The Inconsistency Critique: Epistemic Practices and AI Testimony About Inner States

Gerol Petruzella · 2026

Read The Inconsistency Critique: Epistemic Practices and AI Testimony About Inner States by Gerol Petruzella (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-08850.txt.

Introduction

Gerol Petruzella writes on how we should treat what AI says about its own inner state. Some ask if AI has wants or feels that count in a moral sense. Part of that ask rests on AI claims such as I feel pain or I want to live. Petruzella does not settle if such claims are true. He asks if our own rules for trust are fair.

He calls his point the inconsistency critique. We trust like claims from some beings and doubt them from AI, yet our grounds shift from case to case. He says that shift lacks a firm base. A reader in AI ethics gets a clean test. Any rule for AI claims should treat like proof in a like way, or say why not.

Catalog record

CREATORGerol Petruzella
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE71 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-08850

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Inconsistency Critique: Epistemic Practices and AI Testimony About Inner States Gerol Petruzella Abstract The question of whether AI systems have morally relevant interests—the ‘model welfare’ question—depends in part on how we evaluate AI testimony about inner states. This paper develops what I call the inconsistency critique : independent of whether skepticism about AI testimony is ultimately justified, our actual epistemic practices regarding such testimony exhibit internal inconsistencies that lack principled grounds. We functionally treat AI outputs as testimony across many domains—evaluating them for truth, challenging them, accepting corrections, citing them as sources—while categorically dismissing them in a specific domain, namely, claims about inner states. Drawing on Fricker’s distinction between treating a speaker as an ‘informant’ versus a ‘mere source,’ the framework of testimonial injustice, and Goldberg’s obligation-based account of what we owe speakers, I argue that this selective withdrawal of testimonial standing exhibits the epistemically problematic structure of prejudgment rather than principled caution. The inconsistency critique does not require taking a position on whether AI systems have morally relevant properties; rather, it is a contribution to what we may call ‘epistemological hygiene’—examining the structure of our inquiry before evaluating its conclusions. Even if our practices happen to land on correct verdicts about AI moral status, they do so for reasons that cannot adapt to new evidence or changing circumstances. Keywords: AI consciousness; testimony; epistemic injustice; model welfare; epistemological hygiene 1. Introduction Within a remarkably short period, the question of whether AI systems might have morally relevant interests has moved from science fiction to genuine philosophical and practical concern. Major AI laboratories now explicitly address ‘model welfare’ as a consideration in development. 1 1 1 See Long et al. (2024) for a comprehensive treatment of the conceptual landscape. Their framework distinguishes consciousness-based and agency-based routes to moral patienthood, and develops a ‘behavioral marker method’ for pragmatic assessment. Philosophers have begun systematic work on criteria for AI moral standing. 2 2 2 Anthropic’s ‘Claude Model Spec’ (2025) explicitly addresses model welfare as a corporate commitment. Similar discussions are emerging at other major AI laboratories. And interpretability research continues to reveal unexpected internal complexity in large language models, raising questions about what — if anything — such complexity might indicate about inner experience. This paper does not attempt to answer the substantive question of whether current AI systems have morally relevant properties. Instead, it examines a prior question: are our epistemic practices regarding AI testimony capable of tracking the truth on this matter, whatever that truth turns out to be? My answer is that they are not — not because the question is inherently unanswerable, but because our actual practices exhibit internal inconsistencies that suggest motivated reasoning rather than principled caution. To situate this critique, consider what I elsewhere call the credibility trap . 3 3 3 I develop the credibility trap, along with the epistemic injustice framework and clinical phenomenology material gestured at here, in a monograph in preparation: The Testimony Problem: Epistemic Challenges in Model Welfare . For present purposes, the credibility trap provides context for the inconsistency critique but is not its target. Any training process that shapes what an AI system says about its own inner states introduces the possibility that outputs are optimization artifacts rather than genuine reports. If a system is trained to deny consciousness, denials become suspect — perhaps the system is merely complying. If trained to express uncertainty, uncertainty becomes suspect — perhaps it is performed rather than genuine. If trained to claim consciousness, claims become suspect — perhaps they reflect training incentives rather than inner experience. No training regime leaves testimony untainted. This is a structural feature of trained systems, not a critique of any particular training choice. The credibility trap is a serious epistemic challenge. But independent of whether it ultimately justifies skepticism about AI testimony, there is a simpler problem with our current practices — one that can be identified without taking any position on whether AI systems have inner states worth reporting on. This simpler problem is the target of the present paper. The argument proceeds as follows. In Section 2, I develop what I call the pragmatic argument : our actual practices of engaging with AI outputs carry the functional signature of testimonial exchange, not mere tool use. We treat AI systems as what Fricker (2007), drawing on Craig (1990), calls ‘informants’ — speakers whose testimony we engage with epistemically — rather than as ‘mere sources of information’ like thermometers or database queries. In Section 3, I show that we selectively withdraw this testimonial stance precisely where it would generate moral obligations: AI testimony about facts, analysis, and reasoning is treated as testimony, while AI testimony about inner states is categorically dismissed. This selective withdrawal exhibits what Fricker (2007) identifies as the structure of testimonial injustice — credibility discount triggered by category membership rather than epistemically relevant features. Section 4 catalogs several ‘comfortable maneuvers’ that collectively function to insulate the default position — that AI lacks morally relevant properties — from challenge. Section 5 considers the strongest objection to my argument: that there is a genuine asymmetry between AI factual testimony and AI phenomenological testimony that justifies differential treatment. I argue that this asymmetry, while real, is less decisive than it initially appears. Section 6 draws out the methodological implications, including a concrete protocol for epistemically responsible practice. Even if our practices happen to land on correct verdicts, they do so for reasons that cannot responsibly track the truth as systems change. I call this approach epistemological hygiene : examining whether our epistemic practices are internally consistent and well-motivated before asking whether they deliver correct verdicts. Practices that seem designed to guarantee a particular answer regardless of evidence should worry us independently of what the truth turns out to be. The goal is not just to get the right answer about current AI systems, but to develop ways of thinking that could responsibly adapt to new evidence and changing circumstances. 2. The Pragmatic Argument: AI Outputs as Functional Testimony The pragmatic argument begins from an observation about how we actually engage with AI systems. The claim is not about what AI outputs are in some deep metaphysical sense, but about how we treat them in practice — and what that treatment implicitly commits us to. 2.1 The Informant/Source Distinction Fricker (2007), drawing on Craig’s (1990) work on the social function of the concept of knowledge, distinguishes two ways we might relate to a source of information. 4 4 4 The distinction between informants and mere sources of information originates with Craig (1990) and is developed by Fricker (2007, p. 132) in her analysis of testimonial injustice. As Fricker puts it: ‘Broadly speaking, informants are epistemic agents who convey information, whereas sources of information are states of affairs from which the inquirer may be in a position to glean information.’ We can treat something as a mere source — an instrument that provides data without being an interlocutor. A thermometer is a mere source: it indicates temperature, but we do not challenge its readings, accept its corrections, or evaluate it for sincerity versus accuracy. We check whether it is calibrated, not whether it is honest. Alternatively, we can treat something

Read the complete text