Between Policy and Practice: GenAI Adoption in Agile Software Development Teams

Michael Neumann, Lasse Bischof, Nic Elias Hinz, Abdullah Altun, Luca Stockmann, Dennis Schrader, Ana Carolina Ahaus, Erim Can Demirci, Benjamin Gabel, Maria Rauschenberger, Philipp Diebold, Henning Fritzemeier, Adam Przybyłek · 2026

Read Between Policy and Practice: GenAI Adoption in Agile Software Development Teams by Michael Neumann, Lasse Bischof, Nic Elias Hinz, Abdullah Altun, Luca Stockmann, Dennis Schrader, Ana Carolina Ahaus, Erim Can Demirci, Benjamin Gabel, Maria Rauschenberger, Philipp Diebold, Henning Fritzemeier, Adam Przybyłek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-07051.txt.

Introduction

Michael Neumann and colleagues wrote a 2026 arXiv preprint. The work covers between policy and practice. ArXiv posted the preprint in 2026 under its PAPERS collection. Context: The rapid emergence of generative AI (GenAI) tools has begun to reshape various software engineering activities.

Yet, their adoption within agile environments remains underexplored. Objective: The work investigates how agile practitioners adopt GenAI tools in real-world organizational contexts, focusing on regulatory conditions, use cases, benefits, and barriers. The work gives specialists a compact account of the problem and one proposed way to handle it.

Catalog record

CREATORMichael Neumann, Lasse Bischof, Nic Elias Hinz, Abdullah Altun, Luca Stockmann, Dennis Schrader, Ana Carolina Ahaus, Erim Can Demirci, Benjamin Gabel, Maria Rauschenberger, Philipp Diebold, Henning Fritzemeier, Adam Przybyłek
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-07051

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Between Policy and Practice: GenAI Adoption in Agile Software Development Teams Michael Neumann, Lasse Bischof, Nic Elias Hinz, Abdullah Altun, Luca Stockmann, Dennis Schrader, Ana Carolina Ahaus, Erim Can Demirci, Benjamin Gabel, Maria Rauschenberger, Philipp Diebold, Henning Fritzemeier, Adam Przybyłek Abstract Context: The rapid emergence of generative AI (GenAI) tools has begun to reshape various software engineering activities. Yet, their adoption within agile environments remains underexplored. Objective: This study investigates how agile practitioners adopt GenAI tools in real-world organizational contexts, focusing on regulatory conditions, use cases, benefits, and barriers. Method: An exploratory multiple case study was conducted in three German organizations, involving 17 semi-structured interviews and document analysis. A cross-case thematic analysis was applied to identify GenAI adoption patterns. Results: Findings reveal that GenAI is primarily used for creative tasks, documentation, and code assistance. Benefits include efficiency gains and enhanced creativity, while barriers relate to data privacy, validation effort, and lack of governance. Using the Technology-Organization-Environment (TOE) framework, we find that these barriers stem from misalignments across the three dimensions. Regulatory pressures are often translated into policies without accounting for actual technological usage patterns or organizational constraints. This leads to systematic gaps between policy and practice. Conclusion: GenAI offers significant potential to augment agile roles but requires alignment across TOE dimensions, including clear policies, data protection measures, and user training to ensure responsible and effective integration. 1 Introduction The rapid development and use of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in recent years has precipitated a profound transformation across a wide array of economic and technological domains. We see a high impact even in institutional contexts such as higher education [ 19 ] or public administration [ 26 ] . Also, the rise of GenAI since the release of ChatGPT in November 2022 has had various effects on our daily work and life in the various industries [ 11 , 20 ] . Today, GenAI tools such as ChatGPT or GitHub Copilot are used in a wide range of software engineering [ 4 ] and thus led to a change in the way software development teams work and operate [ 25 ] . For example, we know that software professionals apply GenAI for routine tasks like writing source code [ 16 ] or test cases [ 2 , 10 ] . Also, further approaches like AI agent-based tools are applied in practice to support the elicitation and analysis of requirements [ 27 , 36 ] . We know from the growing research body that the effects of GenAI adoption in software development are diverse. Besides a growing performance of software development teams, other authors mention negative effects and risks [ 29 , 28 ] , e.g., on source code quality [ 21 , 31 ] . Thus, the importance of human-integration is emphasized in the literature [ 22 ] , in particular, by providing specific values and principles in the Copenhagen Manifesto [ 24 ] . Within the area of agile software development (ASD), in particular, GenAI tools promise to automate routine tasks, foster creativity, and significantly improve the productivity of software developers and project stakeholders [ 35 ] . Agile methods, characterized by iterative development cycles, cross-functional collaboration, and continuous feedback, provide a particularly conducive environment for the piloting and integration of GenAI tools into established workflows [ 9 ] . However, the deployment of these sophisticated systems also introduces a range of new challenges. According to Bahi et al. [ 3 ] , practitioners are confronted with critical questions such as: “Is the use of such tools permissible?” and “Can sensitive data be safely disclosed to GenAI services?”. As agile methods are focusing strongly on social interaction and communication, one may assume that various agile related practices with a strong emphasis on social interaction such as pair programming are affected [ 30 ] when specific tasks are performed with GenAI support instead of humans [ 1 ] . We know that the facet how agile software development teams specifically adopt GenAI tools in their practice is underrepresented in literature. Thus, in this study, we address the following research questions: • RQ 1: What organizational and regulatory conditions shape GenAI adoption in practice? • RQ 2: Which use cases of GenAI tools are adopted in agile software development teams? • RQ 3: What benefits and barriers do agile team members associate while they adopt GenAI? The paper is structured as follows: In the next Section, we provide an overview of the related work and present the contributions of our study in Section 2 . In Section 3 , we explain how we applied the multiple case study. Next, we present our results and answer the research questions in Section 4 . The paper closes with a conclusion in Section 6 . 2 Literature Review In this Section, we provide an overview of the identified related work. As related work in the area of ASD is limited, we searched with a broader scope in the software engineering field and found some studies closely related to ours. The study most closely related to ours is by Kemell et al. [ 14 ] , who conducted a multiple case study across seven companies to examine GenAI adoption, identifying relevant use cases and challenges. They found six organizational barriers, including data privacy and legacy system concerns, as well as issues related to the black-box nature of LLMs. From a user perspective, they reported four further challenges, notably the complexity of learning to apply GenAI tools—particularly regarding prompt formulation in daily work. Karlovs-Karlovskis [ 13 ] supports these findings in his systematic literature review. Among 117 analyzed studies, about 65% focus on GenAI-based code generation, revealing major gaps in empirical research on real-world integration and a lack of studies in other domains with potential for cost reduction, innovation, and optimization. Similar observations are made by Nguyen Duc et al. [ 20 ] , whose focus group covering eleven software engineering areas shows that research concentrates on implementation, quality assurance, and maintenance, while requirements engineering, design, and education remain underrepresented. They nonetheless argue that GenAI is likely to fundamentally transform the discipline, despite the early stage of current research. Overall, existing research on GenAI in software engineering—especially within ASD—remains limited. While some studies ( e.g. , Ulfsnes et al. [ 33 ] ; Coutinho et al. [ 7 ] ) highlight productivity gains and tool versatility, they also point to persistent issues in knowledge sharing, reliability, and security. Bahi et al. [ 3 ] similarly show that GenAI can support Scrum practices but emphasize ongoing challenges across the development lifecycle, underscoring the paucity of empirical evidence from real-world agile environments. Recent XP conference editions also hosted two workshops on GenAI and Agile (2024; 2025), producing exploratory papers on GenAI use in specific agile practices, such as Test-Driven Development [ 17 ] , and broader topics like responsibility [ 32 ] and teamwork effects [ 15 ] . While informative, their exploratory nature and workshop format limit their applicability to our research questions. To address the identified gaps, this qualitative study examines the use of GenAI within agile software teams. It explores how GenAI is applied in practice, the organizational implications of its adoption, and relevant use cases

Read the complete text