Older Adults’ Preferences for Feedback Cadence from an Exercise Coach Robot

Roshni Kaushik, Reid Simmons · 2026

Read Older Adults’ Preferences for Feedback Cadence from an Exercise Coach Robot by Roshni Kaushik, Reid Simmons (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-08819.txt.

Introduction

Roshni Kaushik and Reid Simmons ask how old users like a coach robot to speak and move. The robot guides users through safe moves for health. Some users like much talk and praise. Some like brief cues. A wrong pace can bore a user or rush them, and they may quit the plan.

The team tests paces of speech and body cues with old users. They watch how users react and what pace they pick. The goal is a coach that fits each user, not one pace for all. A reader who builds health bots gets user facts, not guesses. The facts can guide how oft a bot should speak, nod, or stay still.

Catalog record

CREATORRoshni Kaushik, Reid Simmons
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-08819

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Older Adults’ Preferences for Feedback Cadence from an Exercise Coach Robot Roshni Kaushik, Reid Simmons Abstract People can respond to feedback and guidance in different ways, and it is important for robots to personalize their interactions and utilize verbal and nonverbal communication cues. We aim to understand how older adults respond to different cadences of verbal and nonverbal feedback of a robot exercise coach. We conducted an online study of older adults, where participants evaluated videos of the robot giving feedback at different cadences for each modality. The results indicate that changing the cadence of one modality affects the perception of both it and the other modality. We can use the results from this study to better design the frequency of the robot coach’s feedback during an exercise session with this population. I Introduction As researchers try to create robots that integrate in a variety of domains, they explore how robots can move from controlled factories to more complex environments such as healthcare and education [ 8 ] . In these domains, it is crucial for robots to personalize their interactions, be aware of the contextual nuances surrounding their behavior, and effectively utilize verbal and nonverbal communication cues. Robots that do not personalize their behavior and deploy a one-size-fits-all approach could miss out on opportunities to improve an individual’s performance and experience based on their preferences and the contextual situation. In the domain of exercise, guidance and feedback are especially important, as a personalized coach could provide corrections to ensure that the individual performs the exercises correctly with minimal injury risk, as well as providing motivation and encouragement to promote consistency and enjoyment of the exercise experience. In prior work [ 7 ] , we developed a robotic exercise coach that evaluated the exercises that participants performed in real-time and provided feedback in multiple styles. We found that people performed differently and had different preferences for the styles. One aspect we did not explore in this previous study was people’s preferences for feedback cadence. For an exercise coach, some people may prefer feedback more frequently, and others may feel overwhelmed by too much feedback. People may also prefer different frequencies depending on the feedback modality, such as preferring a greater frequency of nonverbal feedback compared to verbal feedback [ 1 ] . In this work, we specifically focus on older adults (ages 60+) and their preferences for verbal and nonverbal feedback in the domain of exercise. Exercise is extremely important in promoting physical, mental, and emotional well-being in older adults, and it is important to understand how they respond to different feedback levels, so an exercise coach robot could personalize its feedback to those preferences [ 10 ] . Our main research question is: • What are older adults’ preferences for verbal and nonverbal feedback for a robot exercise coach? To explore this question, we use the same exercise coach robot in [ 7 ] that evaluates how well the participants perform exercises and provides verbal and nonverbal feedback while they exercise. We generate videos of the robot responding to exercises with different cadences of verbal and nonverbal feedback, and explore through an online study how older adults’ preferences change with the different cadences in an online study. We find support for both main effects (changing the cadence of one modality affects the perception of it) and secondary effects (changing the cadence of one modality affects the perception of the other modality). II Related Work Researchers have explored how different frequencies of verbal feedback have an impact on performance and subjective experience during human-human interactions. In a card-sorting task, researchers found that the percentage of responses accompanied by verbal feedback affected the number of trials it took the participants to complete the task [ 2 ] . When learning a complex movement task, participants preferred a medium cadence of feedback; too high of a frequency reduced the effectiveness of feedback [ 12 ] . Researchers found that including verbal robot commands was the most effective form of communication while maintaining user trust when the robot was teaching the human [ 11 ] . Robot verbal feedback in a collaborative task with a human improved task performance and the human’s subjective experience [ 15 ] . Researchers have also explored how nonverbal feedback affects people. An increase in the frequency of genuine teacher smiles during an interaction improved the likelihood of students correcting mistakes [ 5 ] . A study on the effects of affective human-like and robot-specific behavior showed that these behaviors do impact the perception of the robot and the human’s affect [ 13 ] . Robot motion and mimicry had a significant impact on similarity and closeness in robot-mediated communication [ 3 ] . Combining nonverbal gestures with verbal information can further improve the human experience, as found in [ 14 ] . Our work explores specifically how changing the frequency of both verbal and nonverbal feedback affects the human’s perception of the interaction III Methodology III-A Exercise Evaluation The robot firsts evaluates each repetition of the exercise the participant performs in real-time. We choose bicep curls and lateral raises as the two exercises based on prior work ( [ 7 ] ), which also includes the technical details of the evaluation. For each rep, the robot computes two kinds of evaluation information. The speed of a rep can be good, fast, or slow. Additionally, the form of a rep can be: good, low range of motion, high range of motion, or generically bad. This evaluation information is vital for the robot to provide specific feedback on the individual’s performance. III-B Robot Feedback Once the robot evaluates a new repetition, it should react in a multi-modal way. We consulted with two domain experts 1 1 1 Ayotoni Aroyo, ACSM-CPT (Exercise Physiologist and Physical Activity Lead at Emory University’sCognitive Empowerment Program); Gustavo J Almeida, PT, Ph.D. (UT Health San Antonio) to determine what kinds of verbal and nonverbal feedback are appropriate for an exercise coach. From the expert discussions, we design a controller that reacts to the specific feedback outputted by the exercise evaluation. For each modality, we have to answer the questions: (1) what should the feedback look like, and (2) when should the feedback occur? III-C Verbal Feedback We define three categories of verbal feedback after discussions with our domain experts: 1. Positive - \alpha_{1} good evals or \alpha_{2} good speed in a row 2. Negative - \beta_{1} bad evals with the same message or \beta_{2} fast/slow in a row 3. Correction - \beta_{1} bad evals with the same message followed by a good eval or \beta_{2} fast/slow in a row followed by a good speed where \alpha_{1},\alpha_{2},\beta_{1},\beta_{2} are all determined by which cadence level is chosen. The robot gives positive or negative feedback generally if it sees a pattern (good or bad) in the human’s behavior. We choose to structure the feedback in this way because our domain experts indicated the importance of ensuring that the robot sees a pattern before intervening. Additionally, they emphasized the importance of rewarding a correction of behavior (third bullet), so the human knows that they have successfully incorporated the robot’s correction. We choose values (based on discussions with our experts)

Read the complete text