Self-organization of local streamline structures and energy transfer rate in compressible plasma turbulence
Simone Benella, Virgilio Quattrociocchi, Emanuele Papini, Andrea Verdini, Simone Landi, Maria Federica Marcucci, Giuseppe Consolini · 2026
Read Self-organization of local streamline structures and energy transfer rate in compressible plasma turbulence by Simone Benella, Virgilio Quattrociocchi, Emanuele Papini, Andrea Verdini, Simone Landi, Maria Federica Marcucci, Giuseppe Consolini (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-05996.txt.
Introduction
Plasma turbulence organizes itself in ways Simone Benella and 6 co-authors examine in a 2026 simulation study. Plasma is hot ionized gas, and turbulence means its flows churn across many scales. The team asks how local streamline shapes, the paths flow follows, connect to energy moving between scales.
Using a fully compressible Hall magnetohydrodynamic simulation, a model of charged fluid with magnetic fields, they measure energy transfer below the grid scale. For nearly incompressible flow, strain-heavy and stable swirling structures send energy to smaller scales, while unstable swirls send it back. For compressible flow, compression or expansion of the plasma sets the direction instead, with no clear pattern from shape alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Simone Benella, Virgilio Quattrociocchi, Emanuele Papini, Andrea Verdini, Simone Landi, Maria Federica Marcucci, Giuseppe Consolini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-05996
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Self-organization of local streamline structures and energy transfer rate in compressible plasma turbulence Simone Benella, Virgilio Quattrociocchi, Emanuele Papini, Andrea Verdini, Simone Landi, Maria Federica Marcucci, Giuseppe Consolini Abstract We examine how local streamline topology and energy cascade rate self-organize in plasma turbulence for both compressible and incompressible regimes. Using a fully-compressible Hall-magnetohydrodynamic simulation, we quantify the subgrid-scale energy transfer and analyze its relationship to streamline structures by means of grandient tensor geometric invariants of the velocity field. Our results highlight how streamline topology is crucial for diagnosing turbulence: for nearly-incompressible fluctuations the energy is primarily transferred to smaller scales through strain-dominated and stable-vortical structures, while is back-transferred towards larger scales through unstable-vortical structures. Compressible fluctuations, on the contrary, do not show a clear topological selection of the energy transfer since the overall direction of the local cascade rate is found to be determined by the sign of − ∇ ⋅ 𝒖 -\nabla\cdot\bm{u} (plasma volumetric compression or expansion). show][email protected] I Introduction Turbulence in space plasmas remains a major open problem, despite significant advances from theory, improved spacecraft in situ measurements, and numerical simulations ( R. Bruno & V. Carbone 2016 ) . In a turbulent plasma, the large-scale energy budget is transferred across the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) inertial range toward ion scales through a cascading process that generates a hierarchy of structures at all scales. Observational and numerical studies have shown that while the average direction of the energy transfer is predominantly forward, inverse energy transfer can also occur at all scales. In the case of incompressible plasmas, for example, the emergence of inverse cascade has been linked to the imbalance between counter propagating Alfvén waves, suggesting a dependence of the local energy transfer to the large-scale organization of the turbulent fluctuations ( C. W. Smith et al. 2009 ; J. E. Stawarz et al. 2010 ; J. T. Coburn et al. 2014 ) . In addition to the local energy transfer associated with nonlinear interactions, at ion scales kinetic instabilities and other nonlocal processes can significantly contribute to the energy transfer. For instance, magnetic reconnection occurring at sub-ion scales has been shown to induce an inverse energy transfer toward MHD scales ( L. Franci et al. 2017 ; D. Manzini et al. 2023 ; R. Foldes et al. 2024 ) . An heuristic proxy of the energy transfer rate, which is local in time (space), hence called local energy transfer (LET), has been introduced by L. Sorriso-Valvo et al. 2018 in the context of numerical simulations. This quantity provides useful insights about the irregular and burst-like activity associated with the transfer rate from and towards small scales, and possibly constituting an indirect proxy of turbulent structures. The operative definition of the LET is based on the Yaglom’s law ( H. Politano & A. Pouquet 1998 ; R. Marino & L. Sorriso-Valvo 2023 ) , which is averaged on a fixed short time window, allowing to assess the locality of the energy transfer in time. The deep link between LET and kinetic plasma properties has been emphasized by ( L. Sorriso-Valvo et al. 2019 ) , where the LET has been estimated on Magnetospheric Multiscale ( J. L. Burch et al. 2016 , MMS;) measurements. As energy flows across scales, turbulence organizes in a hierarchy of coherent, multiscale structures. An effective way of investigating the local properties of such behavior is based on the statistics of the gradient-tensor geometrical invariants (GTGIs). The first investigation of the properties and the lagrangian dynamics of GTGIs has been provided by P. Vieillefosse 1982 , who introduced the evolution equation of GTGIs for a restricted Eurler system ( P. Vieillefosse 1984 , see also) . This simple theoretical framework has been later extended to more sophisticated models, such as shell models by L. Biferale et al. 2007 , (see C. Meneveau 2011 , for a review) . The typical hallmark of energy dissipation in the statistics of the GTGIs consists of an asymmetric feature called the Vieillefosse tail . In addition to the lagrangian time evolution of GTGIs, further investigations also elucidated the scale dependent behavior of GTGI statistics. M. Chertkov et al. 1999 showed that by coarse-graining the velocity field, the Vieillefosse tail tends to disappear when moving towards the inertial range. In the framework of MHD simulations, V. Dallas & A. Alexakis 2013 investigated the statistics of GTGIs of velocity and magnetic fields by means of MHD direct numerical simulations providing an extension of earlier hydrodynamic theories. First observational evidence of the presence of the Vieillefosse tail in the GTGI statistics in space plasmas was reported in G. Consolini et al. 2015 leveraging the multipoint measurements provided by the Cluster spacecraft constellation ( C. P. Escoubet et al. 1997 ) . In that work, authors showed that the typical asymmetry in the velocity-field gradients routinely observed in hydrodynamics is also present in the solar wind. Conversely, the absence of this feature in the magnetic field GTGIs, reported by V. Dallas & A. Alexakis 2013 in MHD simulations, has been confirmed by numerous studies based on data gathered by Cluster and Magnetospheric Multiscale (MMS) missions ( V. Quattrociocchi et al. 2019 ; B. Hnat et al. 2021 ; J. Zhang et al. 2023 ; V. Quattrociocchi et al. 2025 ) . All these works provide important clues on the properties of turbulent systems by quantifying the statistics of the formation of local structures, but their relation to the energy transfer has not been fully assessed yet. Evidence of the existing correlation between the energy transfer rate and the GTGIs, which elucidates how the local topology of streamline structures connects to the local turbulent cascade, has been introduced in the context of hydrodynamics ( F. van der Bos et al. 2002 ; A. Vela-Martín & J. Jiménez 2021 ; H. Yao et al. 2024 ) . In the field of space plasmas, the crucial interplay between field line topology and LET has been assessed by B. Hnat et al. 2025 for the magnetic field. They show that positive LET (i.e., direct energy cascade) exhibits a significant correlation with the occurrence of strain-dominated magnetic field structures, suggesting the crucial role of fundamental processes, such as magnetic reconnection, in driving the energy cascade. Figure 1: Sketch of the local streamline topologies in the RQ -plane for the three cases P=0 (left), P>0 (middle), and P<0 (right). Thick line is the discriminant surface \Delta . Red line marks the separation between stretching and compressing regions, and the dashed line indicate the separation between stable and unstable topologies. Shaded areas indicate topologies associated with local volumetric contraction (yellow) and expansion (green) emerging in compressible cases only. Another key aspect of all these studies presenting the statistics of GTGIs in space plasmas is that they rely on the assumption of incompressibility, which is encoded in the GTGI equations used in the data analysis. In this context, the aim of this letter is two-fold: to reveal the intimate relation between local streamline topology and energy transfer rate, and to investigate and compare this connection in both compressible and incompressible cases. All these steps are carried out by analyzing a three-dimensional Hall-MHD numerical simulation of plasma turbulence. II The geometric invariants of