Three-equation turbulent convection models in classical variables
Gábor B. Kovács, Róbert Szabó, János Nuspl · 2026
Read Three-equation turbulent convection models in classical variables by Gábor B. Kovács, Róbert Szabó, János Nuspl (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-04931.txt.
Introduction
Gábor B. Kovács, Róbert Szabó, and János Nuspl work on cheap one-line models of churning heat inside stars that pulse in a 2026 paper. Such models track the star's beat with one added rule for the heat in churn. Yet they fail to say why a star picks the beat modes it shows. Full models in more than one line cost far too much to run as a rule.
The trio build a three-rule model in the classic terms of the field. Their extra rules are non-local: each layer of the star feels what far layers do, not just its near kin. They aim for results close to the full models, at least in a range of star types that labs use. A cheap model that gets the beat right would sharpen what pulse data tell us about the cores of stars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gábor B. Kovács, Róbert Szabó, János Nuspl |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-04931
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Three-equation turbulent convection models in classical variables Gábor B. Kovács, Róbert Szabó, János Nuspl Abstract Context. Turbulent convection models in nonlinear radial stellar pulsation models rely on an extra equation for turbulent kinetic energy and fail to adequately explain mode-selection problems. Since multidimensional calculations are computationally expensive, it is reasonable to search for generalizations of physically grounded 1D models that approximate multidimensional results with sufficient accuracy, at least in a given parameter range. A natural way of progressing from one-equation models is to use additional nonlocal equations. While these types of models also exist in the literature, they have not been adopted for this type of object. Aims. We aim to adapt the three-equation turbulent convection model from Kuhfuss to radial stellar pulsation modeling. Methods. We use a Reynolds-stress one-point closure approach to derive our extensions alongside the model, while using additional models from the literature to close the anisotropy and dissipation terms. Results. We provide five extensions to the original model. These include an enhanced dissipation correction to the mixing length, a local anisotropy model replacing eddy viscosity, a second-order correction for turbulent ion transport in the atmosphere (alongside opacity effects), and turbulent damping of entropy fluctuations and convective flux. 1 Introduction Modeling turbulent convection inside stellar cores and envelopes is one of the most important problems in astrophysics. While most studies have focused on phenomenological improvements to the mixing-length theory of 5 ( 38 ) , in the case of radial stellar pulsations, time-dependent convection models were necessary ( 28 ) to describe the significant effects of the narrow convective zones in the envelope of these stars. In these objects, envelope convection is confined to partial ionization zones, which also drive radial pulsations via the \kappa - \gamma mechanism. Despite the envelope being mostly radiative, these zones provide major damping for the pulsations. The most straightforward way of modeling stellar convection is to use 3D numerical hydrocodes. 20 ; 21 developed the multidimensional stellar pulsation code SPHERLS, which was the first to successfully model RR Lyrae stars at maximum amplitudes in 2D ( 21 ; 22 ) and 3D ( 23 ) , although this was achieved using relatively simple numerical methods 1 1 1 For a recent overview and calibration of SPHERLS, see 34 . 41 extended the ANTARES ( 43 ) code to model radial stellar pulsations; they compared the 2D structure to 1D treatments for a Cepheid model ( 42 ) . 56 ; 57 used the COBOLD5 software to model a 2D Cepheid variable and then used it as input for spectral synthesis models. Recently, 51 performed a 2D model analysis of the convective region in Cepheid models using the MUSIC code, while 34 performed a similar study of RR Lyrae stars using the SPHERLS code. However, both studies investigated these stars in the static limit. All of the aforementioned studies either focus on a special case or calculate only a few stellar models due to the extreme computational cost of these simulations. Multidimensional simulations of these stars remain challenging, because adaptive grids are required to keep the partial ionization regions (which drive the pulsation) resolved as the star undergoes rapid expansion and contraction. Meanwhile, to reach maximum amplitudes, one must simulate several (thousands) pulsation cycles. This makes improving 1D convection theories an important task ( 38 ; 32 ) , as these models can be used in large model surveys ( 48 , e.g.,) and also serve as inputs for multidimensional simulations. Traditionally, asteroseismology has been studied primarily using linear approximations ( 1 ) , which have also provided important information on radial pulsators ( 13 ) . While linear theory can provide accurate pulsation frequencies, pulsation amplitudes enter the equations only as a normalization factor. Linear pulsation analysis can be performed in the adiabatic approximation, in which case the theory provides only frequencies. Linear nonadiabatic calculations also provide information about the growth rates of pulsation modes (i.e., whether a mode is pulsationally unstable) and result in somewhat different frequencies. Meanwhile, one can only approximately describe coupling between modes through amplitude equations. Nonlinear calculations, on the other hand, include every amplitude-dependent effect present in the system (and more accurate coupling with convection). This modifies the linear frequencies and provides additional results comparable to observations, such as light curves, amplitudes, and the actual nonlinearly selected pulsational modes. This is particularly important, because we often observe monomode pulsators where multiple modes are linearly excited. Therefore, mode selection studies investigate the nonlinear behavior of pulsation modes to determine which pulsation mode is excited, which survives if multiple modes are present, or whether they can coexist in double-mode pulsation. This, along with other nonlinear phenomena, has been central to radial pulsation modeling over the past two decades (see, e.g., 30 ; 53 ; 48 ). Nevertheless, both linear and nonlinear studies have shown that including turbulent convection is crucial for describing radial stellar pulsations ( 3 ) . Building on the pioneering work of 25 , 54 , and 12 , the nonlocal models 2 2 2 These are the so-called one-equation models, which use a single additional nonlocal equation describing the specific turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) in the stellar envelope. of 49 , 35 , and 19 are used in current state-of-the-art nonlinear radial stellar pulsation hydrocodes developed in the 1990s and early 2000s ( 6 ; 30 ; 46 ; 44 ) . For a detailed summary, see 32 . Meanwhile, these models have their own limitations: they have many free parameters; nonlinear phenomena such as mode selection and double-mode pulsations are model-dependent ( 53 ; 47 ; 32 ; 33 ) ; light and radial velocity curves show discrepancies with observations ( 39 ; 32 ) and the models produce unphysical stratification in the stellar envelope ( 7 ; 37 ; 32 ) . Many of these problems stem from the so-called downgradient approximation of the convective flux and the resulting nonphysical stratification of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) ( 7 ; 37 ; 32 ). In the downgradient approximation, the convective flux is considered proportional to the super-adiabatic gradient. There is a further assumption that in stable regions (i.e., where the gradient is negative), the gradient is taken as zero ( 49 ) . This approximation also affects the TKE profile, which in turn influences mode selection through the turbulent pressure and viscous stress terms. This effect determined whether simulations reproduce or fail to exhibit double-mode pulsation ( 46 ; 47 ; 32 ) . Neglecting negative convective flux leads to insufficient turbulent damping, causing overshooting into the deep stellar interiors. This provides additional damping that can stabilize double-mode pulsations ( 47 ; 32 ) . Meanwhile, maintaining a negative flux prevents TKE leakage to deeper regions but leads to unstable double-mode pulsations, where one mode is eventually damped despite a “physically more correct” picture. This occurs because negative flux terms cause strong turbulent damping in the overshooting region, where convective elements behave as if colliding with a rigid wall ( 37 ; 32 ) . Both pictures are nonphysical, illustrating the limitations of one-equation models. While the aforementioned problems depend primarily on the coupling between convection and radial pulsation, other observed features –