Limits of vacuum-template subtraction for LISA massive black hole binary sources in realistic environments

Lorenz Zwick · 2026

Read Limits of vacuum-template subtraction for LISA massive black hole binary sources in realistic environments by Lorenz Zwick (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-06684.txt.

Introduction

Lorenz Zwick tests vacuum-template subtraction for LISA black hole sources in 2026. LISA will observe massive black hole binaries from space over years. A global fit must subtract each source to find the others.

He investigates gravitational wave dephasing due to gas accretion on the binaries. The subtraction is studied over four years of LISA data. Realistic environments, not clean vacuum, are the paper's key focus. Gas can shift a binary's phase enough to leave residuals behind. Those residuals could corrupt the global fit for other sources. His limits show where vacuum templates stop being good enough. Gravitational wave astronomers get a warning calibrated to real astrophysics. Environment effects must enter LISA analysis plans from the start.

Catalog record

CREATORLorenz Zwick
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-06684

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Limits of vacuum-template subtraction for LISA massive black hole binary sources in realistic environments Lorenz Zwick Abstract We investigate the impact of gravitational wave (GW) dephasing due to gas accretion on the subtraction of massive black hole (MBH) binary signals over 4 yr of LISA data in the context of the global-fit. Based on state of the art predictions for the population of merging MBHs, we show that imperfect subtraction with vacuum waveform templates leaves a GW residual with an SNR of 3.2 − 1.9 + 5.4 × f Edd ​ ⟨ n ˙ ⟩ / ( 20 ​ yr − 1 ) 3.2^{+5.4}_{-1.9}\times\sqrt{f_{\rm Edd}\langle\dot{n}\rangle/(20\,{\rm yr}^{-1})} , where f Edd f_{\rm Edd} is the typical Eddington ratio and ⟨ n ˙ ⟩ \langle\dot{n}\rangle the mean merger rate of LISA MBH binaries. We characterize the dependence of the residual on key population hyper-parameters, provide a simple fitting function and discuss detection and mitigation strategies. I Introduction A crucial difference between space-based gravitational-wave (GW) observatories and their ground-based counterparts lies in the approach to data analysis: Signals detected by ground-based interferometers are typically short-lived, separated in time and frequency ( 1 ; 80 , see e.g.) . Instead, sources populating the mHz band probed by the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna 1 1 1 Among other proposed space based detectors ( 79 ; 83 ) . (LISA) will be composed of more diverse, long-lasting and overlapping GW signals ( 4 ; 108 ; 35 ) . As a consequence, LISA data analysis relies on a “global fit” approach ( 15 ; 42 ; 38 ; 7 ; 76 ; 35 ) , in which many signals must be modeled and subtracted simultaneously rather than sequentially. The necessity of a global fit introduces a number of challenges for properly distinguishing between true signals and noise. Several studies have explored the consequences of using simplified or imperfect GW templates when fitting for simultaneous signals, showing that modeling inaccuracies can lead to imperfect source subtraction and the appearance of unphysical biases or residual features in the data ( 37 ; 41 ; 31 ; 5 ; 70 ) . As a further complication, the vast majority of these works are relying on the assumption that both the true signals and the templates are fully described by vacuum General Relativity, such that additional physical effects induced by the environments of inspiralling binaries ( 29 ; 97 ; 10 ; 74 ; 72 ; 8 ; 68 ; 84 ; 19 ; 112 ; 93 ; 28 ; 56 ; 77 ; 120 ; 64 ; 34 ; 30 ; 98 ; 122 ; 109 ; 51 ; 111 ; 46 ; 27 ; 26 ; 123 ; 116 ; 126 ; 124 ; 44 ; 13 ; 23 ; 115 ; 52 ; 45 ; 36 ; 113 , known as environmental effects, hereafter EEs,) are neglected. However, this assumption is at odds with the astrophysical formation channels of LISA sources, which instead involve sustained interactions with gaseous or stellar media prior to and during their GW-driven evolution (see 3 , and references therein) . Among these sources, massive black hole (MBH) binaries produce the loudest signals in the LISA band. The evolution of MBH binaries from galactic separations down to the GW–dominated regime proceeds through multiple stages of hardening, mediated by interactions with the surrounding stellar population and/or the presence of a circumbinary gas disc ( 85 ; 14 ; 87 ; 100 ; 66 ; 25 ; 103 ; 21 ; 104 ) . In particular, it is expected for gas-assisted hardening to a key role in delivering binaries into the LISA band, a fact that is motivating the recent body of work devoted to characterizing MBH binary–disc interactions ( 110 ; 55 ; 49 ; 91 ; 62 ; 102 ; 50 ; 47 ) . Numerical simulations suggest that the influence of gas persists throughout the GW-driven inspiral ( 60 ; 48 ; 73 ; 6 ; 33 ; 90 ) , as both dynamical and viscous processes allow the disc to remain coupled to the binary. Beyond a plethora of interesting electromagnetic counterparts ( 107 ; 18 ; 81 ; 53 ; 101 ; 54 ; 61 ) , this residual interaction with gas can also induce environmental effects (EEs) in the GW signal, most notably in the form of a cumulative phase shift with respect to the vacuum evolution ( 8 ; 122 ; 64 ; 63 , see e.g.) . For individual MBH binaries, this environmentally induced dephasing is often marginal, detectable only in a subset of lighter, low-redshift sources. However, any mismatch between the true signal and the fitted template necessarily leaves behind a residual. Even in a regime where such effects are individually undetectable, the collective impact of residuals due to unmodelled EEs in a global-fit framework increases in tandem with the number of simultaneous signals. In this work, we characterize the limits of using vacuum waveform templates to subtract MBH binary signals from sources that are merging in realistic astrophysical environments, such as circumbinary discs. We show that accumulated residuals from unmodelled EEs are likely to produce a measurable power excess over the LISA noise power spectral density (PSD), analogous to the stochastic foreground generated by unresolved Galactic white dwarf binaries. We quantify this effect starting from state of the art predictions for populations of merging MBH binaries and realistic prescriptions for gas-induced dephasing, determining how the resulting PSD feature depends on key population parameters. Our results showcase a previously unexplored contribution to LISA noise and emphasize the importance of EEs not only for parameter estimation of individual sources, but also for the global characterization of the LISA data stream. The paper is structured as follows: In Sec. II , we describe our choices for parameterizing massive black hole binary populations, as well as outline the relevant GW physics. In Sec. III , we characterize the resulting residuals and quantify their dependence on the parameters of the population distributions for merging binaries. Finally, we discuss the implications of our findings and summarize our conclusions in Sec. IV . II Methods II.1 Massive binary populations and their environments Figure 1: Normalised differential merger rates from the ASTRID simulation ( 119 , blue) , L-Galaxies ( 69 , orange) and 9 (green). We employ a lognormal parametrization (black) with representative uncertainties (grey) to broadly reproduce the results of and the variation between different predictions. The distribution in mass ratio q is truncated between 0.01 and 1. The formation and evolution of MBH binaries from galactic scales down to sub-parsec separations is a long-standing problem in astrophysics ( 14 ; 87 ) . Both cosmological simulations and semi-analytical approaches are used to provide quantitative predictions for the merger rate of MBH binaries ( 86 ; 117 ; 118 ; 32 ) . In practice, such population models yield differential merger rates of the form: \frac{\mathrm{d}\dot{n}}{\mathrm{d}x}\propto\mathcal{P}_{x}(x) (1) where \dot{n} is the merger rate, \mathcal{P}_{x} the probability distribution and x represents one or more source parameters, such as the primary BH mass M_{1} , the binary mass ratio q<1 , or the redshift z . The detailed physical pathways for MBH binary

Read the complete text