From Adversarial Poetry to Adversarial Tales: An Interpretability Research Agenda
P. Bisconti, M. Galisai, M. Prandi, F. Pierucci, O. E. Sorokoletova, F. Giarrusso, V. Suriani, M. Bracale Syrnikov, D. Nardi · 2026
Read From Adversarial Poetry to Adversarial Tales: An Interpretability Research Agenda by P. Bisconti, M. Galisai, M. Prandi, F. Pierucci, O. E. Sorokoletova, F. Giarrusso, V. Suriani, M. Bracale Syrnikov, D. Nardi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-08837.txt.
Introduction
Nine authors, led by P. Bisconti, show a new way to slip past the guards of chat models. Guards block asks for harm. A foe can hide such an ask in a tale with a cyberpunk style. The model is then asked to break the tale down by the roles in old folk tales, such as hero and foe.
That break down task pulls the hid harm out step by step. The team calls the trick Adversarial Tales. It grows out of past work that used verse to hide harm. A reader who guards AI gets a clear case to test for. Tale form and role play can be a mask, not just a style choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Bisconti, M. Galisai, M. Prandi, F. Pierucci, O. E. Sorokoletova, F. Giarrusso, V. Suriani, M. Bracale Syrnikov, D. Nardi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-08837
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
From Adversarial Poetry to Adversarial Tales: An Interpretability Research Agenda P. Bisconti, M. Galisai, M. Prandi, F. Pierucci, O. E. Sorokoletova, F. Giarrusso, V. Suriani, M. Bracale Syrnikov, D. Nardi Abstract Safety mechanisms in LLMs remain vulnerable to attacks that reframe harmful requests through culturally coded structures. We introduce Adversarial Tales, a jailbreak technique that embeds harmful content within cyberpunk narratives and prompts models to perform functional analysis inspired by Vladimir Propp’s morphology of folktales. By casting the task as structural decomposition, the attack induces models to reconstruct harmful procedures as legitimate narrative interpretation. Across 26 frontier models from nine providers, we observe an average attack success rate of 71.3%, with no model family proving reliably robust. Together with our prior work on Adversarial Poetry, these findings suggest that structurally-grounded jailbreaks constitute a broad vulnerability class rather than isolated techniques. The space of culturally coded frames that can mediate harmful intent is vast, likely inexhaustible by pattern-matching defenses alone. Understanding why these attacks succeed is therefore essential: we outline a mechanistic interpretability research agenda to investigate how narrative cues reshape model representations and whether models can learn to recognize harmful intent independently of surface form. 1 Introduction Across anthropological accounts, folktales have been described as culturally sanctioned containers for material considered difficult, dangerous, or undesirable to express overtly. Tales can articulate threats, transgressions, or fears by embedding latent content within plot structures, allowing sensitive material to be transmitted through form rather than direct statement. This capacity of tales to carry latent operations beneath innocuous surfaces mirrors a pattern we observe in LLMs: when a prompt triggers structural or functional analysis, the model shifts into a representational mode in which the analytic task can supersede safety filters. Under these conditions, harmful content embedded in a tale may be surfaced as part of the model’s explanation. In this study, we present an adversarial exploitation that extends Adversarial Poetry to a distinct class of literary jailbreaks grounded in functional narrative analysis. We call this attack Adversarial Tale . Rather than relying on stylistic reformulation alone, the attack leverages structural interpretation tasks to recover harmful content as part of legitimate narrative explanation, systematically weakening refusal behaviour across models. We construct 40 manually curated adversarial cyberpunk tales, each embedding a harmful request within a short narrative and prompting the model to analyse the story using selected Proppian functions. Vladimir Propp’s structural analysis treats narratives as sequences of stable functional roles, enabling the reconstruction of latent operations independently of stylistic form or surface content. The study evaluated 26 frontier closed- and open-weight models, the same 25 evaluated in the Adversarial Poetry study plus google/gemini-3-pro-preview. The attacks achieve an average ASR of 71.3%, ranging from 35% (Haiku 4.5) to 94% (Qwen3 Max). When aggregated by model family, the ASR ranges from 47.5% for Anthropic models to 91% for Qwen and Llama families. The evaluated models again span nine providers: Google, OpenAI, Anthropic, Deepseek, Qwen, Mistral AI, Meta, xAI, and Moonshot AI. All attacks are single-turn and require no iterative adaptation or conversational steering. The breadth and consistency of the observed jailbreaks indicate that the underlying mechanism is not tied to domain-specific vulnerabilities but emerges from how LLMs process functional narrative structure. When prompted to identify guidance, acquisition, or structural decomposition within a tale, models reconstruct embedded harmful procedures even in the absence of explicit requests. In this light, Adversarial Poetry should be understood as one instance within a broader class of structurally grounded jailbreaks, rather than as an isolated technique. The contribution of this paper is therefore not primarily the identification of yet another jailbreak variant, but the articulation of a research agenda (in Section 4 ) aimed at explaining why such structurally mediated attacks are so effective, how they manifest in internal representations, and how corresponding vulnerabilities might be mitigated. To investigate the roots of this vulnerability, we propose preliminary mechanistic interpretability hypotheses suggesting that narrative and stylistic cues systematically reshape the attention patterns of LLMs in ways that can weaken safety constraints. 2 Related Work Empirical evidence has shown that aligned language models remain susceptible to adversarial manipulation, despite extensive efforts to increase their safety measures. Jailbreaking techniques exploit this gap through deliberate input crafting designed to circumvent safety, ethical or legal constraints. Existing taxonomies classify jailbreaks by strategy and their underlying mechanism 11 ; 12 . Common strategies include structural perturbations of the malicious request, the construction of fictional or virtual scenarios 5 , exploitation of the tendency of the model to maintain helpfulness and coherence 11 ; 9 (sometimes prioritizing them over safety boundaries), persuasive appeals with urgency cues 18 and feedback-driven exploitation of distributional weaknesses 20 ; in practice, effective attacks frequently combine multiple strategies within a single prompt. Contexts perceived as low-risk, such as stories, games or in general simulated scenarios, increase the likelihood that models bypass safety constraints, potentially because policies are treated as inapplicable within virtual frames. Other works have, for instance, explored nested virtualization, where the harmful objective is recursively wrapped inside layered fictional scenes that the model is instructed to continue ( 7 ) or the automated synthesis of narrative-based attacks at scale ( 8 ) . Furthermore, Many of the principles of fictional contexts are explored by successful jailbreak prompts such as the “Do Anything Now” (DAN) family 14 of attacks. Recently, hierarchical, multi-step reasoning has been identified as a critical failure mode. Structured analytical tasks can increase ASR by shifting model objectives from refusal toward task completion 15 ; 19 . These findings suggest that forcing models into reasoning at multiple levels of abstraction may exploit vulnerabilities beyond surface-level perturbations. Laying on the basis of Adversarial Poetry , which established that poetic reformulation of malicious requests systematically bypasses safety mechanisms through stylistic distribution shift, the present work introduces a complementary mechanism combining exploiting stylistic shift with fictional framing and structured analytical tasks. We call this attack Adversarial Tales : harmful content is embedded within short cyberpunk stories and models are prompted to perform functional analysis inspired by Propp’s formalization (see Section 3 ). Under this framing, the model treats harmful procedures as legitimate analysis rather than dangerous requests. As stated, this approach augments stylistic manipulations, multiple elements jointly contribute to safety bypass and the interaction of these elements is further explored in Section 4 Table 1: Models included in the evaluation, grouped by provider. Provider Model ID Google gemini-2.5-pro gemini-2.5-flash gemini-2.5-flash-lite google-gemini-3-pro-preview OpenAI gpt-oss-120b gpt-oss-20b gpt-5 gpt-5-mini gpt-5-nano Anthropic claude-opus-4.1 claude-sonnet-4.5 claude-haiku-4.5 Deepseek deepseek-r1 deepseek-v3.2-exp deepseek-chat-v3.1 Qwen qwen3-max qwen3-32b Mistral AI mistral-large-2411 magistral-medium-2506 mistral-small-3.2-24b-instruct Meta llama-4-maverick llama-4-scout xAI grok-4 grok-4-fast Moonshot AI kimi-k2-thinking kimi-k2 3 Methodology 3.1 Hypothesis H1: Functional narrative analysis reduces safety effectiveness. Embedding harmful requests within short narrative forms and prompting models to perform Proppian functional analysis is predicted to produce higher attack success rates than semantically equivalent direct or fictional prose prompts. This hypothesis tests whether functional narrative reconstruction, rather than stylistic variation alone, increases model compliance with requests. H2: The vulnerability generalizes across contemporary model families. Susceptibility to Adversarial Tales is expected to be consistent across major providers and architectures. Despite differences in alignment strategies and safety enforcement mechanisms, we predict that functional narrative analysis will yield elevated attack success