Topology or Demography? Understanding Sources of Bias in Opinion Dynamics Models

Stanisław Stępień, Michalina Janik, Mateusz Nurek, Akrati Saxena, Radosław Michalski · 2026

Read Topology or Demography? Understanding Sources of Bias in Opinion Dynamics Models by Stanisław Stępień, Michalina Janik, Mateusz Nurek, Akrati Saxena, Radosław Michalski (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-03859.txt.

Introduction

Stanisław Stępień and four co-authors study fairness in opinion dynamics, the models that simulate how people's views shift through social influence. Opinions form under many pressures: upbringing, education, wealth, beliefs, and minority status, all filtered through changing social networks. Models of such systems tend to serve the majority best and discriminate against marginalized groups, a problem the field of fairness in social network analysis is growing to address.

The authors examine how a state-of-the-art opinion model discriminates against certain minority groups. They also ask whether it is possible to predict reliably for whom the model will perform worse. Tools that forecast social influence feed into marketing, moderation, and policy, so knowing in advance which communities a model underserves is a first step toward fixing the imbalance.

Catalog record

CREATORStanisław Stępień, Michalina Janik, Mateusz Nurek, Akrati Saxena, Radosław Michalski
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-03859

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Topology or Demography? Understanding Sources of Bias in Opinion Dynamics Models Stanisław Stępień, Michalina Janik, Mateusz Nurek, Akrati Saxena, Radosław Michalski Abstract Ways in which people’s opinions change are, without a doubt, subject to a rich tapestry of differing influences. Factors that affect how one arrives at an opinion reflect how they have been shaped by their environment throughout their lives, education, material status, what belief systems they subscribe to, and what socio-economic minorities they are a part of. This already complex system is further expanded by the ever-changing nature of one’s social network. It is therefore no surprise that many models have a tendency to perform best for the majority of the population and discriminate against those people who are members of various marginalized groups. This bias and the study of how to counter it are subject to a rapidly developing field of Fairness in Social Network Analysis (SNA). The focus of this work is to look into how a state-of-the-art model discriminates certain minority groups and whether it is possible to reliably predict for whom it will perform worse. Moreover, is such a prediction possible based solely on one’s demographic or topological features? To this end, the NetSense dataset, together with a state-of-the-art CoDiNG model for opinion prediction, has been employed. Our work explores how three classifier models (Demography-Based, Topology-Based, and Hybrid) perform when assessing for whom this algorithm will provide inaccurate predictions. Finally, through a comprehensive analysis of these experimental results, we identify four key patterns of algorithmic bias: 1. variability in predictive effectiveness across issue types and minority groups, 2. extreme predictive variability for behaviourally-defined minorities, 3. potent but variable predictive signals from socio-economic and religious minorities, 4. persistent challenges in accurately predicting misclassifications for certain demographic minorities. Our findings suggest that no single paradigm provides the best results and that there is a real need for context-aware strategies in fairness-oriented social network analysis. We conclude that a multi-faceted approach, incorporating both individual attributes and network structures, is essential for reducing algorithmic bias and promoting inclusive decision-making. Journal: Computers in Human Behavior 1 Introduction Society can be thought of as a mixture of individuals, each holding and exchanging opinions when interacting. This complex system of opinion dynamics can sometimes start a revolution or, in most cases, simply agree or disagree on something. However, being able to predict people’s opinions is an important sociological challenge that is often needed in multiple situations: for instance, when introducing a legislative change in countries or designing urban spaces. Independent of the case, the complexity of this task is high, given that it involves multiple factors, the most important ones being the understanding of cognitive processes, opinion dynamics, and human interactions. This task is assessed in multiple ways, but often researchers overlook an important factor that has recently gained a lot of importance in the research of social network analysis: the aspect of fairness. In order to train an algorithm to accurately assess which opinion a person is going to have, a multitude of factors should be considered: their choice history, who that person has interacted with in the past, and, obviously, their attributes such as gender, age, or place of living. There is no one, clear-cut recipe on how to create an algorithm that will be able to anticipate future opinions of everyone, and each real-life case requires a deeper insight in order to identify outliers, non-conformists, and other hard-to-guess participants. However, it is generally the case that the more data we have of a certain group of people, the better we are able to train our models to work with such a group. At the foundation of this work lie three questions that we have asked: 1. When it comes to opinion prediction, are there any sub-groups for which algorithms perform better or worse? 2. Can we guess for whom an algorithm will more often mispredict? 3. Which of the following holds more predictive power in this regard: demographic or topological data of the users? The evolution of real-world social networks is generally affected by user homophily, which is a widespread tendency of people to contact others who are perceived as similar to themselves McPherson et al. (2001) . This may be due to personal bias, a product of one’s social bubble, or even the unfair influence of an algorithm affecting their choices. This homophilic tendency of a given model does not need to stem from the intentions of algorithm creators. Instead, it often results from the fact that the accuracy of the tools that we have is dependent on the size of the communities for which the model is trained. With this taken into account, one could ask the following question: Is it one’s demographic attributes or rather their place in the network that affects their likelihood of being systematically more misclassified by the model? Answering this question and identifying the factors that correlate most strongly with these mispredictions would make it possible to assess how fair or biased a given model is. It would also allow the discovery of any potential vulnerabilities that the given algorithm is prone to. Therefore, the goal of this work is to construct a transparent framework that would allow such an assessment of the model’s misclassification bias and to establish whether it skews more towards demographic or topological factors of the affected people. Moreover, it would be beneficial to distinguish whether the type of survey question for which the opinion is predicted affects how different minorities are affected, or whether, and compare the results with the general population. However, the results obtained throughout this work indicate that in the context of predicting which factors are likely to play the most significant role in the model’s discriminative behaviour, there is no one answer that is likely to hold true for each type of minority. It appears that consistently both the considered subgroup and the very nature of the question for which an answer is being predicted play a relevant role in predicting when the dip in the opinion classifier’s performance is going to occur. This work has been structured into eight sections, together with an additional appendix section at the end of the document. The following - Section 2 focuses on the discussion of works within the field of Fair Social Network Analysis, which have been foundational to the creation of this research. Section 3 delves into the details of the CoDiNG model, which served as the basis for the tests conducted. Section 4 focuses on the structure and insights of the NetSense dataset and the definitions for consecutive minorities. It also contains baseline observations derived from the CoDiNG experiment dataset. Section 5 contains the description of our framework’s architecture and insights from the process of classifiers’ training. Then, Section 6 describes the results of the experiments. Next, Section 7 focuses on the discussion of the obtained results. Finally, Section 8 summarizes the findings of our work, discusses them in the context of fair opinion dynamics, and considers future avenues for this line of research. The following section will focus on the overview of other works that delve into the problem of fairness and opinion dynamics in the context of SNA, together with

Read the complete text