Setting up the physical principles of resilience in a model of the Earth System

Orfeu Bertolami, Magnus Nyström · 2026

Read Setting up the physical principles of resilience in a model of the Earth System by Orfeu Bertolami, Magnus Nyström (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-05994.txt.

Introduction

Orfeu Bertolami and 1 co-author set out physical principles for resilience in a 2026 model of the Earth System. Resilience here means the capacity of a system to cope with change, adapt, and keep going. The paper links that idea to climate change and to keeping the planet habitable.

The model describes stable states and energy loss in terms of planetary boundaries, the limits that gauge human impact. Variables such as carbon dioxide levels, aerosol loading, and ozone loss interact in the model. Under stated conditions, stable states and a kind of dynamic friction can stop a runaway shift to a much hotter state. The authors argue such features may help keep future paths sustainable.

Catalog record

CREATOROrfeu Bertolami, Magnus Nyström
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-05994

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Setting up the physical principles of resilience in a model of the Earth System Orfeu Bertolami, Magnus Nyström Abstract Resilience is a property of social, ecological, social-ecological and biophysical systems. It describes the capacity of a system to cope with, adapt to and innovate in response to a changing surrounding. Given the current climate change crisis, ensuring conditions for a sustainable future for the habitability on the planet is fundamentally dependent on Earth System (ES) resilience. It is thus particularly relevant to establish a model that captures and frames resilience of the ES, most particularly in physical terms that can be influenced by human policy 1 1 1 See page 4 for examples of strategies . In this work we propose that resilience can serve as a theoretical foundation when unpacking and describing metastable states of equilibrium and energy dissipation in any dynamic description of the variables that characterise the ES. Since the impact of the human activities can be suitably gauged by the planetary boundaries (PBs) and the planet’s temperature is the net result of the multiple PB variables, such as CO 2 \text{CO}_{2} concentration and radiative forcing, atmospheric aerosol loading, atmospheric ozone depletion, etc, then resilience features arise once conditions to avoid an ES runaway to a state where the average temperature is much higher than the current one. Our model shows that this runaway can be prevented by the presence of metastable states and dynamic friction built out of the interaction among the PB variables once suitable conditions are satisfied. In this work these conditions are specified. As humanity moves away from Holocene conditions, we argue that resilience features arising from metastable states might be crucial for the ES to follow sustainable trajectories in the Anthropocene that prevent it run into a much hotter potential equilibrium state. I Introduction Over the past decades the human imprint on the Earth System (ES) has been exceptional ( 41 ; 24 ) . While the mass of humans is only about 0.01\% of the total biomass, we have become a dominant force in shaping the face of Earth, including its atmosphere, biosphere, hydrosphere and lithosphere ( 44 ; 15 ; 17 ; 18 ; 31 ) , and as of 2020 the global human-made mass surpasses the dry-weight of all living biomass ( 16 ) . Thus, humans have become a hyper-keystone species ( 45 ) , which rivals geological forces in influencing the trajectory of the ES ( 40 ) A major concern of these changes is the risk of crossing of so-called tipping-points, which refer to the critical threshold at which a small change or event triggers a significant and potentially irreversible (regime) shift in a system ( 27 ) . Tipping-points have been observed in various systems, such as ecosystems (e.g. food webs, benthic communities), social systems (e.g. norms, policy), economic systems (e.g. market-based economy) and technological systems (e.g. steam engine, smartphone, artificial intelligence) ( 35 ; 37 ; 30 ) . Over the past couple of decades there have been raising concerns around the existence of tipping-elements, which are large-scale components (subsystems) of the ES that may transgress a tipping-point ( 27 ; 2 ) . Example of such tipping-elements include, the Greenland Ice Sheet, the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), permafrost, monsoon systems, and the Amazon rainforest. Importantly, these tipping-elements interact, which may lead to a cascading behaviour of the entire ES ( 46 ) . The consequences of these dynamics for humanity could be colossal ( 40 ) . Clearly, knowledge about tipping-points, where they are located, when they are approached and identifying ways to navigate away from them, are key challenges for humanity ( 2 ; 36 ) . Two broad frameworks that could help assist in this regard are planetary boundaries and resilience theory. The two are complementary in the sense that the planetary boundaries provide a quantitative assessment whereas the resilience framework adds a strong theoretical underpinning. The planetary boundaries (PB) framework ( 33 ; 39 ; 32 ) has been used to define global and regional limits in biophysical processes – ‘safe operating space’ – that must not be crossed if humanity is to stay away from systemic and potentially irreversible shifts in the ES. As such, the planetary boundaries framework serves as a ”global dashboard,” tracking humanity’s collective impact on key environmental factors that threaten the Earth’s ability to sustain human life. More recently, focus has been directed towards exploration of how different boundaries can interact and potentially cascade, thereby shrinking the safe operating space for future human impacts on the ES ( 26 ) . Importantly, while the PB framework highlights the presence of tipping points in biophysical processes, it does not specify their exact thresholds. Instead, it delineates two risk zones: a zone of increasing risk and a high-risk zone. In the former, the further boundary limits are exceeded, the greater the likelihood of causing significant harm—destabilizing critical Earth system processes and disrupting essential life-support functions. In the latter, or high-risk zone, there is a substantial risk of severe and potentially irreversible damage to key planetary functions. In essence, these zones are defined at a precautionary distance from the estimated locations of potential tipping points. The resilience concept describes the extent to which a system can resist and develop (e.g. ecosystems or the the entire ES) with change by absorbing recurrent perturbations, deal with uncertainty and risk, and still sustain its key properties ( 22 ; 21 ) . This conception of resilience is based on the understanding that humans and Nature are deeply interconnected through feedbacks between social and ecological components, which together influence overall behavior and dynamics ( 14 ) . This interdependence defines a social-ecological system ( 3 ) in which human well-being and prosperity rely on the stability and functioning of the Earth system ( 20 ) . Multiple states (regimes), tipping-points and self-reinforcing feedback mechanisms (hysteresis) are a central feature of resilience ( 22 ) . In cases where resilience is high, a powerful shock – such as, storms, large wildfires, pest outbreaks in ecosystems, or armed conflicts, trade wars, and supply chain disruptions in social systems – is required to push the system beyond a tipping-point and into another state. However, gradual (creeping) change – such as, loss biodiversity, habitat fragmentation and pesticide resistance in ecosystems, or growing inequality and changing social norms in society – erodes resilience of the current state. This makes the system vulnerable even to smaller perturbations. Once the system finds itself in this new state it can be difficult, or even impossible to reverse due to self-reinforcing feedback mechanisms ( 35 ; 37 ; 31 ) . Within the context of PB variables, species extinction (i.e. biodiversity loss PB) represents an irreversible process. Resilience has also been suggested as a conceptual framework that could assist in developing paths towards sustainability ( 19 ) . Hence, it can serve as a theoretical and practical foundation for the planetary boundaries framework. An important point to bear in mind, however is that resilience is a property of a system and is neither ”good” nor ”bad” per se. It can help maintain the current state of a system no matter

Read the complete text