Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? 2026 Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? – References
Michael L. Weber, Barbara Ercolano, Giovanni Picogna · 2026
Read Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? 2026 Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? – References by Michael L. Weber, Barbara Ercolano, Giovanni Picogna (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-08938.txt.
Introduction
Michael Weber, Barbara Ercolano, and Giovanni Picogna ask if star light alone can carve gaps in young disks of gas and dust. Such disks form round new stars, and planets grow in them. Light from the star can boil gas off the disk face. That boil off is called photoevaporation. Some claim it can open a clean gap, as a planet can.
The team runs 2D sims that tie disk growth to the boil off flow. They find a catch. Once a dip forms, the boil off rate there drops fast. That drop stops the gap from deep growth. A reader in planet birth work gets a bound on what star light can do alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael L. Weber, Barbara Ercolano, Giovanni Picogna |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-08938
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? 2026 Can photoevaporation open gaps in protoplanetary discs? – References Michael L. Weber, Barbara Ercolano, Giovanni Picogna Abstract We investigate whether photoevaporation alone can open and sustain gaps in protoplanetary discs by coupling the evolving disc structure with the photoevaporative flow in two-dimensional radiation–hydrodynamical simulations. Our results show that once a density depression forms, the local mass-loss rate decreases sharply, suppressing further gap deepening. Viscous inflow and radial mass transport along the disc surface act to partially refill the depleted region, preventing complete clearing. The resulting configuration is a persistent, partially depleted zone whose evolution is largely insensitive to the initial disc morphology. This behaviour challenges the standard paradigm that photoevaporation efficiently carves clean inner cavities and directly produces transition discs. However, the pressure maximum at the outer edge of the depression may still trap dust grains, giving rise to transition-disc–like observational signatures. We also present a first-order prescription to approximate this behaviour in one-dimensional disc evolution models, suitable for use in planet formation and population synthesis studies. Although the prescription improves upon static mass-loss treatments, it remains approximate, underscoring the need for further multidimensional simulations and parameter-space exploration to derive robust recipes for global disc and planet population models. 1 Introduction Protoplanetary discs are the birthplaces of planets, as demonstrated by direct detections of forming planets around PDS 70 ( 13 ; 18 ) . Planet formation and migration proceed within these discs until their dispersal, which occurs rapidly ( 29 , e.g.) after \sim 2-8 Myr ( 23 , e.g.) . Constraining the mechanisms responsible for disc dispersal is therefore essential to understanding the timing and conditions of planet formation. Photoevaporation – the removal of gas through thermally driven winds launched by high-energy stellar radiation – has long been recognised as a key dispersal mechanism ( 6 ; 15 ; 22 , see reviews by ) . The process is most efficient at a characteristic radius, typically a few au, where the gas thermal energy exceeds the stellar gravitational potential. When the local mass-loss rate due to photoevaporation exceeds the inward viscous mass flux, a gap can form ( 3 , e.g.) . The inner disc then drains onto the star on a short viscous timescale, while the outer disc is eroded from the inside out. This inside-out dispersal is another important constraint demonstrated by observations ( 30 ; 12 ; 1 , e.g.) , including photometric surveys ( 14 ; 4 ) . Radiation-hydrodynamical models have confirmed that photoevaporation can produce such gaps and drive disc clearing ( 20 ; 21 ; 25 ; 24 ; 7 ; 27 ; 19 , e.g.) . Observationally, this scenario provides a natural explanation for transitional discs – systems showing inner cavities in infrared and millimetre continuum emission. While many cavities are attributed to planet-disc interactions, a population of low-accretion, cavity-bearing discs is consistent with photoevaporative origin ( 8 ; 10 ) . The theoretical basis for gap opening by photoevaporation remains, however, uncertain. Most models rely on two-dimensional (r– \theta ) simulations from which one-dimensional radial profiles of the mass-loss rate, \dot{\Sigma} (r), are extracted and used as fixed sink terms in viscous evolution calculations ( 9 ; 5 ; 2 , e.g.) . These prescriptions implicitly assume that \dot{\Sigma} (r) remains constant during the gap-opening phase, neglecting feedback between the evolving disc structure and the photoevaporative flow. This neglects the fact that once a gap begins to form, local mass-loss rates within the gap region might decrease sharply or vanish, and viscous inflow might refill the transition region, preventing further deepening of the gap. If photoevaporation is self-limiting in this way, it may be less efficient than previously assumed at clearing gas at the radii where giant planets form. This has far-reaching implications for models of core accretion, gas envelope growth, and migration, and ultimately for the observed architectures of planetary systems ( 11 ; 17 , e.g.) . In this Letter, we use hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the ability of photoevaporation to open and sustain gaps in protoplanetary discs when the flow dynamically responds to changes in disc structure. We test the validity of the commonly adopted static mass-loss prescription and assess whether photoevaporation alone can account for gap formation and subsequent clearing under realistic conditions. 2 Methods To reduce the computational cost of the simulations, a two-phased approach was employed. 2.1 Phase I: One-dimensional disc evolution In the first phase, the one-dimensional viscous evolution code spock ( 9 ) was used to simulate the evolution of a viscously accreting disc undergoing X-ray photoevaporation until the onset of gap formation. spock evolves the one-dimensional gas surface density, \Sigma , according to \frac{\partial\Sigma}{\partial t}=\frac{1}{R}\frac{\partial}{\partial R}\bigl[3R^{1/2}\frac{\partial}{\partial R}(\nu\Sigma R^{1/2})\bigr]-\dot{\Sigma}_{W}(R,t), (1) where R is the cylindrical radius, t the time, \nu the kinematic viscosity of the disc, and \dot{\Sigma}_{W}(R,t) the photoevaporation profile. The first term on the right-hand side describes viscous evolution ( 16 ) , while the second term is a sink term representing the mass-loss by photoevaporation, parametrised using the mass-loss profile from 25 . The adopted initial conditions were: stellar mass M_{*}=0.7 M ⊙ , disc mass M_{disc}=4\cdot 10^{-3} M ⊙ , and aspect ratio \frac{H}{R}=0.05 at R_{1}=50 au. A locally isothermal disc with temperature T\propto R^{-1/2} was assumed, resulting in a slightly flared structure with H\propto R^{5/4} . Viscosity was prescribed using the \alpha -disc model ( 28 ) , such that \nu=\alpha c_{s}H , with c_{s} the sound speed and H the scale height of the disc. An \alpha value of 5\cdot 10^{-4} was adopted. The computational domain was discretized to a grid of 1024 radial cells, equispaced in R^{1/2} , extending from 0.1 to 400 au. Figure 1: Surface density evolution in the 1D model S1 . The red dotted line shows the initial conditions for the model with an initial depletion ( p-g ). For the model without an initial depletion ( p-ng ), the surface density was modified using the solid red line, as described in subsection 2.2 . The one-dimensional model was evolved for 2.1 Myr, at which point a partial depletion in the surface density developed due to the photoevaporative wind, marking the onset of gap formation. Figure 1 shows the surface density at that time as well as 100 kyr before and after. Throughout this work, the spock model is referred to as S1 . Unless otherwise noted, t=0 denotes the start of the pluto simulations. 2.2 Phase II: Two-dimensional radiation-hydrodynamic simulations The surface density at 2.1 Myr was used as the input for the second phase, where the model was evolved in axisymmetric 2D ( r – \theta ) spherical coordinates using pluto to simulate the photoevaporative outflow and its impact on the disc. The photoevaporative wind driven by stellar high-energy irradiation was modelled following 25 , to which we refer for details. We note that this model employs a line-of-sight heating approximation, which maximizes the effect of shadowing by neglecting diffuse heating; however previous work has demonstrated that the contribution of the diffuse radiation field is negligible in gap regions ( 31 ) . The computational domain extended radially from 0.75 to 380\,\mathrm{au} , resolved with 512 logarithmically spaced radial cells.