Evolution of Plastic Dispersal in Stable Environment: Local Information of Fitness Consequence
Wayne Liang, Rufus Johnstone · 2026
Read Evolution of Plastic Dispersal in Stable Environment: Local Information of Fitness Consequence by Wayne Liang, Rufus Johnstone (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-03619.txt.
Introduction
Wayne Liang and Rufus Johnstone ask how an organism can wisely choose whether to disperse when the payoff depends on the whole landscape. An animal or seed deciding to move cannot know which patches are open or what travel will cost. That missing information troubles both the organism and scientists, who normally must measure vast areas or assume them away.
The pair proposes a link between local demographic processes, which an organism can sense nearby, and the fitness payoff of leaving. If local cues carry that information, then plastic dispersal, meaning movement rules that adjust to conditions, can evolve on complex landscapes. Their approach also gives empiricists a cheaper way to study adaptiveness, using local measurements instead of landscape-wide surveys.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wayne Liang, Rufus Johnstone |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-03619
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evolution of Plastic Dispersal in Stable Environment: Local Information of Fitness Consequence Wayne Liang, Rufus Johnstone Abstract Fitness consequence of dispersal depends on property of the entire landscape, which patches are available and what are the cost of moving. These are information that are not available locally when an organism make the decision to disperse. This poses a problem to the organism, where it is unclear how an adaptive decision can be made. This also poses a problem to the scientist, since in order to study the adaptiveness of dispersal, we need information of the entire landscape. For theorist, this is through making a series of assumption about either the landscape or the organism, and for empiricists, this means a large amount of measurements needs to be made across a large area. In this paper, we propose a link between local demographic process, which an organism can have access to, to the fitness consequence of dispersal. This meant local environmental cue can be used for the decision on dispersal, and hence allow the evolution of plastic dispersal strategy. We will then show that using this approach, evolution of dispersal on complex landscape can be modelled with relative ease, and to show that accidental dispersal in one patch can drive the evolution of adaptive dispersal in another. 1 Introduction Dispersal is an important trait that interacts with various aspect of biological evolution. It determines the pattern of gene flow allowing or restricting local adaptation ( 16 ) , changes relatedness structure and hence effects social evolution ( 38 ; 9 ) , and alters population dynamics, affecting the persistence of the population ( 33 ) . Due to its central importance, it has long been a subject of theoretical investigation, which have made clear that dispersal generates strategic feedbacks: an individual’s optimal dispersal decision both depends on, and alters, the dispersal environment experienced by others. For example, Hamilton and May have shown that the evolution of dispersal can be shaped by kin selection ( 17 ) , while other models have shown that dispersal is disfavored in the absence of temporal heterogeneity even with spatial variation ( 18 ) , but favored under changing environmental conditions ( 29 ; 30 ) . Taken together, these studies show that the evolution of dispersal is inherently frequency-dependent, with the fitness consequences of individual dispersal decisions shaped by the dispersal behaviour of others and by environmental variability.. For a decision on dispersal to be adaptive, it must on average provide fitness benefit to the decision maker. However, since dispersal is a choice between staying locally or moving to somewhere else in space, for the decision to be reliable it requires the focal individual to have information about the global environment. A similar constraint works for scientists as well: for a theorist, to solve for the optimal dispersal pattern requires global information about the metapopulation. Consequently, in order for models to remain tractable, modellers must often make strong assumptions of global homogeneity or symmetry. And for a empiricist, it is necessary to monitor across a large landscape to discern the fitness consequence of dispersal. To deal with these issues, theorists have mainly resorted to two approaches. Firstly, to let the disperser be omniscient ( 12 ) , or at least allow them to sample patches with very small costs ( 28 ; 11 ) , these are the ideal-free-distribution models. On the other hand, another approach is to let the environment be constant over an evolutionary timescale (e.g. 36 ) , or at least to assume that the pattern of environmental change is constant (e.g. 6 ) . This renders the environment predictable, so that selection favours genotypes that act "as if" they are aware of the pattern of change. Whilst these methods have been applied with great success, assumption of low-cost sampling and environmental stability over evolutionary timescales limits the scope of natural systems to which the theory can be applied to. Furthermore, the need for simplifying assumptions of global symmetry means that most theoretical models must work with extremely simplified landscapes. In this chapter, I aim to develop a model of dispersal that requires only stability in the demographic timescale, which could well be within a single generation and does not require the stability over evolutionary timescale as is often presumed. I will show that there is sufficient information in the local demographic processes to determine the fitness consequence of dispersal. The benefit is three folds: Firstly and most importantly, this shows there are sufficient environmental cue locally for a plastic dispersal strategy to evolve, allowing different probability of dispersal in different patches following the same reaction norm. Secondly, this is a new tool for modelling. Since optimal dispersal strategies can be determined by local population attributes, models can be greatly simplified, and consequently, much more realistic assumptions about the landscape and the mode of dispersal can be made. Lastly, if the theoretical result is validated empirically, cost of measuring the fitness consequence of dispersal would be greatly reduced, since one need only measure rate of movement into and out of the focal patch, without the need to track individuals across the landscape. We would first illustrate the approach through a simplified model. First, we will show that the fitness consequence of dispersal from a patch can be directly inferred from the local rate of immigration and emigration. Secondly, we will show how individuals can detect the fitness consequence of dispersal through knowledge of local population growth rate. In the third section, we will show the power of this modelling framework, through modelling evolution of dispersal in complex landscape. We will also show how accidental dispersal can drive the evolution of adaptive dispersal, even in the absent of kin selection and temporal heterogeneity, in contrast with previous results ( 18 ; 30 ) . Lastly, we will show how kin selection can be incorporated into this modelling framework. 2 Models 2.1 Taster Model To illustrate the general approach, an island model is built where the within-patch dynamic is the same as those in 36 but the assumptions about global parameters are relaxed. Specifically, we assume that for a focal patch, there are N breeding site, and for each adult who occupies a breeding site, they produce c offspring. Some of these offspring then disperse with probability d resulting in Ncd=\mathbf{o} emigrants, and the patch receive a total number of \mathbf{i} juvenile immigrants. All the adults then dies, with the juveniles competing for the breeding site equally. Those juveniles that does not win a breeding site dies. The only assumption about the global property is that the population dynamics has reached an steady state so that reproductive value of each class is well defined. 2.2 General Model Suppose that there are a number of N patches, each with their internal dynamics. Suppose that given a plastic dispersal strategy, it is possible to write the population dynamic as: \displaystyle\mathbf{n}_{t+1}=M\mathbf{n}_{t} (1) where the i^{th} index of \mathbf{n}_{t} is the population size of patch i at time t . Suppose that M is both ergodic and positive semidefinite. The diagonal entries of the matrix M thus represents the internal dynamic of each patches, and the off-diagonal entries