Fast and slow surfactants in turbulent bubble breakup
Zhan Wu, Tristan Aurégan, Luc Deike · 2026
Read Fast and slow surfactants in turbulent bubble breakup by Zhan Wu, Tristan Aurégan, Luc Deike (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-03157.txt.
Introduction
Zhan Wu, Tristan Aurégan, and Luc Deike study how bubbles multiply when a large air cavity is torn apart by turbulence, and how surfactants change the outcome. A breaking cavity stretches into filaments and sheds bubbles across a wide range of sizes, at rates set by turbulence and surface tension. In their experiments, adding surfactant or salt sometimes produced five times as many bubbles.
For bubbles larger than the Hinze scale, where turbulence and surface tension balance, the size distribution stayed the same for every solution tested. Below that scale, surfactants and salt increased bubble counts and steepened the distribution. The effect appeared only for surfactants that adsorb fast enough. They must adsorb faster than turbulence creates new surface. That timing condition explains the fast and slow surfactants of the title.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhan Wu, Tristan Aurégan, Luc Deike |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-03157
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Fast and slow surfactants in turbulent bubble breakup Zhan Wu, Tristan Aurégan, Luc Deike Abstract When a large air cavity breaks in a turbulent flow, it goes through very large deformations and cascading events of new interface formation, including elongated filaments and bubbles over a wide range of scales, with their rate of formation controlled by turbulence and capillary processes. We experimentally investigate the effects of surfactants and salt on the fragmentation, and observe an order of magnitude increase of the number of bubbles being produced in some cases. For bubbles larger than the Hinze scale d H d_{H} (defined as the balance between surface tension and turbulence stresses), we observe that bubble size distributions remain unchanged for all solutions tested. For bubbles below d H d_{H} , however, we observe an increase of the number of bubbles produced and an associated steepening of the bubble size distribution upon the addition of surfactant or salt. This later effect is only visible for some of the surfactants tested when their adsorption timescale is fast enough compared to the rate at which new interfaces are being generated by turbulence. 1 Introduction Gas bubbles dispersed in turbulent flows play a crucial role in mediating the transfer of mass and energy across interfaces. At the ocean surface the bursting of bubbles produces sea spray aerosols ( Deike, 2022 ; Deike et al., 2022 ; Cochran et al., 2017 ) , influencing atmospheric and climate processes, while bubbles entrained underwater break ( Deike et al., 2016 ; Deane and Stokes, 2002 ) and influence gas exchange ( Deike and Melville, 2018 ; Deike, 2022 ; Deike et al., 2025 ) . Underwater bubbles transport facilitates oil and gas migration from deep wells, while bubble breakup enhances gas dissolution through increased interfacial area and enhanced mixing in bubble column reactors ( Galinat et al., 2005 ; Risso, 2018 ) . In practical configurations, air-water interfaces are almost always contaminated by surface active agents (surfactants) related to biological or anthropogenic activities. The presence of surfactant modulates surface waves dynamics ( Erinin et al., 2023a ) , bubble rise velocity ( Takemura and Yabe, 1999 ; Tagawa et al., 2014 ; Farsoiya et al., 2024 ) , bubble bursting ( Eshima et al., 2025 ) , with surface tension gradients leading to Marangoni flows, as well as tip streaming leveraged in microfluidics devices to produce droplets ( Eggleton et al., 2001 ; Rubio and Montanero, 2023 ) . Another practical example of surfactant effects include oil-contaminated surfaces, where surfactants are used in mitigation strategies but also lead to chemical transport by aerosolization ( Sampath et al., 2019 ; Yang et al., 2023 ) . Beyond Marangoni effects, variations in surface tension and sorption kinetics also play important roles ( Fernández-Martínez et al., 2025 ) , and comparison between the time scale of adsorption/desorption of surfactant molecules with the characteristic time scale of the flow of interest becomes necessary. A comprehensive understanding of surfactant-mediated bubble behavior is essential for both mitigating environmental impacts of marine pollution and optimizing industrial processes involving gas–liquid interactions. In this letter, we consider the effect of surfactant on bubble break-up. Bubble fragmentation under breaking waves or in turbulent flows has been widely investigated through both experiments ( Deane and Stokes, 2002 ; Ruth et al., 2022 ; Ni, 2024 ) and numerical approaches ( Deike et al., 2016 ; Mostert et al., 2022 ; Rivière et al., 2021 ; Rivière et al., 2022 ) . Some numerical studies have probed the effect of surfactants in two-phase turbulence ( Soligo et al., 2019 ; Cannon et al., 2024 ) , and a few experiments investigated the role of salt in bubbly flows ( Blaauw et al., 2025 ) , but to the best of our knowledge, no systematic studies on the role of surfactants on the distribution of bubbles in turbulence exist. Bubble breakup in turbulence is initially understood by considering the competition between inertial stresses from turbulence that promote fragmentation and surface tension forces that resist it. The Weber number, \text{We}=\rho U^{2}d/\gamma , which compares these two effects, is commonly used to characterize bubble breakup conditions. Here, d is the bubble’s volume-equivalent diameter, U a characteristic velocity defined as the average velocity difference at the bubble-diameter scale, \rho the liquid density, and \gamma_{s} the surface tension. For bubbles within the inertial subrange, the square of the characteristic velocity at the bubble scale is 2\epsilon^{2/3}d^{2/3} , leading to \text{We}=2\rho\epsilon^{2/3}d^{5/3}/{\gamma} Rivière et al., 2021 . A critical Weber number We_{c} provides the balance between inertial and surface tension forces, serves as a loose bubble breakup criterion and is of order unity ( Martínez-Bazán et al., 1999 ; Vejrazka et al., 2018 ; Rivière et al., 2021 ) . The associated length scale is the Hinze scale, d_{H} ( Hinze, 1955 ) : d_{H}=\left(\frac{We_{c}}{2}\right)^{3/5}\left(\frac{\gamma_{s}}{\rho}\right)^{3/5}\epsilon^{-2/5}, (1) which separates the super-Hinze regime ( d>d_{H} ) which will break due to turbulence, from the sub-Hinze regime ( d<d_{H} ). The critical Weber number or Hinze scale is a soft threshold due to the inherent stochasticity of turbulent flows. The super-Hinze bubble size distribution in turbulence or under breaking waves has been described by \mathcal{N}(d)\propto d^{-10/3} , explained by a turbulent break-up cascade, controlled by the eddy turn over time at the scale of the bubble T_{\text{eddy}}(d)=\epsilon^{-1/3}d^{2/3} ( Garrett et al., 2000 ) . In contrast, the sub-Hinze bubble size distribution exhibits a gentler slope, following \mathcal{N}(d)\propto d^{-3/2} , which can be explained by a capillary break-up process related to large bubbles experiencing large deformation and the formation of filaments which will then rupture in a time scale controlled by capillarity T_{\text{cap}}(d)=(2\sqrt{3})^{-1}\left(\rho/\gamma_{s}\right)^{1/2}d^{3/2} ( Rivière et al., 2022 ; Ruth et al., 2022 ) . Both regimes have been extensively documented through laboratory experiments ( Ruth et al., 2022 ; Deane and Stokes, 2002 ) and direct numerical simulations ( Mostert et al., 2022 ; Rivière et al., 2022 ) . The formation of such broad size distribution from an initial air cavity occurs through a sequence of events controlled by the turbulent and capillary time scales, with new interfaces formed along the way. Figure 1 (a) illustrates the time scales of bubble break-up in turbulence as a function of bubble size d , using the integral length scale and turbulent dissipation rate estimated in our laboratory experiments. The lengths are normalized by the integral length scale L_{\rm int} , corresponding to the length scale of the larges eddies ( \approx 1 cm) and the times are normalized by the associated integral timescale ( T_{\rm int}\approx 40 ms). When using surfactants, we now have to consider their relevant time scales and how they compare to capillary and turbulence times which will control break-up and deformation. Marangoni stresses related to gradients in surfactant concentration along the interface will occur on capillary time scales. However, the presence and amount of surfactant on a newly formed interface within a sequence of break-up events will be related to the surfactant adsorption time \tau_{\rm ads} , which controls how fast surfactant in the bulk will make it to the interface ( Manikantan and Squires, 2020 ) . As we will demonstrate experimentally, surfactant will influence the multi-scale