Actively Obtaining Environmental Feedback for Autonomous Action Evaluation Without Predefined Measurements
Hong Su · 2026
Read Actively Obtaining Environmental Feedback for Autonomous Action Evaluation Without Predefined Measurements by Hong Su (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-04235.txt.
Introduction
Hong Su, writing alone, proposes that AI agents should hunt for their own feedback instead of waiting for fixed measures. Judging whether an action worked usually relies on predefined scores or rewards. In open, changing settings, new actions may need kinds of feedback that nobody specified in advance.
Su's actively feedback getting model has the agent probe the environment, then screen and verify what comes back. The key clue is that actions always change the environment in measurable ways, so target feedback can be found from those differences even when it was never defined. A self-triggering drive, aimed at better accuracy, precision, and efficiency, plans and adjusts the probing without outside commands. Experiments show the active approach finds factors faster and more robustly than passive routes, Su reports.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hong Su |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-04235
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Actively Obtaining Environmental Feedback for Autonomous Action Evaluation Without Predefined Measurements Hong Su Abstract Obtaining reliable feedback from the environment is a fundamental capability for intelligent agents to evaluate the correctness of their actions and to accumulate reusable knowledge. However, most existing approaches rely on predefined measurements or fixed reward signals, which limits their applicability in open-ended and dynamic environments where new actions may require previously unknown forms of feedback. To address these limitations, this paper proposes an Actively Feedback Getting model, in which an AI agent proactively interacts with the environment to discover, screen, and verify feedback without relying on predefined measurements. Rather than assuming explicit feedback definitions, the proposed method exploits action-induced environmental differences to identify target feedback that is not specified in advance, based on the observation that actions inevitably produce measurable changes in the environment. In addition, a self-triggering mechanism, driven by internal objectives such as improved accuracy, precision, and efficiency, is introduced to autonomously plan and adjust actions, thereby enabling faster and more focused feedback acquisition without external commands. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed active approach significantly improves the efficiency and robustness of factor identification. I Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have been widely adopted as core components of AI agents operating in real-world environments [ 1 ] [ 2 ] . By providing strong reasoning, planning, and language understanding capabilities, LLMs enable agents to interpret complex situations and generate sophisticated action plans. As a result, LLM-powered agents are increasingly deployed in interactive systems, autonomous control, and decision-support applications. Despite these advances, most existing AI agents in real-world settings still rely heavily on predefined measurements or actions , explicit reward functions, or externally specified feedback signals to evaluate the outcomes of their actions. Such designs impose strong assumptions on how feedback should be represented and interpreted, which significantly limits agent autonomy in open-ended and dynamic environments. When new actions are introduced or when relevant feedback does not conform to predefined forms, agents often lack effective mechanisms to discover, interpret, and verify feedback. In contrast, human behavior in natural environments does not depend on predefined measurement schemas. Humans actively interact with the environment, observe differences caused by their actions, and deliberately perform additional actions to identify, amplify, or accelerate feedback. Rather than passively waiting for results, humans intervene in the feedback generation process, adjusting actions and observation scopes to obtain clearer and more reliable feedback. This ability to actively obtain feedback is a key factor underlying human adaptability and learning. Inspired by this observation, we argue that AI agents should not rely solely on passive LLM-driven reasoning or externally defined feedback channels. Instead, agents should be equipped with mechanisms to actively discover feedback from the environment, even when no explicit measurement is provided in advance. In particular, action-induced environmental differences provide a universal signal through which feedback can be detected, screened, and validated. Moreover, agents should be able to plan and execute actions that intentionally expose or accelerate feedback, guided by internal objectives (as in Section III-F3 ) rather than external commands. In this paper, we propose an Actively Feedback Getting model that enables AI agents to autonomously obtain, validate, and accumulate feedback from the environment without relying on predefined measurements. The proposed model treats difference as the fundamental carrier of feedback, integrates active action as a form of feedback intervention, and employs internal action trigger sources to drive exploration and refinement. By combining difference-driven detection, active screening and validation, and accumulated learning of action–feedback relationships, the model supports efficient and adaptive feedback acquisition in open-ended environments. The main contributions of this paper are summarized as follows: • We propose a difference-driven feedback model that enables implicit feedback discovery without assuming predefined measurements. • We introduce active action as a feedback intervention mechanism, allowing agents to accelerate and disambiguate feedback acquisition through deliberate environmental manipulation. • We design an accumulated learning mechanism that records and reuses action–feedback relationships, supporting continual adaptation and efficiency improvement. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II reviews related work on feedback modeling, active perception, and autonomous agents. Section III presents the proposed Actively Feedback Getting model in detail. Section IV provides experimental verification and analysis. Finally, Section V concludes the paper and discusses future research directions. II Related Works This section reviews prior work related to feedback modeling, active perception, causal reasoning, and autonomous agents. We highlight the limitations of existing approaches in open-ended environments and clarify how the proposed model differs from and extends previous studies. II-A Predefined Feedback and Reward Modeling Most existing intelligent systems rely on predefined feedback representations, such as explicit reward functions, handcrafted metrics, or task-specific evaluation signals. Reinforcement learning (RL) frameworks typically assume that a scalar reward is available after each action or episode, enabling policy optimization through repeated interaction [ 3 ] [ 4 ] . Similarly, many decision-making and control systems depend on predefined measurements to assess action outcomes. While effective in closed or well-defined environments, such approaches face challenges in open-ended real-world scenarios. Designing appropriate reward functions or measurement criteria requires strong prior knowledge and often fails to generalize when new actions, goals, or environmental dynamics emerge. The proposed model differs by removing the assumption of predefined measurements and treating feedback as an implicit signal discovered through interaction. II-B Active Perception and Active Learning Active perception emphasizes that an agent can improve its understanding of the environment by actively selecting actions that influence observations [ 5 ] . Similarly, active learning focuses on querying informative data points to reduce uncertainty in supervised or semi-supervised settings. These approaches demonstrate that action selection can significantly affect information acquisition. However, most active perception and learning methods still assume predefined observation features, labels, or uncertainty measures. In contrast, our model extends the notion of activeness to the feedback level, enabling agents to actively intervene in the environment to discover and validate feedback itself, even when its form is unknown in advance. II-C Causal Discovery and Difference-Based Reasoning Causal discovery methods aim to identify cause–effect relationships from observational or interventional data [ 6 ] [ 7 ] . Difference-based reasoning, including counterfactual analysis, has been used to isolate influential factors by comparing alternative conditions or outcomes. Although these methods provide valuable theoretical tools, they often assume access to explicit variables, structured datasets, or well-defined interventions. Moreover, many causal approaches focus on offline analysis rather than online interaction. The proposed model adopts the intuition of difference-based reasoning but integrates it into an online, action-driven feedback acquisition process without requiring explicit causal variable definitions. II-D Autonomous Agents and Intrinsic Motivation Recent studies on autonomous agents emphasize intrinsic motivation, self-goal-driven behavior, and internal action triggers [ 8 ] . Such mechanisms allow agents to explore environments beyond externally specified objectives and improve long-term adaptability. Large language models have further enhanced agent autonomy by enabling high-level reasoning, planning, and instruction following. However, LLM-driven agents often remain passive with respect to feedback acquisition, relying on externally provided observations or predefined evaluation criteria. Our work complements these efforts by introducing internal action trigger sources specifically designed for feedback discovery and validation, enabling agents to actively shape the conditions under which feedback emerges. II-E Summary In summary, prior work