One cloud is not enough: extreme conditions bias chemical abundances in high-redshift galaxies
B. Moreschini, F. Belfiore, A. Marconi, E. Cataldi, M. Curti, A. Amiri, A. Feltre, F. Mannucci, E. Bertola, C. Bracci, M. Ceci, A. Chakraborty, G. Cresci, Q. D’Amato, E. Di Teodoro, M. Ginolfi, I. Lamperti, C. Marconcini, M. Scialpi, L. Ulivi, M. V. Zanchettin · 2026
Read One cloud is not enough: extreme conditions bias chemical abundances in high-redshift galaxies by B. Moreschini, F. Belfiore, A. Marconi, E. Cataldi, M. Curti, A. Amiri, A. Feltre, F. Mannucci, E. Bertola, C. Bracci, M. Ceci, A. Chakraborty, G. Cresci, Q. D’Amato, E. Di Teodoro, M. Ginolfi, I. Lamperti, C. Marconcini, M. Scialpi, L. Ulivi, M. V. Zanchettin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-08939.txt.
Introduction
B. Moreschini and a large team warn that one cloud form can skew chem counts in far galaxies. The Webb scope lets us read the gas in such galaxies with tools honed nearby. Near tools rest on calm gas states. Far gas is far more wild, with strong light and low metal counts. A calm form may not fit it at all.
The team shows how wild states shift the lines we read. If we force a one cloud form, the chem counts we get can be off by much. More than one cloud state must be let in the fit. A reader who reads far gas gets a clear warn. Old near tools need a fresh check at high range.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | B. Moreschini, F. Belfiore, A. Marconi, E. Cataldi, M. Curti, A. Amiri, A. Feltre, F. Mannucci, E. Bertola, C. Bracci, M. Ceci, A. Chakraborty, G. Cresci, Q. D’Amato, E. Di Teodoro, M. Ginolfi, I. Lamperti, C. Marconcini, M. Scialpi, L. Ulivi, M. V. Zanchettin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 97 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-08939
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
One cloud is not enough: extreme conditions bias chemical abundances in high-redshift galaxies B. Moreschini, F. Belfiore, A. Marconi, E. Cataldi, M. Curti, A. Amiri, A. Feltre, F. Mannucci, E. Bertola, C. Bracci, M. Ceci, A. Chakraborty, G. Cresci, Q. D’Amato, E. Di Teodoro, M. Ginolfi, I. Lamperti, C. Marconcini, M. Scialpi, L. Ulivi, M. V. Zanchettin Abstract Since its launch, JWST has opened an unprecedented opportunity to characterise the ionised interstellar medium (ISM) of high-redshift galaxies using well-established rest-frame ultra-violet (UV)/optical diagnostics from the local Universe. At the same time, these observations challenge the validity of such classical methods when applied to the extreme and diverse environments typical at high redshift. In this paper, we present an in-depth analysis of the ISM in three representative case studies at z = 2 − 6 z=2-6 (MARTA 4327, the Sunburst Arc and RXCJ2248-ID) conducted within a multi-cloud photoionisation modelling framework (HOMERUN), which models integrated galaxy spectra as linear combinations of photoionised regions spanning a wide range of ionisation and density conditions. We show that even a small fraction of unresolved high-density ( n e = 10 4 − 10 7 cm − 3 n_{\mathrm{e}}=10^{4}-10^{7}\ \mathrm{cm^{-3}} ) clumps can contribute more than half of the observed flux of auroral lines such as [O III] λ \lambda 4363 and [O II] λ λ \lambda\lambda 7323,7332, while only negligibly to standard optical density tracers. As a result, T e T_{\mathrm{e}} -method metallicities can be underestimated by ∼ 0.15 − 0.3 \sim 0.15-0.3 dex, as for MARTA 4327. By modelling rest-frame UV and optical data simultaneously, we demonstrate that discrepancies between abundance estimates obtained from diagnostics tracing different zones do not necessarily imply chemical inhomogeneities. In RXCJ2248-ID, the disagreement between UV and optical N/O may naturally arise from ionisation and density structure alone. In contrast, we find evidence for genuine chemical stratification in the Sunburst Arc, where a matter-bounded component enriched in nitrogen ( log ( N / O ) = − 0.46 \log(\mathrm{N/O})=-0.46 ) coexists with a chemically normal ( log ( N / O ) = − 1.39 \log(\mathrm{N/O})=-1.39 ), ionisation-bounded one. Finally, we argue that high-ionisation lines such as He II λ \lambda 1640 and C IV λ λ \lambda\lambda 1548,1551 can be explained within a pure star-formation scenario invoking matter-bounded regions, consistent with a non-negligible Lyman-continuum leakage. However, in the case of RXCJ2248-ID, we cannot rule out a minor contribution from an active galactic nucleus based solely on the observed emission-line fluxes. Together, these results indicate that classical diagnostics can be significantly biased in high-redshift galaxies and that self-consistent, physically motivated tools are therefore essential to properly interpret the complex ISM conditions and chemical enrichment in the early Universe. %=11 1 Introduction The interstellar medium (ISM) plays a major role in galaxy evolution: it is where stars form, and the stage for all feedback and regulatory processes governing star formation and interactions with the environment ( 73 ; 135 ) . A large body of observations from the last decade has demonstrated that the high- z ISM differs from its local counterpart, showing higher ionisation conditions, harder ionising spectra, lower gas-phase metallicities, and higher densities ( 141 ; 128 ; 148 ; 150 ; 97 ; 127 ; 88 ; 130 , e.g.,) . However, due to observational limits, rest-frame optical spectroscopy was confined mostly to Cosmic Noon. Thanks to its sensitivity and wavelength coverage, JWST has revolutionised our view of the high- z ISM by enabling detailed characterisation of galaxies from Cosmic Noon to Cosmic Dawn (e.g., 41 ; 98 ; 146 , for recent reviews) . Such detailed spectroscopic information has highlighted key differences in gas density, ionising spectra, and chemical abundance patterns. Firstly, JWST has revealed a population of luminous, compact galaxies at z\sim 10 , characterised by low metallicities, high star-formation rates, and possibly powered by intense starburst episodes ( 15 ; 22 ; 36 ; 110 ; 108 ; 136 , e.g.,) . Their spectra often show very high-ionisation species like N IV] \lambda\lambda 1483,1486 , C IV \lambda\lambda 1548,1551, and He II \lambda 1640, which need photons with energies above 47.5, 47.8, and 54.4 eV, respectively. These extreme emission features are difficult to reproduce with standard stellar population models, and often require invoking strong bursts of young, metal-poor stars or alternative hard sources, such as active galactic nuclei (AGN), X-ray binaries, Wolf–Rayet (WR) stars ( 143 ; 140 ; 109 ; 132 ; 152 , e.g.,) , or even super- and very-massive stars ( 25 ; 166 , SMS, VMS, with M\sim 10^{3}-10^{5}\ {\rm M}_{\odot} and \sim 10^{2}-10^{3}\ \mathrm{M}_{\odot} ;) . The growing number of detections of AGN-like features (such as high-ionisation lines or broad components) at high redshift raises the issue of disentangling the contributions of AGN activity from that of metal-poor stellar sources. The classical method for separating AGN from stellar photoionisation relies on rest-frame optical diagrams, like the Baldwin-Phillips-Terlevich (BPT) diagram ( 8 ; 74 ) . However, the evolving ISM conditions at high redshift cast doubt on its applicability ( 75 ; 58 ; 59 ; 32 ; 137 , e.g.,) . Moreover, classical methods often struggle to distinguish mixed contributions from AGN and star formation (with some exceptions, e.g., 40 for integral field data), and to robustly constrain ISM conditions in such cases. Recent spectral fitting tools like BEAGLE-AGN ( 165 ) and Cue ( 84 ) are however making progress in this direction. Among high- z galaxies with unusual properties, N-rich systems have attracted particular attention. These galaxies have elevated nitrogen abundances ( \sim 0.5-1.5 dex) as inferred from their rest-frame ultra-violet (UV) lines (e.g., 69 ; 106 , for compilations) . One interpretation links these galaxies to the progenitors of local globular clusters, given their similar abundance patterns ( 25 ; 64 ; 138 ; 69 , e.g.,) . Physically, this may be connected to the presence of massive stars, whose stellar feedback (through -also temporally- differential winds and consequent shocks) could enhance observed N/O abundances in localised, chemically enriched regions ( 47 ; 124 , e.g.,) . Some studies suggest additional contributions from multiple bursts of star formation or tidal disruption events ( 17 ; 78 ; 159 ; 167 ; 12 ; 100 , e.g.,) . Furthermore, in dense stellar clusters, stellar collisions may promote the formation of black holes, potentially seeding intermediate-mass black holes ( 119 , e.g.,) . Such a connection between black holes and N-emitters provides a possible explanation for the AGN signatures observed in many of these systems ( 61 ) . Finally, theoretical predictions, simulations, pre-JWST and JWST-based studies found evidence for increasing electron density with redshift, using both UV and optical diagnostics ( 163 ; 128 ; 97 ; 63 ; 1 ; 158 ; 94 , e.g.,) . In particular, recent works found densities sometimes \gtrsim 10^{5} cm -3 . Most common rest-frame optical density diagnostics involve low critical-density transitions (like [O II] \lambda\lambda 3727,3729 or [S II] \lambda\lambda 6717,6731), which are not sensitive to such high-density clumps. This aspect becomes even more crucial in high-redshift environments, where the ISM may exhibit strong density stratification ( n_{\rm e}\sim 10-10^{5} cm -3 , e.g., 55