Theoretical Prediction of optimal T c T_{c} for Nickelate La 3 − x ​ Sm x ​ Ni 2 ​ O 7 − δ \mathrm{La_{3-x}Sm_{x}Ni_{2}O_{7-\delta}}

Xiuqing Huang · 2026

Read Theoretical Prediction of optimal T c T_{c} for Nickelate La 3 − x ​ Sm x ​ Ni 2 ​ O 7 − δ \mathrm{La_{3-x}Sm_{x}Ni_{2}O_{7-\delta}} by Xiuqing Huang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-06083.txt.

Introduction

Xiuqing Huang predicts a ceiling for superconductivity in nickelate materials in a 2026 theory paper. Under high pressure, a lanthanum-samarium nickel oxide reaches a record transition temperature near the top of its class. That result raised the question of how high nickelate transition temperatures can go.

Huang argues two crystal forms of the material share a quantum-well structure that also governs a famous copper-based superconductor. A scaling law based on the depth of that well reproduces the measured temperatures closely. Further calculations give a universal limit near 100 kelvin for rare-earth nickelates, whatever the layer stacking. The paper also links broken mirror symmetry in paired quantum wells to Fermi pockets and to superconductivity at normal pressure.

Catalog record

CREATORXiuqing Huang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-06083

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Theoretical Prediction of optimal T c T_{c} for Nickelate La 3 − x ​ Sm x ​ Ni 2 ​ O 7 − δ \mathrm{La_{3-x}Sm_{x}Ni_{2}O_{7-\delta}} Xiuqing Huang Abstract Recently, the nickel-based superconductor T c T_{c} record was updated to 96 ​ K 96\ \text{K} in bilayer La 3 − x ​ Sm x ​ Ni 2 ​ O 7 − δ \mathrm{La_{3-x}Sm_{x}Ni_{2}O_{7-\delta}} (LSNO) under pressure, raising a critical question: Can its T c T_{c} exceed the 164 K benchmark of copper-based superconductors? We find that both monoclinic and tetragonal LSNO have an octahedral quantum well structure (determining T c T_{c} ) nearly identical to YBa 2 ​ Cu 3 ​ O 7 − δ \mathrm{YBa_{2}Cu_{3}O_{7-\delta}} (YBCO). Based on the formula T c = Λ / ξ 2 T_{c}=\Lambda/\xi^{2} (Planck ground-state quantum well oscillator hypothesis, ξ \xi = lattice parameter-determined quantum well depth), we predict Sm-doped nickelate T c T_{c} values of 93.4 ​ K 93.4\ \text{K} (monoclinic) and 97.1 ​ K 97.1\ \text{K} (tetragonal), in excellent agreement with experimental data ( 92 ​ K 92\ \text{K} and 96 ​ K 96\ \text{K} ). Notably, despite distinct composition and symmetry (LSNO: P ​ 2 1 / m P2_{1}/m ; YBCO: P ​ m ​ m ​ m Pmmm ), their ξ \xi ( 3.6629 ​ Å 3.6629\ \AA vs 3.6720 ​ Å 3.6720\ \AA ) and T c T_{c} ( 92 ​ K 92\ \text{K} vs 93 ​ K 93\ \text{K} ) are nearly identical. This validates the proposed superconducting formula and unifies copper-based and nickel-based superconductors at the angstrom-scale octahedral quantum well. Further predictions indicate the maximum achievable T c T_{c} for lanthanide-based nickelates (regardless of layer number) is ∼ 100 ​ K \sim 100\ \text{K} . The discovery of superconductivity in bilayer Ruddlesden–Popper (R–P) \mathrm{La_{3}Ni_{2}O_{7}} single crystals under high pressure ( T_{c}\sim 80\ \mathrm{K} ) 55 has attracted extensive experimental 59 ; 53 ; 34 ; 72 ; 8 ; 40 ; 15 ; 6 ; 75 ; 10 ; 46 ; 48 ; 69 ; 28 ; 29 ; 74 ; 36 ; 51 ; 65 ; 1 ; 14 ; 32 and theoretical attention 47 ; 52 ; 37 ; 25 ; 26 ; 68 ; 73 ; 38 ; 50 ; 60 ; 57 ; 43 ; 19 ; 9 ; 20 ; 4 ; 24 ; 67 ; 11 ; 62 ; 63 ; 70 ; 39 ; 5 . Subsequent studies have yielded numerous superconducting samples via various methods, yet their T_{c} remained around 80 K 59 ; 53 ; 34 ; 72 . To date, the scientific community lacks an effective superconducting mechanism or comprehensive theory for accurately predicting T_{c} , so the discovery of new superconductors still relies on researchers’ experience and trial-and-error experiments. Recently, Sm-doped nickel-based superconductors were synthesized via the ambient-pressure flux method, with T_{c} increased from 83 K to 96 K 33 . This breakthrough boosts the prospects of exploring higher- T_{c} superconductors and ignites the expectation of breaking the T_{c} record following cuprate superconductors, while challenging the guiding validity of existing theoretical frameworks 30 ; 2 ; 31 ; 16 . Within just two years, several comprehensive reviews on nickel-based superconductors have emerged 41 ; 58 ; 35 ; 61 , and theoretical/experimental studies are published frantically, pushing superconductivity research into the *nickelate era* almost overnight 42 . This scenario mirrors the excitement sparked by the 1986 cuprate 3 and 2008 iron-based superconductor discoveries 27 . Strikingly, the deluge of theoretical work provides no valuable insights; most studies merely replicate unproductive or erroneous efforts on cuprate and iron-based systems, leading to contradictory predictions. For bilayer \mathrm{R_{3}Ni_{2}O_{7}} ( \mathrm{R}=\text{La} to Sm ), for example, some studies argue T_{c} decreases with rare-earth ion radius 71 , while others predict an increase or even room-temperature superconductivity 45 ; 18 . Across cuprate, iron-based, and nickel-based systems, theoretical research is unproductive and misleading, mainly because subtle changes in temperature, pressure, or doping trigger intricate phase transitions—exemplified by KFeSe, where a slight pressure rise above 10.5 GPa abruptly boosts T_{c} from zero to over 40 K 56 , a phenomenon beyond existing theories. Undoubtedly, superconductivity theory urgently needs a new paradigm. Figure 1: Planckian Quantum Wells and Localized Electrons in Unconventional Superconductors. (a) Octahedral quantum wells in cuprates (YBCO, Bi-2223): their geometry and density dictate Fermi surface structure and symmetry, with well depth \xi governing optimal T_{c} . (b) Polyhedral quantum wells of 1111/111-type iron-based superconductors ( R : substitutable elements). Unlike cuprates, they possess two distinct well types ( \alpha , \beta ) with depths \xi_{\alpha} , \xi_{\beta} and corresponding dual superconducting phases. Lattice mirror symmetry ensures paired upward/downward quantum wells ( \alpha^{\pm} , \beta^{\pm} ). Since \xi_{\alpha}<\xi_{\beta} , hence T_{c}^{\alpha}>T_{c}^{\beta} . Pressure reduces \xi_{\beta} , driving originally localized \beta -pairing electrons in the Se plane into the high- T_{c} \alpha -Fe plane via enhanced Coulomb repulsion—this is the microscopic mechanism of dual-superconducting-phase transition in iron-based superconductors 56 . The predicament of superconductivity research arises from a false consensus: new superconductors demand new mechanisms. With over thirty categories and tens of thousands of superconducting materials discovered, this paradigm renders the high-temperature superconductivity puzzle permanently unsolvable. Let us consider an alternative view: why cannot all superconductors share a single universal mechanism? Casting back to 1911, when Onnes first discovered mercury superconductivity 44 , suppose cuprate, iron-based, and nickel-based superconductors were also found that year. Unshackled by the various theories and models that have failed to explain or predict superconductivity over the past century, how would we rethink and interpret the phenomenon of superconductivity? Does the artificially imposed divide between conventional and unconventional superconductors still necessary? The superconducting state is an energy-lossless coherent condensed state, which should positively correlate with conductivity (metallicity) and lattice simplicity/perfection. However, gold, silver, and copper—possessing the simplest, most perfect lattices and optimal conductivity—do not superconduct. In contrast, high- T_{c} superconductors positively correlate with energy-loss-inducing factors (e.g., insulation, disorder, doping, lattice distortion, resistivity). For instance, recent experiments revealed T_{c}\propto\sqrt{A_{1}} , where A_{1} denotes the linear resistance coefficient 66 . Moreover, cuprate, iron-based, and nickel-based high- T_{c} superconductors require doping (purity degradation) in their pristine parent phases to achieve high superconducting performance. Crucially, the traditional view that superconductivity originates from free electrons contradicts experimental observations. To resolve the contradiction among superconductivity, metallicity, and insulation, we propose that the superconducting state corresponds to the Planck quantum ground state. On this basis, we establish a novel theory centered on quantum-well-localized electrons with an electron-hole symmetry-breaking pairing mechanism, termed the QSP theory. Notably, the QSP theory has successfully explained and predicted nearly all superconducting phenomena observed in cuprate and iron-based systems 22 ; 23 . Table 1: The relationship between T_{c} and the depth \xi of localized electron quantum well in Cu- and Fe-based superconductors . 1st column: Superconductor compounds. 2nd column: Corresponding superconducting transition temperature ( T_{c} ). 3rd to 5th columns: Depths of different quantum wells in the superconductors (bold values denote superconducting phases corresponding to T_{c} ). 6th column: Correlation strength factor calculated by \Lambda=T_{c}\xi^{2} . Compound \textbf{T}_{\textbf{c}} (K) \xi_{\alpha} (Å) \xi_{\beta} (Å) \xi_{\gamma} (Å) \Lambda \mathrm{YBa_{2}Cu_{3}O_{7-\delta}} 93 {\bm{3.6720}} 1254 \mathrm{Bi_{2}Sr_{2}Ca_{2}Cu_{3}O_{10+\delta}} 110 3.1511 {\bm{3.3272}} 1217 \mathrm{TlBa_{2}CaCu_{2}O_{7+\delta}} 103 {\bm{3.5771}} 1317 \mathrm{TlBa_{2}Ca_{3}Cu_{4}O_{11+\delta}} 112

Read the complete text