Conformity Dynamics in LLM Multi-Agent Systems: The Roles of Topology and Self–Social Weighting

Chen Han, Jin Tan, Bohan Yu, Wenzhen Zheng, Xijin Tang · 2026

Read Conformity Dynamics in LLM Multi-Agent Systems: The Roles of Topology and Self–Social Weighting by Chen Han, Jin Tan, Bohan Yu, Wenzhen Zheng, Xijin Tang (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-05606.txt.

Introduction

Chen Han and 4 co-authors study, in a 2026 paper, how network shape drives conformity among language model agents. When agents interact, shared decisions emerge through social influence, and agents often align with the majority view. The team examined that tendency through a misinformation detection task.

A confidence-normalized pooling rule let them tune the balance between self-reliance and social influence. They compared centralized aggregation with distributed consensus across network topologies. Centralized systems decided instantly but depended heavily on hub quality and showed same-model bias. Distributed systems reached more robust consensus, while denser networks converged faster yet risked confident shared errors. The results map how topology and self-social weighting shape shared judgment.

Catalog record

CREATORChen Han, Jin Tan, Bohan Yu, Wenzhen Zheng, Xijin Tang
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-05606

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Conformity Dynamics in LLM Multi-Agent Systems: The Roles of Topology and Self–Social Weighting Chen Han, Jin Tan, Bohan Yu, Wenzhen Zheng, Xijin Tang Abstract Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly instantiated as interacting agents in multi-agent systems (MAS), where collective decisions emerge through social interaction rather than independent reasoning. A fundamental yet underexplored mechanism in this process is conformity, the tendency of agents to align their judgments with prevailing group opinions. This paper presents a systematic study of how network topology shapes conformity dynamics in LLM-based MAS through a misinformation detection task. We introduce a confidence-normalized pooling rule that controls the trade-off between self-reliance and social influence, enabling comparisons between two canonical decision paradigms: Centralized Aggregation and Distributed Consensus. Experimental results demonstrate that network topology critically governs both the efficiency and robustness of collective judgments. Centralized structures enable immediate decisions but are sensitive to hub competence and exhibit same-model alignment biases. In contrast, distributed structures promote more robust consensus, while increased network connectivity speeds up convergence but also heightens the risk of wrong-but-sure cascades, in which agents converge on incorrect decisions with high confidence. These findings characterize the conformity dynamics in LLM-based MAS, clarifying how network topology and self–social weighting jointly shape the efficiency, robustness, and failure modes of collective decision-making. The code will be publicly released upon acceptance. Figure 1: Illustration of centralized (hub-based) and distributed (collective) multi-agent structures, highlighting their decision-making mechanisms, relative advantages, and inherent limitations in collective inference. 1 Introduction Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly instantiated as interacting agents within Multi-Agent Systems (MAS) ( 31 ) . Across a wide range of applications, including collaborative problem solving ( 17 ) , complex reasoning ( 33 ) and misinformation detection ( 25 ) , the effectiveness of collective decision-making depends not only on the competence of individual agents, but also on the social dynamics induced by their interactions ( 18 ; 13 ) . A central mechanism underlying these dynamics is conformity, the tendency of agents to adjust their judgments toward majority opinions. Prior studies suggest that conformity can reduce idiosyncratic noise and facilitate coordination ( 12 ) . However, excessive conformity may also cause information cascades, leading groups to converge on incorrect conclusions with high confidence ( 8 ; 28 ) . Existing research on MAS has primarily emphasized task efficacy, focusing on protocol design, role specialization, and coordination efficiency ( 1 ; 19 ) . For example, multi-agent debate frameworks can shift individual judgments toward majority positions, improving reliability while reinforcing systematic biases ( 21 ) . Related work on persuasion further suggests that LLM agents tend to imitate dominant argumentative patterns during the interaction ( 6 ) . While conformity has been studied in computational opinion dynamics ( 22 ; 15 ; 20 ) , existing approaches still lack an explicit treatment of how agents generate judgments during decision processes, and in particular how interaction topology and neighbor effect jointly govern the propagation, aggregation, and amplification of agent confidence. In this study, we bridge this gap by investigating how network topology modulates conformity through a binary misinformation detection task. We propose a confidence-normalized update rule governed by a global self-weighting parameter \alpha , which balances an agent’s self-reliance against their neighborhood influence. Specifically, we compare two distinct decision modes: (i) Centralized Aggregation (e.g., star networks), where a hub synthesizes a collective decision in a single round; and (ii) Distributed Consensus (e.g., sparse rings to complete graph), where influence propagates iteratively. This allows us to disentangle one-step hub dominance from multi-round interaction. Our contributions are summarized as follows: (1) Topology as a determinant of conformity. We show that network structure systematically shapes conformity by trading off convergence speed and robustness. Centralized structures concentrate influence, yielding immediate decisions but making outcomes highly dependent on hub competence and model homogeneity; Distributed structures diffuse influence and support more robust consensus formation, while increased connectivity accelerates convergence and may facilitate high-confidence error cascades. (2) A transparent confidence-normalized pooling rule. We propose a transparent and generalizable update mechanism that introduces a global parameter to explicitly regulate social influence. By integrating agent-level confidence into the pooling process, the rule yields bounded belief scores, stable binarization, and well-controlled conformity dynamics, providing a principled basis for different decision paradigms. (3) Empirical insights on robustness and risk. Experiments on current fact-checking datasets reveal that system reliability is heavily contingent on hub competence and majority composition. We further characterize the dual nature of conformity, showing that it enhances accuracy under reliable conditions but can induce confident errors when early majority signals are incorrect. 2 Related Works 2.1 MAS and Collective Decision-Making Early research on MAS primarily focused on distributed optimization and consensus formation under idealized assumptions, where agents were modeled as homogeneous entities with limited reasoning capacity ( 7 ; 3 ) . The recent integration of LLMs expands this paradigm by endowing agents with advanced reasoning, enabling MAS to address complex, unstructured decision-making problems such as multi-step problem solving ( 10 ) and automated fact-checking ( 21 ) . Despite these advances, most existing studies emphasize aggregate performance metrics, leaving the role of social dynamics such as conformity in shaping collective reliability largely unexamined. 2.2 Conformity and Opinion Dynamics Conformity, defined as the tendency of individuals to align their judgments with a perceived majority, has been widely studied in social psychology ( 9 ) . In computational settings, opinion dynamics models such as DeGroot averaging ( 16 ) and bounded-confidence mechanisms ( 24 ) formalize how local interactions give rise to collective consensus and have been used to explain phenomena including information cascades and polarization ( 29 ) . However, these models operate at an abstract level and do not capture the semantic reasoning or contextual understanding characteristic of modern LLM agents ( 5 ) . Consequently, how classical conformity theories extend to LLM-based MAS, where judgments are produced through generative processes, remains insufficiently explored. 2.3 Network Topology Network topology is a fundamental determinant of how influence propagates and consensus forms in multi-agent systems ( 11 ; 3 ) . Centralized aggregation structures, such as star or hierarchical graphs, concentrate influence and enable rapid decision-making, but render collective outcomes highly sensitive to the reliability of central agents. By contrast, Distributed consensus structures, including ring and complete graphs, diffuse influence across agents, enhancing robustness to local noise at the expense of slower convergence. Latest studies have further examined how connectivity modulates communication cost, convergence speed, and robustness ( 14 ; 30 ; 32 ) . Despite these efforts, existing work has yet to clarify the interplay between interaction topology, agent confidence, and conformity in shaping collective outcomes in LLM-driven MAS. 3 Methodology 3.1 Agent Decision Model Building on classical opinion dynamics and weighted consensus frameworks ( 4 ; 24 ; 16 ) , we formalize misinformation detection in MAS as a binary collective decision problem. At each interaction round t , agent i produces a binary judgment y_{i}^{(t)}\in{0,1} (with 0 denoting True and 1 denoting False), accompanied by a confidence score p_{i}^{(t)} that quantifies the agent’s self-assessed reliability. Update rule. Agents update an internal support score using confidence-normalized pooling: s_{i}^{(t+1)}=\frac{\alpha\,p_{i}^{(t)}y_{i}^{(t)}+(1-\alpha)\sum_{j\in N_{i}}p_{j}^{(t)}y_{j}^{(t)}}{\alpha\,p_{i}^{(t)}+(1-\alpha)\sum_{j\in N_{i}}p_{j}^{(t)}+\varepsilon}, (1) where N_{i} denotes the neighbor set of agent i ,

Read the complete text