Simulating the photospheric to coronal plasma using magnetohydrodynamic characteristics III: validation including gravity, flux emergence, and an eruption Simulations performed using the LaRe3D ( 3 ) and CHAR ( 39 ) MHD codes. Analysis primarily carried out in Numpy ( 16 ) in python3. Figures create
Lucas A. Tarr, N. Dylan Kee, James E. Leake, Mark G. Linton, Peter W. Schuck · 2026
Read Simulating the photospheric to coronal plasma using magnetohydrodynamic characteristics III: validation including gravity, flux emergence, and an eruption Simulations performed using the LaRe3D ( 3 ) and CHAR ( 39 ) MHD codes. Analysis primarily carried out in Numpy ( 16 ) in python3. Figures create by Lucas A. Tarr, N. Dylan Kee, James E. Leake, Mark G. Linton, Peter W. Schuck (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-09804.txt.
Introduction
Lucas A. Tarr and four co-authors validate a simulation that follows solar plasma from the surface to the corona. Their 2026 arXiv paper is the third in a series on the traits that steer such flows. Solar eruptions grow when the sun's air turns unstable or loses its balance.
Observers cannot yet read the magnetic and plasma state well enough to predict eruptions directly. Data-driven simulations are the appealing alternative. This part checks the code with gravity, rising flux, and a full eruption all included. A trusted code can then run on real maps of the sun's field to probe why a region is about to blow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lucas A. Tarr, N. Dylan Kee, James E. Leake, Mark G. Linton, Peter W. Schuck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-09804
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Simulating the photospheric to coronal plasma using magnetohydrodynamic characteristics III: validation including gravity, flux emergence, and an eruption Simulations performed using the LaRe3D ( 3 ) and CHAR ( 39 ) MHD codes. Analysis primarily carried out in Numpy ( 16 ) in python3. Figures created with Matplotlib ( 20 ) , and Tecplot ( Figure 1 ). Lucas A. Tarr, N. Dylan Kee, James E. Leake, Mark G. Linton, Peter W. Schuck Abstract Solar eruptions arise from instabilities or loss of equilibria in the solar atmosphere, but routinely inferring the precise magnetic and plasma properties that lead to eruptions is not currently practical using synoptic solar observations. Data driven simulations offer an appealing alternative. We test our boundary data-driven magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) approach, based on the method of characteristics, on a simulation that includes full MHD, a stratified atmosphere, and the emergence of a model solar magnetic active region, from the photosphere upwards. The driven simulation is tested against a larger, ab initio “Ground Truth” simulation that extends downward into the convection zone. Our driven simulation accurately reproduces the dynamic emergence of the active region above the photosphere, the formation of key topological features throughout the corona, and the subsequent eruption of mass and magnetic field. The total emerged energy matches to better than one percent, the ratio of emerged to eruptive energy is ≈ 2 % \approx 2\% , and the actual values of each energy term agree to within 10 % 10\% between the two cases. Crucially, the data injection cadence, when properly scaled, matches the cadence of synoptic observations of the Sun’s surface magnetic field, and is three to four orders of magnitude longer than the inherent CFL time step of the simulations. The stability of the code and fidelity of the results over an entire active region lifetime, from emergence to eruption, strongly suggests that our method will produce reliable results when driven using solar synoptic observations from existing and anticipated ground and spaced based observatories. show][email protected] I Introduction This is the third paper in a series describing the systematic application of the method of characteristics ( 10 ; 30 ; 19 ; 40 ; 41 ) to boundary conditions for magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulations, with the goal of studying the evolution of magnetic active regions on the Sun. In 39 , hereafter 39 , we laid out the mathematical description of general boundary conditions in terms of the characteristic formulation of MHD, its application to (boundary) data driven simulations in particular, and the numerical implementation and testing of our data driving method on a toy problem. The numerical boundary condition framework implemented in 39 is called CHAR , and was initially developed as a module extending the LaRe3D MHD code ( 3 ) ; a standalone module capable of being called by most MHD codes is in development. The module is general, and any physically admissible boundary conditions can be implemented using it. For example, in 23 , hereafter 23 , we analyzed the performance of two common versions of so-called “non-reflecting boundary conditions” ( 19 ; 41 ; 8 ) on a suite of test problems. Data driven boundary conditions and the various flavors of nonreflecting boundary conditions are all types of open boundary conditions, and are conceptually closely related. Nonreflecting boundary conditions attempt to accurately model information leaving a domain and data driven boundary conditions attempt to use physical variables inferred from remote (and potentially in situ) observations to accurately model information entering a domain. Both are derived from an accurate representation of how information propagates though an MHD system, with the characteristics being the natural mathematical description of those processes anywhere in a volume. An open boundary condition then specifies the bidirectional interaction, in terms of the flow of information, between a given domain of interest and the external universe. This third paper in our series refocuses attention back to the data driving problem by testing a numerical setup that is much more representative of conditions on the Sun than the toy models we have previously considered. Our motivation in developing data driven boundary conditions is to accurately reproduce key features of the low solar atmosphere, between the photosphere and the Alfvén surface, in order to understand the origin of solar flares and coronal mass ejections. Essentially, we want to model the evolution of solar active regions from their emergence through the photosphere to their eruption in the corona above. We focus on data driving using photospheric data for two main reasons. First, within the photosphere, the inference of the state of the plasma from remote observations of polarized emission of atomic spectral lines is a much more tractable problem than in any other layer of the solar atmosphere; and second, the solar physics community has long-running, publicly available synoptic observations at high enough spatial resolution and temporal cadence to make boundary data driving feasible ( 17 ; 36 ; 37 ) . Previous theoretical work and observational evidence suggests the presence of twisted flux ropes, magnetic null points and separators, thin current layers, and a complex distribution of plasma pressure within solar active regions, all of which combine to create the instabilities or loss of equilibria that ultimately precipitate eruptions ( 33 ) . The appeal of a data-driven approach is that, if properly implemented, these features of the solar atmosphere will arise dynamically and self-consistently within the driven simulation, with a minimum of ad-hoc assumptions. Numerous data driving methods for solar active regions have been published very recently, including 13 ; 1 ; 5 ; 21 ; 14 ; 12 ; 29 ; 43 ; 6 ; see also relevant review articles by 22 , 15 , and 38 . Not all of these studies are directly comparable, given the relative novelty of the field, the rapid progress by different groups on different techniques, and the use of the term “data driving” to (justifiably) apply to all of them. Most of these involve applying a succession of different techniques to various stages of the emergence–to–eruption lifetime of an active region, some ad hoc, which collectively can be described as data driven or data constrained approaches. The steps are varied and can include: various magnetic field extrapolations, magnetofrictional relaxation, ad hoc emergence using semi-analytic flux tube models, randomized electric field driving, switching from (quasi-driven) magnetofrictional to (perhaps line-tied) MHD relaxation, and so on. The breadth and variety of methods above are not of particular interest here, so we will not describe them in detail. Instead, we note several features that distinguish our method from the others. In this paper, we define a ‘‘data driven simulation’’ as an ongoing, dynamic simulation where the lower boundary conditions for the primitive variables 1 1 1 The specifics of how the primitive variables are set vary depending on the numerical scheme, e.g., a finite volume scheme might set them in terms of fluxes of conserved quantities. Mathematically, all schemes must be equivalent to using Dirichlet, Neumann, or Robin boundary conditions on the primitive variables. are updated at each Courant condition-limited time step using some form of temporal interpolation (perhaps with additional modifications) between longer-spaced observation times. With that in mind, our approach is relatively straight-forward, requiring