NLO QCD sum rules analysis of 1 − ⁣ + 1^{-+} tetraquark states

Wei-Yang Lai, Hong-Ying Jin · 2026

Read NLO QCD sum rules analysis of 1 − ⁣ + 1^{-+} tetraquark states by Wei-Yang Lai, Hong-Ying Jin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-04927.txt.

Introduction

Wei-Yang Lai and Hong-Ying Jin calculate the masses of exotic tetraquark states in a 2026 particle physics paper. Tetraquarks bind four quarks rather than the usual two or three, and states with quantum numbers 1-+ cannot be ordinary mesons at all. The authors apply QCD sum rules at next-to-leading order, a method that connects quark-level theory to observed particle masses through carefully chosen correlation functions.

Testing compact tetraquark and molecular configurations, they exclude one candidate particle as a tetraquark and suggest it may not exist, matching recent experiments. Several predicted states near a higher mass match another candidate well. Such calculations tell experimentalists which claimed exotic particles deserve belief and where new ones should appear.

Catalog record

CREATORWei-Yang Lai, Hong-Ying Jin
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-04927

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

NLO QCD sum rules analysis of 1 − ⁣ + 1^{-+} tetraquark states Wei-Yang Lai, Hong-Ying Jin Abstract We present a next-to-leading order QCD sum rule analysis of J P ​ C = 1 − ⁣ + J^{PC}=1^{-+} light tetraquark states. By investigating various compact tetraquark and molecular configurations, we determine the mass spectrum of these states. Our calculations exclude the possibility that π 1 ​ ( 1400 ) \pi_{1}(1400) is a tetraquark or hybrid-tetraquark mixture. This suggests that it may not exist, which is consistent with recent experimental results. In contrast, we obtained multiple 1 − ⁣ + 1^{-+} states around 2.0 ​ GeV 2.0\,\text{GeV} that match well with π 1 ​ ( 2015 ) \pi_{1}(2015) , which makes us confident that π 1 ​ ( 2015 ) \pi_{1}(2015) is a tetraquark candidate. As for π 1 ​ ( 1600 ) \pi_{1}(1600) , our results indicate that the tetraquark currents tend to couple to heavier states, reducing the possibility of it being a tetraquark, while earlier studies suggested the opposite. 1 Introduction The study of non- q\bar{q} mesons beyond the conventional quark model remains a central topic in hadron physics GELLMANN1964214 ; Albuquerque_2019 . QCD predicts the existence of mesons with various structures, such as hybrid states containing excited gluons li2025revisingmasslighthybrid ; PhysRevD.107.034010 , glueballs composed purely of gluons adsfwefcv , and multiquark states CPC:10.1088/1674-1137/ac2a1d ; hv4x-dnmt ; CPC:10.1088/1674-1137/43/3/034104 ; PhysRevD.91.054034 ; Dong2020 ; CPC:10.1088/1674-1137/ac0b3b . Mesons with the exotic quantum numbers J^{PC}=1^{-+} have attracted much attention and are typically regarded as candidates for hybrids, tetraquarks, or their mixtures. In particular, the ambiguity surrounding the isovector state \pi_{1}(1400) has persisted for a long time. \pi_{1}(1400) appeared in the \pi^{-}p\to\pi^{0}\eta n reaction ALDE1988397 , and it was later observed in the \pi^{-}p\to\eta\pi^{-}p channel PhysRevLett.79.1630 ; PhysRevD.60.092001 . However, some recent evidence suggests that \pi_{1}(1400) may be an artifact of the \pi_{1}(1600) particle and might not exist Kopf2021 . In fact, a single pole is sufficient to fit the experimental data for both \pi_{1}(1400) and \pi_{1}(1600) . In Ref. PhysRevD.71.011502 , \pi_{1}(1400) was interpreted as a molecular tetraquark, while Ref. NARISON2009319 suggested that a hybrid-tetraquark mixture might explain \pi_{1}(1400) , a conclusion also reached in later work PhysRevD.105.054030 . Studies on hybrids indicate that the mass of a 1^{-+} hybrid state is higher than 1.7\,\text{GeV} PhysRevD.52.5242 ; MEYER201521 ; Huang2015 , making it difficult to match the mass of \pi_{1}(1400) . Therefore, within the framework of QCD sum rules, the existence of \pi_{1}(1400) depends on whether there exists a tetraquark state with a mass close to or less than 1.4\,\text{GeV} . In Ref. PhysRevD.78.054017 , a series of compact tetraquark currents were calculated, and several isospin-1 1^{-+} compact tetraquark states with masses around 1.6 GeV and 2.0 GeV were obtained. However, all the studies mentioned above on tetraquark states were only calculated to Leading Order (LO) without considering next-to-leading order (NLO) contributions, which can sometimes be significant li2025revisingmasslighthybrid . In this work, we present the first NLO analysis of the 1^{-+} tetraquark states. Using the latest phenomenological parameters and a more precise running coupling, we reanalyze the possibility of the existence of \pi_{1}(1400) . 2 Tetraquark Currents and Renormalization In past studies, some currents involving only the lighter u , d , and s quarks and their antiquarks yielded lower ground-state masses in the spectral density when calculated at LO PhysRevD.78.054017 ; PhysRevD.71.011502 . Therefore, they are suitable subjects for this study, such that after adding NLO corrections, their masses might approach 1.4\,\text{GeV} . For compact tetraquark currents, constructed by quark pairs (qq) and antiquark pairs (\bar{q}\bar{q}) , considering charge conjugation symmetry and flavor structure, we have 4 compact tetraquark currents \eta_{1}^{\mu}\sim\eta_{4}^{\mu} : \begin{split}\eta_{1}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\gamma^{\mu}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{2}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}C\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{3}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\gamma^{\mu}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{4}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}C\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}),\\ \end{split} (1) where C is the charge conjugation operator, and \sigma^{\mu\nu}=\frac{i}{2}[\gamma^{\mu},\gamma^{\nu}] . If the d quark is replaced by an s quark, we obtain \begin{split}\eta_{5}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\gamma^{\mu}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}Cs_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{6}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}C\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}+\bar{u}_{b}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{7}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\gamma^{\mu}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}Cs_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a}),\\ \eta_{8}^{\mu}&=u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a})+u_{a}^{T}C\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}s_{b}(\bar{u}_{a}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{b}-\bar{u}_{b}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{s}^{T}_{a}).\end{split} (2) Furthermore, for molecular tetraquark states, we also consider the following two currents PhysRevD.71.011502 \displaystyle J_{1}^{\mu} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{2}\left(\bar{u}\gamma^{5}u-\bar{d}\gamma^{5}d\right)\left(\bar{u}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}u+\bar{d}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}d\right), (3) \displaystyle J_{2}^{\mu\nu} \displaystyle=\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\left(\bar{u}\gamma^{5}\gamma_{\rho}d\,\bar{d}\gamma_{\sigma}u-\bar{d}\gamma^{5}\gamma_{\rho}u\,\bar{u}\gamma_{\sigma}d\right), (4) where \epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} is the totally antisymmetric tensor, with the convention \epsilon^{0123}=+1 . When expanding the perturbative part of the correlation functions for these tetraquark currents to NLO, we need to calculate the Feynman diagrams as shown in Fig. 1 . Since tetraquark currents are composite operators, the calculation results will contain non-local divergence terms such as \log(-q^2/\mu^2)/\varepsilon. (5) These non-local divergences cannot be completely removed by conventional Lagrangian renormalization methods; the operator currents themselves must be renormalized. For operator currents \eta_{1}^{\mu} and \eta_{3}^{\mu} , using the tetraquark renormalization method in Ref. li2025qcdsumruleanalysis , with the Feynman gauge, we can obtain \displaystyle\left(u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}\right)_{r}= \displaystyle\left(Z_{2}^{-2}-\frac{2C_{A}^{2}+1}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon C_{A}}g^{2}\right)u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\frac{3}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}g^{2}u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a} \displaystyle-\frac{C_{A}ig^{2}}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b}+\frac{ig^{2}}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}, (6) \displaystyle\left(u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}\right)_{r}= \displaystyle\left(Z_{2}^{-2}-\frac{2C_{A}^{2}+1}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon C_{A}}g^{2}\right)u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}+\frac{3}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}g^{2}u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b} \displaystyle+\frac{C_{A}ig^{2}}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a}-\frac{ig^{2}}{32\pi^{2}\varepsilon}u_{a}^{T}C\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma^{5}d_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma_{\nu}\gamma^{5}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b} \displaystyle+\frac{1}{48\pi^{2}\varepsilon}\left(\bar{u}D^{\alpha}G_{\alpha\beta}\gamma^{\beta}\gamma^{\mu}\gamma^{5}u-\bar{d}D^{\alpha}G_{\alpha\beta}\gamma^{\beta}\gamma^{\mu}\gamma^{5}d\right), (7) In the above equations, Z_{2}=1-\frac{g^{2}C_{F}}{16\pi^{2}\epsilon}, (8) where C_{F}=4/3 is the quadratic Casimir operator of the fundamental representation of the SU(3) group, and C_{A}=3 is the quadratic Casimir operator of the adjoint representation of the SU(3) group; these parameters are also known as the quark and gluon color factors, respectively. For convenience, we suppress the generator matrix T of SU(3) and the coupling constant g , i.e., D^{\alpha}G_{\alpha\beta}\equiv gD^{\alpha}G^{n}_{\alpha\beta}T^{n}. (9) It can be seen that for the two different color index summation methods, u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{a}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{b} and u_{a}^{T}Cd_{b}\,\bar{u}_{b}\gamma^{\mu}C\bar{d}^{\,T}_{a} , the renormalization results differ by a hybrid-like current D^{\alpha}G_{\alpha\beta} , which only appears in operator currents where the summation is over different quark color indices. By replacing the d quark in Eqs.( 6 ) and ( 7 ) with an s quark, we obtain the operator renormalization results for tetraquark currents \eta_{5}^{\mu} and \eta_{7}^{\mu} . As for the molecular tetraquark currents, they can be obtained through linear combinations of the following renormalized operator currents: \displaystyle\left(\bar{u}\gamma^{5}u\,\bar{d}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}d\right)_{r}= \displaystyle\left(Z_{2}^{-2}+\frac{5C_{F}}{16\pi^{2}\varepsilon}g^{2}\right)\bar{u}\gamma^{5}u\,\bar{d}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}d+\frac{ig^{2}}{8\pi^{2}\varepsilon}\bar{u}T^{n}\sigma^{\mu\nu}u\,\bar{d}\gamma_{\nu}T^{n}d, (10) \displaystyle\left(\bar{u}\gamma^{5}u\,\bar{u}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}u\right)_{r}= \displaystyle\left(Z_{2}^{-2}+\frac{5C_{F}}{16\pi^{2}\varepsilon}g^{2}\right)\bar{u}\gamma^{5}u\,\bar{u}\gamma^{5}\gamma^{\mu}u+\frac{ig^{2}}{8\pi^{2}\varepsilon}\bar{u}T^{n}\sigma^{\mu\nu}u\,\bar{u}\gamma_{\nu}T^{n}u \displaystyle+\frac{i}{24\pi^{2}\varepsilon}\bar{u}D^{\alpha}G_{\alpha\beta}\sigma^{\beta\mu}u. (11) The renormalization of other operator currents is placed in Appendix A.2 . 3 QCD Sum Rules Figure 1 : Feynman diagrams for the perturbative term of tetraquark currents. Permutation diagrams are omitted. The bold cross vertex represents the hybrid-like counterterm. For compact tetraquark currents, the first four diagrams are unnecessary. QCD sum rules 2f559d0e1b0142098757851dd8a536ba ; cohen1995qcd ; NARISON202394 determine the corresponding hadronic spectral structure through the poles of operator current correlation functions in the complex plane. To calculate the correlation function, we first perform an Operator Product Expansion (OPE): \Pi(q)=i\int d^{4}xe^{iqx}\langle 0|T\{J^{\mu}(x)J^{\nu}(0)\}|0\rangle=C_{0}(q)+C_{4}(q)\langle O^{4}\rangle+C_{6}(q)\langle O^{6}\rangle+\cdots, (12) where C_{i}(q) are Wilson coefficients, and \langle O^{i}\rangle denote vacuum condensates(i.e., the vacuum expectation values of various local operators). The first Wilson coefficient C_{0}(q) corresponds to the perturbative diagrams in Fig. 1 , which accounts for the high-energy contribution. Subsequent coefficients like C_{4}(q) and C_{6}(q) can be calculated by cutting certain propagators in the perturbative diagrams or introducing zero-momentum gluons from the vacuum; they represent the contribution from the low-energy region. For this part of the contribution, it is suitable to calculate in coordinate space. We can use the techniques in Refs. PhysRevD.78.054017 ; Aliev_2024 ; SONG2019160 ; Di_2019 to handle these non-perturbative contributions. The quark propagator including vacuum condensates is \begin{split}iS^{ab}&\equiv\langle 0|T[q^{a}(x)\bar{q}^{b}(0)]|0\rangle\\ &={i\delta^{ab}\over 2\pi^{2}x^{4}}\not{x}-{ig\over 32\pi^{2}}G^{n}_{\mu\nu}T^{n\,ab}{1\over x^{2}}(\sigma^{\mu\nu}.\not{x}+\not{x}.\sigma^{\mu\nu})-{\delta^{ab}\over 12}\langle\bar{q}q\rangle\\ &\quad-{\delta^{ab}x^{2}\over 192}\langle g\bar{q}\sigma Gq\rangle-{m_{q}\delta^{ab}\over 4\pi^{2}x^{2}}+{i\delta^{ab}m_{q}\langle\bar{q}q\rangle\over 48}\not{x}+{i\delta^{ab}m_{q}^{2}\over 8\pi^{2}x^{2}}\not{x}\end{split} (13) The Lorentz structure of operator currents indicates that a general vector current can couple to both vector particles and scalar particles. Therefore, we need to isolate the part corresponding to the 1^{-+} vector particle in

Read the complete text