Real-time Gravitational Wave Response in Thermal Spinning fields

and Yuhang Zhu · 2026

Read Real-time Gravitational Wave Response in Thermal Spinning fields by and Yuhang Zhu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-03631.txt.

Introduction

Atsuhisa Ota, Hui-Yu Zhu, and Yuhang Zhu ask whether the spin of particles filling the early universe leaves a mark on passing gravitational waves. In a radiation-dominated cosmos, hot plasma made of scalar, fermion, or light-like fields could damp waves or shift their phase depending on spin. The team revisits the question with real-time quantum field theory, splitting the stress tensor into background, response, and contact parts.

They find a spin-dependent response that acts on a short time scale set by the plasma temperature. Local contact terms cancel it exactly. What remains at long times is universal and matches kinetic theory, so no observable imprint of spin survives. The cancellation is a tidy example of how microscopic detail can vanish from cosmic-scale predictions.

Catalog record

CREATORand Yuhang Zhu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-03631

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Real-time Gravitational Wave Response in Thermal Spinning fields and Yuhang Zhu Abstract We study how the spin content of the thermal plasmas affects the propagation of gravitational waves in a radiation-dominated universe. As a simple but representative setup, we consider conformal scalar, Weyl fermion, and Maxwell fields that provide the background radiation, and we ask whether the resulting damping and phase shift of gravitational waves retain any memory of their spins. We revisit this question in a real-time quantum-field-theoretic framework, where the stress tensor splits into a background part, a dynamical (history-dependent) response, and local contact terms, with an additional on-shell projection fixed by the Friedmann equation. We find that the dynamical spin-dependent response arises on a short time scale characterized by the radiation temperature, which is exactly canceled by the local responses. As a result, the remaining long-time response is universal and consistent with kinetic theory in the hard thermal limit. Although the underlying mechanism exhibits strong spin dependence, it leaves no observable imprint on the large-scale effective dynamics of gravitational waves in this setup. 1 Introduction It has long been known that a thermal medium can influence the propagation of quantum fields [ 3 , 27 ] . A particularly well-developed example is the hard thermal loop (HTL) theory of gauge fields, which provides an effective description of how the thermal medium modifies long-wavelength field propagation [ 7 , 24 , 6 , 8 , 39 ] . In the soft limit of the external gauge field, the HTL self-energy obtained in thermal quantum field theory agrees with the prediction of classical linear response based on collisionless kinetic theory [ 4 , 26 , 5 ] . Gravitational analogues have also been studied in the thermal Minkowski limit [ 38 , 9 , 11 , 10 , 30 ] . This line of work has established the structure of the thermal graviton HTL in the Euclidean framework, but with a few exceptions, it has been restricted to minimally coupled scalar fields [ 18 ] . The kinetic counterpart of the gravitational HTL is particularly well suited to cosmology. In this approach, developed by Weinberg [ 41 ] and by Rebhan and Schwarz [ 37 ] , the effective dynamics of long-wavelength gravitational waves propagating in a thermal medium can be obtained by solving a nonlocal integro-differential equation. The anisotropic stress is history-dependent and proportional to the number of on-shell degrees of freedom. By using the background Friedmann equation, the explicit dependence on particle spin can be removed, so that the induced stress takes a universal form in an evolving background. More recently, real-time analyses based on the in-in formalism [ 42 , 2 ] have been applied to gravitons propagating on a time-dependent, radiation-dominated background [ 33 , 25 , 35 , 34 ] . In this framework, one directly computes the gravitational-wave power spectrum in the operator formalism, and finds the existence of tachyonic mass terms as well as secular growth. However, symmetry arguments show that such pathologies can be removed once the constraints of general covariance are implemented correctly [ 36 ] . As emphasized in this line of work, the effects of thermalized spinning particles on the propagation of gravitational waves are reduced to computing the thermal expectation value of unequal-time stress tensor commutation relation. As has been widely noticed in the literature on Weyl anomalies, the expectation values of the stress tensors depend strongly on the spin content of the underlying quantum fields [ 17 , 13 , 12 , 15 , 21 , 20 , 31 , 22 , 14 ] . In conformal field theory (CFT), for instance, the two-point function of the stress tensor is almost completely fixed by symmetry. Its dynamical tensorial structure is universal and does not depend on the spin of the fields, while its overall coefficient, usually denoted C_{T} , is a spin-dependent constant. Although the zero-temperature result cannot simply be extrapolated to finite temperature, it suggests that the dependence on spin resides entirely in an overall coefficient of the response and not in the detailed dynamical structures. Indeed, explicit calculations show that stress tensor correlators for thermal spinning fields contain similar spin structures in a short-time response. This CFT argument is, in practice, relevant to the gravitational-wave response in a radiation-dominated universe. One might therefore expect that, even at finite temperature, the linear response of the stress tensor would inherit the same dependence on spin. This appears to be at odds with the kinetic descriptions, which predict a universal, spin-independent nonlocal response once the background Friedmann equations are used. Is this a failure of kinetic theory, or does thermal quantum field theory itself reproduce the kinetic prediction in a nontrivial way? In this paper we address this question in a concrete setting. We consider thermal field theories of spin 0, spin 1/2, and spin 1 fields, and compute the real-time linear response of the stress tensor to a gravitational-wave perturbation. Working directly in the in-in formalism, we derive the graviton self-energy in the dynamical background driven by the thermal fields themselves. We show that the nonlocal part of the response, which governs the history-dependent damping and phase shift of primordial gravitational waves, agrees with the universal result of kinetic theory and is independent of spin. This is because the expected spin dependence associated with C_{T} , which resides in the short-time response even at finite temperature, is exactly canceled by other local contributions. 2 Basic setup and summary of the results In this work, we examine the effective dynamics of gravitational waves in a radiation-dominated universe including thermal self-energy. In particular, we are interested in cases where thermal fields with spin account for the thermal radiation and propagate in hard loops of the graviton self-energy in the expanding universe. In this section, we provide a brief introduction to the setup and a quick summary of the results. 2.1 Setup We write the perturbed FLRW metric as \displaystyle g^{\mu\nu}=a^{-2}(\eta^{\mu\nu}+\kappa h^{\mu\nu})~. (2.1) with the gravitational coupling \kappa=\sqrt{32\pi G}=2/M_{\rm{pl}} . h^{\mu\nu} is regarded as a tensor field in the background spacetime, and its indices are raised and lowered using the flat spacetime metric. We use this convention because the Jacobian for the change of variables g^{\mu\nu}\to h^{\mu\nu} is trivial: \displaystyle\frac{\delta}{\delta g^{\mu\nu}}\propto\frac{\delta}{\delta h^{\mu\nu}}~. (2.2) Consider a conformal scalar field (spin 0), a Weyl fermion (spin 1/2), and a Maxwell field (spin 1) that sustain a radiation-dominated universe, while gravity is described by general relativity. We expand the action in powers of \kappa and use interaction-picture perturbation theory for the gravitational wave dynamics. For simplicity, we assume a collisionless plasma, meaning that we consider only interactions between the quantum fields and the gravitational waves. Interactions among the quantum fields themselves are ignored, and thermal states are introduced through an initial thermal ensemble. In this sense, our setup is not hydrodynamical and follows the typical setup in HTL analyses. In practice, our setting is well suited to describing relic radiation after decoupling, such as cosmic neutrinos. The effective equation of motion for h_{\mu\nu}=\eta_{\mu\alpha}\eta_{\nu\beta}h^{\alpha\beta} is obtained by linearizing the Einstein equations \displaystyle G_{\mu\nu}=\frac{\kappa^{2}}{4}T_{\mu\nu}, (2.3) where G_{\mu\nu} is the Einstein tensor and T_{\mu\nu} is the effective stress tensor obtained after integrating out UV degrees

Read the complete text