Profinite genus of HNN-extensions with finite associated subgroups
V.R. de Bessa, A.L.P. Porto, P.A. Zalesskii · 2026
Read Profinite genus of HNN-extensions with finite associated subgroups by V.R. de Bessa, A.L.P. Porto, P.A. Zalesskii (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-06934.txt.
Introduction
V.R. de Bessa and co-authors posted a 2026 arXiv preprint. The preprint deals with profinite genus of HNN-extensions with finite associated subgroups. It came out on arXiv in 2026 as a PAPERS preprint. The authors study the profinite genus of HNN-extensions whose associated subgroups are finite. We give precise formulas for the number of isomorphism classes of HNN ( G , H.
K , t , f ) HNN(G,H,K,t,f) and of its profinite completion and compute the profinite genus of such an HNN-extension HNN ( G. H , K , t , f ) HNN(G,H,K,t,f). Readers in the field get a short, focused account of the problem and the steps the authors take.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | V.R. de Bessa, A.L.P. Porto, P.A. Zalesskii |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 135 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-06934
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Profinite genus of HNN-extensions with finite associated subgroups V.R. de Bessa, A.L.P. Porto, P.A. Zalesskii Abstract We study the profinite genus of HNN-extensions whose associated subgroups are finite. We give precise formulas for the number of isomorphism classes of HNN ( G , H , K , t , f ) {\rm HNN}(G,H,K,t,f) and of its profinite completion and compute the profinite genus of such an HNN-extension HNN ( G , H , K , t , f ) {\rm HNN}(G,H,K,t,f) . We also list various situations when HNN ( G , H , K , t , f ) {\rm HNN}(G,H,K,t,f) is determined by its profinite completion. 1 Introduction There has been much recent study of whether residually finite groups, or classes of residually finite groups of combinatorial nature may be distinguished from each other by their sets of finite quotient groups. In group theory the study in this direction started in 70-th of the last century when Baumslag [ 3 ] , Stebe [ 42 ] and others found examples of finitely generated residually finite groups having the same set of finite quotients. The general question addressed in this study can be formulated as follows: Question 1 . To what extent a finitely generated residually finite group \Gamma is determined by its finite quotients? The study leaded to the notion of genus \mathfrak{g}(G) of a residually finite group G , the set of isomorphism classes of finitely generated residually finite groups having the same set of finite quotients as G . Equivalently, \mathfrak{g}(G) is the set of isomorphism classes of finitely generated residually finite groups having the profinite completion isomorphic to the profinite completion \widehat{G} of G . This study mostly was concentrated to establish whether the cardinality of the genus \mathfrak{g}(G) is finite or 1 (see [ 1 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 13 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 30 , 14 , 15 , 44 ] for example) (we use the same term genus for g(G) from now on). There are only few papers where exact numbers or estimates of the genus appear due to the difficulties of such calculation (see [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 22 , 31 , 32 , 33 ] ). However, the following principle question of Remeslennikov is still open [ 26 , Question 5.48] . Question 2 . (V.N. Remeslennikov) Is the genus g(F) of a free group F of finite rank equals 1? There are two basic constructions in combinatorial group theory: free product with amalgamation and HNN-extension. As many groups of combinatorial and geometric nature split as an amalgamted free product or HNN-extension, it has sense to study the genus of these constructions. It is natural to start with splitting over finite groups, and for free products with amalgamation this was done in [ 6 ] . However, since Remeslennikov’s question is not answered, it is not clear whether the profinite completion of an one-ended group does not split as an amalgamated free product or an HNN-extension over a finite group. This naturally gives restriction to the family in which one does considerations. A finitely generated residually finite group G with less than 2 ends, i.e. a finite or one ended group, will be called an {\rm OE} -group in the paper. It follows from the famous Stallings theorem that G is an {\rm OE} -group if and only if whenever it acts on a tree with finite edge stabilizers it has a global fixed point. A finitely generated profinite group will be called {\rm OE} -group if it has the same property: whenever it acts on a profinite tree with finite edge stabilizers, then it fixes a vertex. Note that finite and one-ended groups acting on a tree have a global fixed point and we need to extend this property to the profinite completion. A finitely generated residually finite group G will be called \rm\widehat{OE} -group if \widehat{G} is a profinite {\rm OE} -group, i.e. \widehat{G} can not act on a profinite tree with finite edge stabilizers without a global fixed point (see Definition 2.2 for the definition of a profinite tree). Note that the class \rm\widehat{OE} -groups is quite large. It contains all finitely generated residually finite not infinite virtually cyclic soluble groups, virtually surface groups, indecomposable (into free products) 3-manifold groups, indecomposable RAAGs, as well as all arithmetic groups of rank >1 and finitely generated residually finite Fab groups (see Propositions 2.6 and 2.7 ). The subject of the present paper is to complement the work that was done in [ 5 ] and [ 6 ] by studying the profinite genus of HNN-extensions of an \rm\widehat{OE} -group whose associated subgroups are finite. Note that in [ 7 ] examples of HNN-extensions with finite base group whose profinite completions are isomorphic were given and in this paper we give more examples with not obligatory finite base group. We first investigate the isomorphism problems for (profinite) abstract HNN-extensions that are of independent interest and in fact calculate the number of isomorpism classes of such abstract HNN-extensions (see Sections 3 and 4 ). Let G={\rm HNN}(G_{1},H,K,f,t) be an abstract HNN-extension with finite associated subgroups H and K . Denote by S the set of all finite subgroups of G_{1} . There is a natural action of G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}(G_{1}) on the set S namely (g_{1},\alpha)\cdot X=g_{1}\alpha(X)g_{1}^{-1}\in S,\mbox{ where }(g_{1},\alpha)\in G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}(G_{1}),X\in S. (1) Denote by {\rm Aut}_{G_{1}}(H) the set of automorphisms of G_{1} that leaves H invariant. Then the stabilizer of the conjugacy class of H in G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}(G_{1}) is the subgroup \Gamma_{H}:=G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}_{G_{1}}(H) (2) of the holomorph G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}(G_{1}) . Denote by \Gamma_{HK} the stabilizer of K\in S in \Gamma_{H} . Let {\rm Iso}(H,K) be the set of all isomorphisms of H in K. Then \Gamma_{HK} acts naturally on the set of isomorphisms {\rm Iso}(H,K) whose action is given by (g_{1},\alpha)\cdot f=\tau_{g_{1}}\alpha f\alpha^{-1}, where (g_{1},\alpha)\in\Gamma_{HK} , f\in{\rm Iso}(H,K) and \tau_{g_{1}} it the inner automorphism corresponding to g_{1} . We denote by \widetilde{\Gamma}_{HK} the image of \Gamma_{HK} in the symmetric group Sym({\rm Iso}(H,K)). Depending on the choice of H and K it might exist \psi\in{\rm Aut}(G_{1}) that swaps the conjugacy classes of H and K , say \psi(H)=K and \psi(K)=H^{g_{1}} for some g_{1}\in G_{1} . In this case the "invertion" of elements of {\rm Iso}(H,K) followed by the action by the element (g^{\prime},\psi)\in G_{1}\rtimes{\rm Aut}(G_{1}) gives an element \iota\in Sym({\rm Iso}(H,K)) that normalizes \widetilde{\Gamma}_{HK} and so \overline{\Gamma}_{HK}:=\widetilde{\Gamma}_{HK}\cdot\langle\iota\rangle is a group that does not depend in fact upon a choice of \psi (see Lemma 3.3 ). If such \psi does not exist we put \overline{\Gamma}_{HK}:=\widetilde{\Gamma}_{HK} . Theorem 1.1 . Let G_{1} be an {\rm OE} -group and G={\rm HNN}(G_{1},H,K,f,t),B={\rm HNN}(G_{1},H,K,f_{1},t_{1}) be abstract HNN-extensions with fixed finite associated subgroups H,K of G_{1} . Then G and B are isomorphic if and only if f and f_{1} belong to the same \overline{\Gamma}_{HK} -orbit in {\rm Iso}(H,K) . Corollary 1.2 . The number of isomorphism classes of HNN-extensions {\rm HNN}(G_{1},H,K,f,t) with G_{1},H,K fixed is |\overline{\Gamma}_{HK}\backslash{\rm Iso}(H,K)|. If the associated subgroups H and K are conjugate in G_{1} , we can make