Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? 2026 Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? – 10
C. R. Angus, A. J. Smith, D. Magill, P. Ramsden, N. Sarin, M. Nicholl, B. Mockler, E. Hammerstein, R. Stein, Y. Yao, T. de Boer, K. C. Chambers, M. E. Huber, C. -C. Lin, T. B. Lowe, E. A. Magnier, S. J. Smartt, R. J. Wainscoat · 2026
Read Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? 2026 Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? – 10 by C. R. Angus, A. J. Smith, D. Magill, P. Ramsden, N. Sarin, M. Nicholl, B. Mockler, E. Hammerstein, R. Stein, Y. Yao, T. de Boer, K. C. Chambers, M. E. Huber, C. -C. Lin, T. B. Lowe, E. A. Magnier, S. J. Smartt, R. J. Wainscoat (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-04406.txt.
Introduction
C. R. Angus and seventeen co-authors ask whether the models used to weigh black holes from stellar deaths can be trusted, in a 2026 arXiv paper. When a star is torn apart by a supermassive black hole, the flare's light curve is routinely fitted to estimate the black hole's mass, an attractive route to counting quiet black holes. But most models assume total destruction, while theory says partial disruptions, where a core survives, should dominate.
Repeating partial disruptions give a natural test: the same surviving star flares again, and every flare must return the same mass. The team confirms a third such repeater spectroscopically and fits all three events with four model families. After systematics, the models agree with themselves and with host-galaxy estimates within a factor of a few, though fallback models drift toward unphysical stars. ultraviolet coverage proves crucial — a warning for coming survey floods.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. R. Angus, A. J. Smith, D. Magill, P. Ramsden, N. Sarin, M. Nicholl, B. Mockler, E. Hammerstein, R. Stein, Y. Yao, T. de Boer, K. C. Chambers, M. E. Huber, C. -C. Lin, T. B. Lowe, E. A. Magnier, S. J. Smartt, R. J. Wainscoat |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-04406
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? 2026 Can tidal disruption event models reliably measure black hole masses? – 10 C. R. Angus, A. J. Smith, D. Magill, P. Ramsden, N. Sarin, M. Nicholl, B. Mockler, E. Hammerstein, R. Stein, Y. Yao, T. de Boer, K. C. Chambers, M. E. Huber, C. -C. Lin, T. B. Lowe, E. A. Magnier, S. J. Smartt, R. J. Wainscoat Abstract Tidal disruption event (TDE) light curves are increasingly used to infer the masses of quiescent supermassive black holes ( M BH M_{\rm BH} ), offering a powerful probe of low-mass black hole demographics independent of host-galaxy scaling relations. However, the reliability of most semi-analytic TDE models assume full stellar disruption, despite theoretical expectations that partial disruptions dominate the TDE population. In this work we test the robustness of current TDE models using three repeating partial TDEs (rpTDEs), in which the multiple flares produced by the same surviving stellar core must yield consistent black hole masses. We present spectroscopic observations establishing AT 2023adr as a rpTDE, making it the third such spectroscopically confirmed event. We independently model the flares of the three rpTDEs; 2020vdq, 2022dbl, and 2023adr, applying fallback-accretion fits, stream–stream collision scaling relations, luminosity-based empirical relations, and cooling-envelope fits. After accounting for statistical and model-specific systematics, we find that all TDE models generally return self-consistent M BH M_{\rm BH} values between flares, and are broadly consistent with host-galaxy M BH M_{\rm BH} proxies, recovering M BH M_{\rm BH} to within 0.3–0.5 dex. However, the convergence of fallback models towards unphysical stellar masses and impact parameters reveals limitations in the existing fallback model grids. We also show that light curve coverage, particularly in the near-UV, is critical for constraining model parameters. This has direct implications for interpreting the thousands of TDE light curves expected from upcoming surveys such as the Rubin Observatory’s Legacy Survey of Space and Time, where from simulations, we find that M BH M_{\rm BH} may be underestimated on average by 0.5 dex without additional follow-up. 1 Introduction The growth and evolution of galaxies appears to be inextricably linked to the black holes that they host ( 88 ; 33 ) , such that every massive galaxy is believed to contain a black hole at its centre. Despite this, our knowledge of the black hole population is severely impeded by our ability to detect them. With only a small fraction ( 65 ; 2 , \sim 10%;) of galaxies in the local Universe hosting an Active Galactic Nucleus (AGN), the rest remain dormant and unseen. Tidal Disruption Events (TDEs), transients produced when an unfortunate star scattered within the tidal radius of a black hole ( 55 ) , can fleetingly illuminate hidden black holes. When this occurs, the black hole’s gravitational force produces a strong gradient across the star, overwhelming its self gravity and producing streams of bound and unbound debris, resulting in a luminous flare. TDEs are thus encoded with information about the disrupting black hole, which if deciphered correctly, presents an opportunity to probe the black hole population in an unbiased, galaxy-independent way. TDEs emit across the electromagnetic spectrum, with detections spanning from the X-ray ( 67 ; 9 ) to the radio at late times ( 21 ; 30 ) . However, the bulk of TDE identification takes place at optical wavelengths, with wide-field time-domain surveys such as the Zwicky Transient Facility ( 45 ; 12 , ZTF; ) enabling the systematic detection of new events, with over 100 TDEs discovered to date ( 146 ; 42 ; 53 ; 154 ) , and multiple spectroscopic subgroups ( 22 ; 53 ) . From the optical light curve, we can potentially measure the mass, M_{\rm BH} ( 97 ; 122 , e.g. ) and spin of the disrupting black hole ( 75 ; 102 , e.g. ) . However, the powering mechanisms behind the observed optical light curve are unclear. In canonical TDE models, energy is liberated from the stellar debris as it forms a compact accretion disk around the black hole, whose luminosity follows the fallback rate of material ( \propto\,t^{-5/3} ; 116 ; 110 ). This model requires efficient circularization and kinetic energy loss from the debris for the disk to form promptly ( 116 ; 26 ; 14 ) . Alternatively, shocks between collisions of self-intersecting streams of debris may release energy and generate the observed TDE luminosities ( 111 ; 62 ) , possibly in combination with fallback accretion at later times ( 139 ) . This picture is complicated further by the apparent presence of an optically thick reprocessing atmosphere ( 83 ; 49 ; 119 ; 27 ) , required to explain the large photospheric radii inferred from TDE spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and the weaker than expected soft X-rays from optically selected TDEs, both of which are inconsistent with hot accretion discs ( 7 ; 60 ; 22 , e.g.) . This reprocessing layer may be the result of outflows – launched either promptly following accretion ( 5 ; 144 ) or from material ejected by stream-stream collisions ( 85 ; 44 ) – or take the form of a pressure-supported envelope formed due to weakly bound stellar debris ( 95 ) . Currently these different theories remain in an observational deadlock. Though some TDEs have the L\propto\,t^{-5/3} power-law light curve declines predicted by fallback models ( 116 ; 41 ; 18 ) , there is significant variation in the post-peak evolution of the population, with many showing shallower, or even exponential declines ( 146 ; 42 ; 53 ; 23 ) , and some exhibiting rebrightenings at late times from the X-ray ( 40 ; 148 , e.g.) to the radio ( 91 ; 21 , e.g.) . The absorption and re-emission of high-energy radiation produced by fallback accretion by an envelope at \sim 10^{14} cm ( 49 ) produces similar blackbody emission to colliding debris at the same radius ( 111 ) . And whilst compelling evidence for outflows has been observed in some TDEs ( 5 ; 104 ; 44 , e.g.) , in other events the implied outflow mass would exceed that of a typical star ( 143 ) . Thus whilst there are now several publicly available semi-analytical models to constrain the physical parameters of TDEs from their optical light curves ( 97 ; 69 ; 124 ) or from the scaling of these key parameters with the luminosity ( 122 ; 102 ) , it is unclear which of these models offers the most reliable way of probing the black hole properties. Recent work from 99 has challenged the key underlying assumptions of many TDE parameter inference frameworks. Comparing the observed scaling of radiated energy and peak luminosity with M_{\rm BH} against predictions from emission models, they find that models in which the optical/UV light curve closely follows the fallback rate are strongly disfavoured, while reprocessing-based or disk-formation models provide a better, though still incomplete, description of the observed emission. Further to this, 51 have shown that simultaneously fitting the late-time exposed accretion-disk SEDs with multi-band light curves yields black hole mass estimates more closely aligned with established host-galaxy scaling relations. Many