational processes whose reliability comes in degrees and is supported by heterogeneous markers, with historical instances of complementarity serving as one key indicator. CR motivates what to measure and report beyond relative accuracy, e.g., stability under updates, task validity, governance and competence scaffolding, enabling more principled evaluation and design of human-AI teaming, while striving for reliability, namely, epistemic adequacy in a given decision-making context. Third, we offer actionable design guidance by arguing, in particular, that researchers should target efficient complementarity: if gains require sustained monitoring, prolonged deliberation, or extensive retraining, the design may merely shift epistemic burden onto users and erode the practical value of the improvement. To operationalize this perspective, we also provide (1) a minimal reporting checklist for ‘justificatory human-AI interactions,’ and (2) measures of efficient complementarity. In summary, we believe complementarity remains a valuable concept in human-AI interaction research, but not in the role it is currently asked to play. Epistemology provides a more suitable one. The structure of this paper is as follows. Section 2 introduces our formal framework for human-AI interactions, complementarity, and its four theoretical challenges. In Section 3 , we reframe complementarity in CR, while in Section 4 we provide three examples to elaborate on our approach. In Section 5 , we share a few recommendations for designers, governance, and policy makers. In Section 6 we collect our conclusions. 2 The Basics: Human-AI Interactions, Reliance, and Complementarity We introduce a few definitions, including complementarity, following perspectives and jargon from the literature in human-AI interactions. The interested reader will find in the Appendix a formalization of all constructs presented here. 2.1 Human-AI Interactions

Read the complete text